Nobody likes being in the hospital, but those who visit St. Clair Hospital seem to like it more than most.
The 329-bed hospital in Mt. Lebanon scored best among Allegheny County hospitals, and among those in suburban counties, when it came to the percentage of patients surveyed who said they would they would “definitely recommend the hospital” to somebody else (83 percent). It also received the highest overall satisfaction score, with 80 percent of those polled saying they would give the hospital a rating of 9 or 10, on a 1-10 scale.
The scores are collected by the hospitals themselves, by way of third-party vendors, and collated by the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, which since 2012 has been using the satisfaction scores to calculate how much money the hospitals in turn receive from Medicare.
While Medicare uses the grades to measure hospitals against each other, the hospitals can use the feedback to correct shortcomings, and to create a less stressful inpatient stay.
“Hospitalization is usually a scary experience,” whether the patient is admitted for an emergency or even an elective procedure, said Joan Massella, an administrative vice president and St. Clair’s chief nursing officer. “The patients are looking for someone to connect with, someone they can trust, [so they know that] their needs are being met.”
The emphasis on meeting those needs is one of the reasons St. Clair is among the top 2 percent of U.S. hospitals when it comes to the most recent round of patient experience scores, collected in 2013. Next month, CMS will issue a new batch of patient feedback grades, and for the first time it will use the feedback to assign star ratings for each hospital on each component of the satisfaction survey — 11 components in all — with five stars being the highest rating.
That’s good news for places such as St. Clair, which figures to rate well. But St. Clair’s rating also reinforces some of the perceived problems with the various CMS hospital metrics, particularly more subjective metrics such as hospital noise levels or room cleanliness — that hospitals in well-heeled, leafy suburbs generally tend to perform better than their urban, teaching hospital counterparts, and that it’s unfair to financially penalize a hospital for its location or its clientele.
For example, one of the worst performers in Allegheny County when it comes to overall satisfaction is UPMC Mercy, located in Uptown. But one of the best was UPMC’s brand new Monroeville facility, UPMC East.
Despite built-in handicaps for certain hospitals, “we don’t believe this is bad measurement,” said UPMC's chief quality officer Tami Minnier. Over time, she said, the survey questions will be refined, weeding out the ones that have less to do with quality of the clinicians.
Some grades, she said, “don’t matter as much, or [are] more driven by physical environment than the actual caregivers” and their treatment of the patients. UPMC Mercy, she noted, doesn’t have many private rooms. And “private rooms matter” to patients when they are reflecting on their hospital experience, Ms. Minnier said. But if a hospital doesn’t offer them, that will affect its survey scores.
System-wide, UPMC tries to block out the less meaningful metrics, and instead focus on “the softer stuff. Was someone nice to me? Did someone listen to me? ... What really is it that drives patient satisfaction?”
But that’s the problem — satisfaction is subjective, and varies from region to region, said Martin Ciccocioppo, vice president of research at the Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania.
“The northeastern part of the country does worse on” the satisfaction surveys than do hospitals in the south and southwest. “There’s no adjustment for any of that variation,” meaning northeastern hospitals are more likely to be penalized by Medicare right out of the gates.
CMS has been collecting the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems data since 2007. Medicare uses the satisfaction data as part of a larger equation, called the Hospital Value-Based Purchasing program, which links up to 6 percent of a hospital’s Medicare reimbursement to its quality-of-care scores. A hospital that scores well might receive hundreds of thousands in bonus Medicare money; those that do poorly, or aren’t improving, could lose out on a $1 million or more annually.
At this point, certain satisfaction survey trends seem set in stone: The busier the hospital, the worse it fares when it comes to patient satisfaction. “Hospital inpatient volume has a significant negative effect on all HCAHPS measures,” according to the Pennsylvania Health Care Quality Alliance. Non-teaching hospitals also score higher than teaching hospitals.
And while “ratings have slowly and steadily improved each year,” suggesting the hospitals are making strides, those strides occur in concert with the gains being made at other hospitals. So hospitals starting out in the bottom quintile of performers tend to stay there, and will be penalized for it.
As a result, a hospital’s survey rank against peers “is something that is hard to move,” Mr. Ciccocioppo said.
But even hospitals with built-in advantages must work hard to maintain their scores, Ms. Massella said.
In 2012, for example, St. Clair started training employees in a new clinical communications method (called AIDET, which means Acknowledge, Introduce, Duration, Explanation and Thank-You). And St. Clair also focuses on the trouble spots that appear on its experience score sheet.
“Noise is a challenge for us,” she said. “That’s one of our lowest scores.” (The survey asks patients whether the area surrounding their room is “always” quiet at night; St. Clair measured at 45 percent, one of the lowest marks in Allegheny County.) Some noise at night is unavoidable, such as medical alarms, but “we can control our voices at night. We can control some noises in the hallway. [And] how has do we respond to the alarms?”
While acknowledging that the perception of a hospital — the way it looks, it age, its neighborhood — can color a patient’s feedback, Ms. Massella said that “you can always find reasons to justify poor performance. The key is to really find ways to overcome them.”
Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.