When Joseph Guyaux left the Highmark Inc. boardroom in 2012, he didn’t slam the door behind him.

Rather, “it was the right time for me to focus on my full-time job,” he said. Mr. Guyaux, 64, a four-decade veteran of PNC Financial Services Group, had just been appointed to the newly created position of chief risk officer. PNC was still dealing with recession fallout and the implementation of Dodd–Frank financial reforms, and “I [knew] that I couldn’t handle both in the short run.”

That short run, evidently, is over. So when Highmark Health came calling in search of a replacement for outgoing board chairman president J. Robert Baum, Mr. Guyaux answered that call, even though he had been away from the board for more than two years.

Highmark announced the appointment Thursday.

Advertise with us

Like many of the region’s top corporate executives, Mr. Guyaux is a highly sought figure when it comes corporate and nonprofit board service. That’s because, at PNC, “we’ve always talked about [a] commitment to the communities in which we live and serve. And you do in that in different ways,” with board service being one of the most common ways, he said.

“When asked to serve, and when we think we can make a difference, we’re generally willing to do it.”

Mr. Guyaux is chairman of the board of directors for the Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera, a life trustee of the Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh (and has served as chairman of the natural history museum board), and he also sits on the boards of directors of DQE Holdings and the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust.

Those are all high-profile slots, but they are small potatoes compare to the board chairmanship at Highmark Health, a $16 billion company that is simultaneously one of the largest health insurers in the U.S., one of the country’s largest vision retailers and, as of 2011, the second-largest hospital operator in the Pittsburgh region. The board chairmanship, like all Highmark Health board appointments, is a paid position.

Like many observers of the perpetual drama between Highmark and UPMC, he said that he thinks the relationship between the two health care rivals could, and should, be improved.

Advertise with us

“I am still concerned [about] the environment, and where we are in Western Pennsylvania isn’t exactly where we would like to have it be,” said Mr. Guyaux, a lifelong resident of the Pittsburgh region, who grew up in Tarentum and now lives in Fox Chapel.

He noted that he is not good friends, but “more than an acquaintance,” to G. Nicholas Beckwith III, chairman of the board at UPMC. They both belong to the Fox Chapel Golf Club, and they are both Brown University graduates. And when PNC, then known as Pittsburgh National Bank, opened its first Murrysville branch back in the 1970s, Beckwith Machinery sat right across Route 22.

It’s not much common ground, but it’s something.

“Every area has its way,” Mr. Guyaux said. “In this area, [historical] relationships do have a lot to do with it. It doesn’t guarantee anything, but good relationships allow you to disagree and still get along.”

He said he expects to be in regular, though not day-to-day, contact with with Highmark Health CEO David Holmberg, and he said his role as board chairman is to provide guidance and oversight without actively steering the ship or “interfering with management ... my [communications] with Highmark executives will start and end with David Holmberg.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Guyaux exited the chief risk officer position this year and is now the senior vice chairman of PNC, and president and CEO officer of PNC’s mortgage division.

He had been with Highmark’s board from 2004 to August 2012.

In assuming the chairman’s role, he replaces Mr. Baum, who has been in the chairman’s seat since 2005, and who also served as the company’s interim chief executive officer for several months in 2012 after the firing of former CEO Kenneth Melani. Mr. Baum will continue to serve as a member of the board of directors at Highmark Health’s vision, dental and risk-management insurance groups.

Also Thursday, Highmark Health announced that the company’s current president and CEO, Mr. Holmberg, is the new chairman of the board of directors of Highmark Inc., the parent company’s insurance arm.