It’s now Year Two of the Obamacare adventure for Pittsburgh-area health care consumers, and a couple of facts seem clear:
No. 1: Shoppers are happy with their individual coverage, purchased through the Affordable Care Act’s online marketplace.
No. 2: They are more than happy to change their coverage, if the price is right.
In Pittsburgh this year, that generally means leaving Highmark Inc. — which had the lowest prices in Western Pennsylvania for 2014 individual insurance policies — and jumping ship to UPMC Health Plan, which dramatically slashed its 2015 individual plan prices in an effort to capture more of the individual market and steer patients to its own UPMC hospitals and clinics in advance of the Highmark-UPMC breakup.
Anecdotally, the strategy worked. Official confirmation should come by way of enrollment numbers that will be released in coming days by Highmark and UPMC Health Plan.
But the only numbers that South Side resident Joe Lucas needed to see, when asked to renew his Highmark policy in late 2014, was the monthly premium quote: The Highmark price was rising to about $220 a month and the UPMC Health Plan price was dropping.
So, hoping to save money and continue seeing his UPMC cardiologist — who would now be out of network for Highmark customers, thanks to the UPMC-Highmark divorce — he switched.
Nothing against Highmark, though.
“I had no problems with it whatsoever,” the 52-year-old painter said. Mr. Lucas, who went without steady health insurance for much of his adult life, bought his Highmark coverage at the end of 2013 through the Affordable Care Act’s online marketplace.
After an initial technological snafu — when he first tried to navigate the HealthCare.gov marketplace, the site crashed, as it did for thousands more in those early roll-out days — he bought a plan. As of Jan. 1, 2014, he had private, subsidized health coverage for about $150 a month.
Verdict?
He didn’t use it much: One chiropractor visit a month, an appointment or two with a primary care physician, and four heart and blood-pressure medications. But even though he didn’t need it very often, he knew it would be there if he did.
“It's peace of mind,” he said. “When I had my aneurysm, I didn’t have any coverage.”
He’s talking about his Oct. 10, 2010, hospitalization with an aortic aneurysm. He spent 11 days in the hospital — without insurance — and walked out with a $69,000 bill. (Medicaid ended up paying the bulk of that bill.) Because of his heart condition, he then had a pre-existing health condition that meant insurers wouldn’t touch him.
Sam Morey, a 30-year-old from Bloomfield, also switched away from Highmark and into a UPMC Health Plan policy for 2015 when he learned his Highmark policy premium price would double over the 2014 price. But for Mr. Morey, who hadn’t had regular health coverage since 2008 before buying his 2014 policy, insurance was about more than peace of mind.
“It really opened a lot of doors for me, being able to get that plan,” he said. Based on his income level and his age, he was able to buy a Highmark “silver” level plan for about $21 a month, after federal subsidies were figured into the mix.
Because he hadn’t seen a physician in years, “I really tested my plan out in a lot of ways,” Mr. Morey said.
That test drive included a full physical, blood work, several prescriptions, and a diagnosis of sleep apnea. The diagnosis meant his sleep apnea breathing machine and mask were covered by insurance, after paying a deductible.
“That’s been a revelation or me. I’ve been much better rested,” he said. Having affordable health coverage meant he was “more willing to look into things that were bothering me, rather than just writing me off.” His new UPMC Health Plan policy, after federal subsidies, will cost about $20 a month.
It’s a similar story for Barbara Valaw, 54, of Carrick.
Ms. Valaw, who is self-employed and makes too much to qualify for an ACA subsidy, bought a 2014 Highmark plan for about $454 a month. That was a considerable savings over the $600 she had been paying each month for COBRA coverage (that is, health coverage made available for purchase through her previous employer, even though she no longer works there).
She had, for a time, also bought an individual policy outside of COBRA, but that policy didn’t offer prescription benefits. The ACA plan through Highmark did, and her arthritis medication was more affordable as a result.
“That actually saved me a couple thousand dollars a year on prescriptions,” Ms. Valaw said.
But like the others, when renewal time came around, UPMC Health Plan’s rock-bottom prices were too good to pass up.
While her Highmark premiums would have gone up had she stayed in the same plan, the UPMC plan she chose had premiums of $360 a month, plus a lower deductible, lower co-insurance rate and a lower out-of-pocket cap than the comparable Highmark policy.
She’s already using her new UPMC Health Plan to treat and rehabilitate an injured Achilles tendon.
“This year’s renewal experience was great,” she said. Even though she receives no subsidies, she was still able to use the HealthCare.gov website to comparison shop among UPMC Health Plan, Highmark, UnitedHealthcare, Assurant, and Coventry, which is owned by Aetna.
“Competition at its best,” she said. “Competition lowered my price.”
According to the US. Department of Health and Human Services, about 7.2 million people were newly enrolled, or had re-enrolled, in a marketplace plan through Jan. 16. About 422,000 of them are from Pennsylvania.
For those who don’t have coverage but are able to afford it and who don’t qualify for government-sponsored health plans such as Medicaid, the deadline to obtain coverage is Feb. 15. Those who don’t have coverage risk paying a fine next tax season.
Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.