As UPMC prepared for the January 2010 closing of its hospital in Braddock, a spokesman cited declining utilization as “the key driver” in the decision.
Two and a half years later, UPMC opened a new $250 million hospital — UPMC East in Monroeville — about two miles from the competing Forbes Regional Hospital and less than 10 miles from the Braddock site.
But in its first two years of operation, UPMC East has yet to match UPMC Braddock’s occupancy rate: According to state health department records, nearly 70 percent of Braddock’s beds were in use in the hospital’s last two full years of operation, while UPMC East’s occupancy rates have been closer to 60 percent.
UPMC spokeswoman Susan Manko said the state’s occupancy rate numbers do not reflect reality, as the data does not include the outpatient observations that have become more prevalent everywhere in recent years. Combining inpatient admissions and observations, UPMC East’s occupancy during that period was 83 percent, she said.
“East has always been busting at the seams, exceeding our expectations.”
Yet Stephen Foreman, a health care administration professor at Robert Morris University, believes the numbers undercut the contention that UPMC Braddock was closed because people weren’t using it.

(Click image for larger version)
“If it had been underutilized and making money, they would have kept it open. It would have been irrational not to,” he said.
Business decisions
This month’s release of individual hospitals’ finances by the independent Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council (HC4) shows how UPMC has prospered by closing its hospital in Braddock and opening a new one in Monroeville.
In its first two years, the Monroeville facility doubled Braddock’s patient revenue, apparently to the detriment of neighboring Forbes Hospital. UPMC East also saw a positive operating margin last fiscal year, something UPMC Braddock hadn’t accomplished since 2003.
The key has been Monroeville’s more prosperous socioeconomic demographic.
By closing UPMC Braddock and opening UPMC East, the Pittsburgh health care provider now has a hospital in which the percentage of uncompensated care has been cut in half, and UPMC East treats only a fraction of the patients receiving medical assistance that Braddock did, according to the HC4 analysis.
Ms. Manko, however, said actual dollar amounts spent on uncompensated care “are very similar” at the two hospitals, while acknowledging that Braddock spent about $3.5 million more than UPMC East in medical assistance.
She said UPMC East provided $7.7 million in community benefits in fiscal 2014, “$6.9 million of which was free and reduced cost care.” She said UPMC also still provides some services in the Braddock area, such as a mobile dental center and a mobile clinic for pediatric primary care and immunizations.
The controversial closing of the only hospital in a struggling Braddock followed closely by the construction of a new hospital in more affluent Monroeville have been closely tied in the minds of many community activists.
UPMC has always maintained that two events were unrelated; that UPMC East was necessary to ease overcrowding at UPMC Shadyside and UPMC Presbyterian.
Mr. Foreman agrees the moves likely were unrelated.
“On the surface, it looks like they moved a facility from a fairly poor area to a facility in a wealthier area, but they’re two different business decisions,” he said.
UPMC was not obligated to keep a money-losing hospital open, Mr. Foreman said, although because of the heath system’s charitable, tax-exempt status, “you would like to think” it would.
From an economic standpoint, he said, opening UPMC East “is purely strategic conduct” meant to draw patients from a competitor.
It has worked, too, at least initially.
Competition
According to the HC4 report, Forbes has seen net patient revenue fall from $195 million the two years prior to UPMC East’s opening to $92 million in fiscal 2014.
Allegheny Health Network spokesman Dan Laurent said Forbes’ total patient volume, both inpatient and outpatient, fell 6.2 percent after UPMC East opened and emergency department volume dropped 20 percent.
“We’ve regained most of that last volume over the last 15 months,” he said, but he minced no words about the impact of opening UPMC East, calling it “nothing more than a blatant and costly duplication of medical services in a community that has been well served by Forbes Hospital for more than three decades.
“The clear intent was to weaken Forbes, as well as other independent providers located east of the city.”
After UPMC Braddock closed in early 2010, the town was left without an emergency care facility until Highmark Health and the Allegheny Health Network opened an urgent care center on Braddock Avenue in January.
“To me, a perfect metaphor is a really nasty divorce,” said Braddock Mayor John Fetterman. “[UPMC] found a much younger partner in the new hospital, and we found Highmark. We have a nice urgent care center; they take Medicare and Medicaid, and you don’t have to sit in the waiting room for hours.”
The urgent care center has spurred development in Braddock’s downtown, he said, with new housing and a revitalized business district.
“I would never go through those five years again,” he continued, “but, in retrospect, Braddock has emerged better, stronger in every metric in terms of quality and access to health care. There isn’t a community that has bounced back as strongly as Braddock.”
The community, he said, “has moved on” from the emotional upheaval of losing its hospital, although he offered that the episode raised still-unanswered questions about the role of charitable, tax-exempt organizations.
“What’s the mission? Is it a business? Is it nonprofit? Is it a mix? I think Highmark has the right mix,” he said.
As for UPMC, he said simply, “moving out of Braddock was a great business decision.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.