Highmark Inc. has fewer Medicare customers and employer-based subscribers than it did a year ago in Western Pennsylvania, in large part due to its ongoing, bruising battle with crosstown rival UPMC — but things could have been a lot worse, according to the Pittsburgh-based insurer’s CEO.
“There have been no real surprises,” said David Holmberg, Highmark’s chief executive since May 2014. “It was pretty clear what the challenges were. … The intensity of the competition [has] been fascinating. But what it’s doing is helping us sharpen our pencils and be smarter about what we do.”
Highmark, a Blue Cross Blue Shield insurer, released its 2015 enrollment figures Wednesday morning; it was the company’s first annual enrollment update to be issued since the Jan. 1 split between Highmark and UPMC.
That means this is the first year that businesses and individual insurance buyers under the age of 65 were forced to leave Highmark — for UPMC Health Plan, United Healthcare, Cigna or Aetna (or its Coventry subsidiary) — if they wanted to keep in-network access to all of UPMC’s hospitals.
For 2015, Highmark reported 1.14 million commercial members in the 29-county Western Pennsylvania market, down from 1.29 million in January 2014. And while the insurer added individual subscribers year over year, largely through the Affordable Care Act’s online marketplace, it lost a substantial chunk of its over-65 Medicare Advantage subscribers in this part of the state.
“We lost about 10 percent of our enrollment,” going from 203,000 to 182,000 Medicare subscribers, said Tim Lightner, vice president of senior markets and products. “The noise in the marketplace was probably a contributing factor, [but] we landed in a better place. We were ahead of plan.”
Read More
Across all of its markets, Highmark says it has 5.3 million health plan members, including in West Virginia and Delaware. It will add about 272,000 new members this spring or summer, once its planned acquisition of Blue Cross of Northeastern Pennsylvania takes effect.
Mr. Holmberg and Anthony Benevento, Highmark’s senior vice president of Pennsylvania markets, also noted that the insurer fared well when employers gave their employees a choice between two or more health plans. When an employer offered multiple carriers for 2015 — Highmark, plus one or more carriers that offer full UPMC access — Highmark retained 71 percent of those employees.
“They’re voting with their wallets, their pocketbooks and making their own choices,” Mr. Holmberg said.
As to whether 2015 might represent a cooling-off period for UPMC and Highmark, allowing the market to stabilize and patients to catch their breath, Mr. Holmberg has his doubts.
“I suspect that when the next open enrollment cycle happens, we’re going to go through another cycle of confusion. Because there are certainly people in the marketplace who want to create uncertainty — and it’s not us,” he said.
He was referring to UPMC, and recent dust-ups over whether certain claims would be paid for children and pregnant women who have Highmark insurance but received or sought care at a UPMC facility.
Mr. Holmberg said he had never been a part of, or heard of, a health care market where the dominant hospital network aired its claim-by-claim grievances so regularly.
“There’s not another market where patients and consumers are being bounced around” as they are in Pittsburgh, he said.
Other figures of note:
• About 420,000 members are enrolled in Highmark’s Community Blue policy line, a low-cost, no-UPMC plan offered in all of its major sales categories.
• Across its three-state territory, Highmark has about 343,000 individual enrollees in its ACA marketplace plans through Jan. 30, and 269,000 of them are in Pennsylvania; there are still two weeks left for those without insurance to purchase an individual plan via the marketplace.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.