HARRISBURG — At the end of a 10-hour hearing Wednesday, the judge asked attorneys for UPMC and Highmark if they could negotiate the question of access to the UPMC hospital network for Highmark Medicare Advantage customers in 2016.

“Is there a possibility of working this out, or are we in a blood feud, rather than an economic feud?” Commonwealth Court President Judge Dan Pellegrini asked. “I believe you can always work out money.”

With that, the representatives of UPMC and Highmark, nearly all of them men in dark suits, huddled on either side of the courtroom.

Then, W. Thomas McGough, UPMC’s chief legal officer, reported that only the system’s board of directors could make that decision, and that a past offer had been rejected. Daniel Booker, an attorney for Highmark, said he agreed: “There is no agreement to be reached here.”

Advertise with us

Judge Pellegrini told the parties it was their choice. And he suggested an uncertain future for the so-called consent decrees with the state that set rules for the breakup of the two Pittsburgh health organizations.

“These are terrible agreements,” he said. “If I can’t make sense out of them, I will throw out these agreements and we’ll go to trial.”

However the judge rules on UPMC access for the Medicare Advantage customers, Highmark would like him to do it quickly.

That’s because while the Medicare open-enrollment period — during which time Medicare beneficiaries can switch plans — doesn’t begin until Oct. 15, Highmark must submit its plan prices and associated provider networks in a matter of days.

By June 1, Highmark must submit its proposed Medicare Advantage plans and premium schedules to the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, which vets privately administered plans.

Advertise with us

The networks attached to those bids — the listing of which doctors and hospitals are in-network for those plans, and which ones aren’t — must be prepared by June 12, according to Highmark.

Insurers then get CMS approval for those plans around mid-August. As a result of those impending deadlines, “we anticipate clarity around this issue” shortly, said Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger.

After hours of arguments Wednesday and the rejection of his invitation to negotiate, Judge Pellegrini declined to put a deadline on his ruling on the legality of UPMC’s decision to sever its Medicare Advantage contract with Highmark.

“You’ll get it when you get it,” he said.

The contract gives Highmark’s Medicare customers in-network access to the UPMC hospital system. Highmark has about 182,000 Medicare Advantage customers in Western Pennsylvania, but that number would drop if Highmark lost all access to UPMC hospitals.

Advertise with us

UPMC begged out of the contract, it said, primarily because Highmark decided last year to dramatically reduce the amount of money it pays to UPMC for oncology services, even though Medicare rules allow UPMC to charge higher rates.

UPMC told Highmark in February that it intended to cut off Medicare Advantage access; in April, the state intervened, filing a complaint with the Commonwealth Court that said UPMC, in severing the Medicare contract, had violated the 2014 consent decree between the two Pittsburgh health organizations. The state also said that it aimed to force both companies into binding arbitration to resolve outstanding pricing and billing issues.

James Donahue, executive deputy attorney general for public protection, said Wednesday that the hearing would not have been necessary if UPMC and Highmark had spoken to one another during the formation of the so-called consent decrees governing their breakup.

“They created this problem by not speaking with Highmark in the first place,” Mr. Donahue said of UPMC.

Mickey Pohl, an attorney for UPMC, said the hearing was about whether UPMC would be found in contempt for a violation of the consent decree. He said it should not be.

Advertise with us

“There’s a pretty high bar to hold someone in contempt,” he said.

In a May 12 filing with the court, UPMC said it was within its rights to back out of the Highmark Medicare Advantage contract, offering a variety of reasons for why this is so, including the ongoing oncology dispute.

But Highmark, in a court filing dated May 19, said that UPMC’s various rationale are legal sleight of hand: “This is a simple case in which the only issue is whether UPMC is authorized under its consent decree with the Commonwealth to walk away from the commitments it made [to] treat Medicare Advantage customers ... [and] to serve Medicare Advantage participating consumers, [UPMC] must have a contract with Highmark.”

Medicare is the federally subsidized health insurance plan for senior citizens. Medicare Advantage plans are Medicare plans and networks assembled by private insurers.

Karen Langley: klangley@post-gazette.com, 1-717-787-2141 or on Twitter @karen_langley. Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625.