Will the state be weighing in on key provisions of last summer’s UPMC-Highmark consent decree?

Highmark president and CEO David Holmberg appeared to suggest that it would during a forum of local business leaders on Tuesday.

“What you can expect is some clarification from the state in the next 30 days, and with that clarity, people will be able to make some decisions based on what’s best for them,” Mr. Holmberg said.

However, a state insurance spokesman later seemed to play down that possibility.

Advertise with us

Mr. Holmberg’s remarks came at the Pittsburgh Business Group on Health’s annual health plan executive leadership forum at the Marriott Hotel, Downtown, a gathering that featured executives from the region’s leading insurers: Highmark, UPMC Health Plan, United HealthCare, Cigna and Aetna.

Mr. Holmberg said there have been 14,396 unpaid UPMC claims made since the Highmark-UPMC contract expired Jan. 1. That is out of 770,384 claims filed, with 723,574 going through the system without problem, 25,603 processed following a review and the remaining 6,811 — many of which were long-standing — paid “to do the right thing for the people.”

Regarding the unresolved claims, Mr. Holmberg said, “We’ve got to have clarity around what’s in and what’s out” of network.

The consent decree, an agreement reached by UPMC and Highmark in anticipation of their Jan. 1 contract expiration, sets out rules designed to protect consumers during the transition, including a one-year safety net that allows Highmark members to continue seeing their UPMC physicians through 2015.

One major provision in question addresses the circumstances in which Highmark members can continue seeing their UPMC physicians on an in-network basis until the consent decree expires in the summer of 2019.

Advertise with us

UPMC points to consent decree language that says the decision is left to the patients and their physician, a point UPMC spokesman Paul Wood reiterated Tuesday. The Pennsylvania Insurance Department “has already defined continuity of care as a patient-doctor decision. Period,” he said. “What’s to clarify?”

Highmark believes continuity of care only applies in serious illness situations, such as ongoing cancer treatment, a view shared by the administration of former Republican Gov. Tom Corbett but so far not directly addressed by Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf’s administration, other than to say it intends to enforce the consent decrees.

On Tuesday, Insurance Department spokesman Ron Ruman reiterated an earlier statement about enforcing the consent decree provisions: “That continues to be our position, and as we said then, as individual cases arise, these will help further define consumer protections.”

During the four-hour session, each executive emphasized his or her company’s particular strength. Mr. Holmberg said Highmark is offering choice and innovation as it builds its own integrated health care delivery network.

Diane Holder, president and CEO of UPMC Health Plan, pointed to efforts to standardize care and the recently announced Pittsburgh Health Data Alliance in which UPMC, the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University will share expertise to use data to improve health care and hold down costs.

Advertise with us

“We want to empower the primary care physicians with as much information as possible,” she said.

Daniel Tropeano, CEO of United HealthCare for Pennsylvania and Delaware, said his company has been able “to establish a nice foothold” in the local insurance market and recently added 75 more employees to handle the increased workload.

Brian McGarry of Aetna, meanwhile, said the insurer has fully integrated Coventry/​HealthAmerica into its operations and has added 18,000 names to the roles of its insured.

And Julia Huggins, Cigna’s regional general manager and president, said that while her company is something of an underdog in the local health insurance market, it enjoys a retention rate of existing clients above 95 percent “so when we engage a client, we keep them for many years.”