Even with his own front-row seat for the negotiations, U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy was surprised by the speed and ease with which a proposed Medicare overhaul navigated his chamber this week.
“A week ago, I’m not sure I would have told you we had the votes for this,” Mr. Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, said of the legislation, which would create a new payment formula for doctors and charge higher premiums to some Medicare beneficiaries.
But by Thursday, those votes materialized — and then some, to the surprise of congressional observers or anyone else who has watched the House and Senate over the last few years. The legislation, approved by an overwhelming House vote of 392-37, now moves to the Senate, which could take it up in April, following a brief recess.
Mr. Murphy, formerly a practicing psychologist, said the discussions about the Medicare overhaul, and the new payment formula therein, had become “all-consuming.” That’s because Congress was facing a March 31 deadline to either fix the formula or kick the can down the road a few more months.
The can, in this case, is a quirk built into the current Medicare funding formula called the “sustainable growth rate,” or SGR, which links a doctor’s Medicare reimbursement rate to larger economic factors such as overall health care costs and inflation.
The SGR was built into a 1997 law, and the equation, which is designed to periodically recalibrate payments to physicians, worked for a few years. But for the last decade, the equation has been calculating substantial cuts to doctors’ Medicare payments. This year, the cut is supposed to be 21 percent.
But the automatic reductions have never been put into place, because each time those cuts are due, Congress approves a temporary end-around that keeps physician pay where it is. That’s happened 17 times in a row, to the frustration of physicians.
It’s hard enough to run a small business — but try doing it, doctors say, when year after year there’s a massive revenue cut dangling over your head.
“Makes it tough to budget,” said Dennis Olmstead, chief strategy officer and medical economist at the Pennsylvania Medical Society. Even though the cuts were never enacted, the regular threat of them makes it difficult for a practice to plan for staff raises or to forecast capital investments.
The impact on physicians varies from practice to practice — a pediatrician, naturally, has no Medicare patient load, and a geriatrician might deal almost exclusively with Medicare, which is the federal health insurance program for senior citizens. A typical primary care practice might have a patient load that is 60 or 70 percent Medicare beneficiaries, and that number continues to grow as younger patients take their business to urgent care centers.
The patches were also a frustration to lawmakers, Mr. Murphy said. That’s because everyone in Washington, D.C., knew that the “Medicare fix” was a must-pass patch — meaning a lot of extraneous spending was attached to the fixes.
“When the train’s leaving the station,” he said, “a lot of people want to get on board.” Mr. Murphy voted in favor of the SGR repeal bill — called the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015 — as did every other member of the Pennsylvania House delegation.
John Krah, executive director of the Allegheny County Medical Society, said local physicians are likewise on board with the fix as proposed by the House, but the devil is in the details — and one of the key details is that in exchange for annual 0.5 percent raises through 2019, a larger share of a physician’s Medicare payments will be tied to performance measures and health care outcomes, rather than sheer volume of service.
Seniors are less enthusiastic about the bill, which requires Medicare recipients with an income over $85,000 to pay higher Part B premiums for physicians services starting in 2018. The projected premium is minimal — about $10, according to the Congressional Budget Office — but AARP, which represents 37 million Americans over the age of 50, remains wary.
“We are concerned that Medicare beneficiaries will now face higher out-of-pocket costs, including higher premiums and reduced coverage,” AARP said in a statement. The proposal also limits Medigap access for new Medicare beneficiaries after 2020; Medigap policies are wrap-around health insurance policies, purchased from a private company, that pay for some of the costs not covered by Medicare coverage.
At the other end of the age spectrum, children’s advocates were pleased that Medicare extended the Children’s Health Insurance Program for two years, but they were hoping for four years of funding certainty. In Pennsylvania, about 151,000 children are covered under the state’s CHIP program.
“Congress is Congress,” said Bruce Lesley, president of First Focus, a Washington, D.C., family advocacy group. “The good news is, we got two years. The bad news is, it was only two years. We’re worried about what this means for CHIP in 2017.”
The bill also would steer $800 million for the Maternal, Infant, and Early-Childhood Home Visiting Program, a provision of the 2010 Affordable Care Act that benefits young mothers.
Although the bill won’t please everybody, including those seniors who may see higher premiums, the alternative was that fed-up doctors might have stopped accepting new Medicare patients, which would have reduced health care access across the board, Mr. Murphy said.
That’s why the agreement between House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, and Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., to negotiate a compromise was so crucial.
The blessing from leadership “really opened the door [to a] significant and permanent” solution, Mr. Murphy said. “People just worked together and got this done.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.