With the break-up of Highmark Health and UPMC just weeks away, UPMC has a message for the Highmark customers who haven’t switched insurers for 2015:

Please don’t leave us.

In an email sent out Friday morning, Steven Shapiro, UPMC chief medical and scientific officer, told all health system physicians that starting Dec. 18, UPMC will launch an outreach campaign in an effort to keep existing Highmark insurance patients under UPMC care.

“We want you and your patients to have written assurances that they will indeed be protected, and will be billed on an in-network basis by UPMC,” the email said. “Starting Thursday, [we] will begin calling Highmark commercial subscribers [to explain that] any Highmark patients under your care, whether it is for preventive, acute, or chronic care, have the right to continue in your care at in-network rates. We want to assure that your patients understand their rights under the consent decrees.”

Advertise with us

The consent decrees, signed this summer by UPMC and Highmark after negotiations with state agencies, say that Highmark customers can continue to see UPMC doctors and specialists via two primary contractual loopholes.

The first is the “safety net” loophole, which says that any existing UPMC patient who is a Highmark subscriber and who saw a UPMC physician at some point in 2014, but is not in the middle of a “continuing course of treatment” can continue to see UPMC doctors for one more year, so long as they are “unable to find alternative physicians and services in their locality.”

But there’s a much broader loophole in the decree — that’s the “continuity of care” provision and, unlike the safety net provision, there is no one-year time limit attached to it. Instead, the continuity of care provision applies for the duration of the decree, which runs through mid-2019.

That piece of the decree says “Highmark and UPMC mutually agree that the continuation of care of a Highmark member in the midst of a course of treatment at UPMC shall be on an in-network basis at in-network rates. The need for a continuing course of treatment shall be determined [by] the patient’s treating physician,” and that continuing care includes “all services reasonably related to that treatment, including but not limited to testing and follow-up.”

“In-network rates” suggest that a Highmark customer would pay the in-network co-pays and deductibles as stipulated by their specific insurance plan. But if Highmark disputes the opinion of the treating physician, and disputes that the nature of the care is “continuing,” the Department of Health or a designated representative will “review the matter and make a final, non-appealable determination.”

Advertise with us

And should Highmark object to the the physician’s determination, UPMC wants its doctors to be prepared with a paper trail: “We will be rolling out the tools to help you and your patients document in the medical record their wish to stay in your care,” Dr. Shapiro wrote in the letter.

Even “preventive” care, according to Dr. Shapiro’s letter, could seemingly qualify for the continuity of care provision.

New Highmark customers, or those who have never used a UPMC physician, would still be locked out of UPMC’s Allegheny County network.

Dennis Gabos, a cardiologist at UPMC Passavant who has been critical of UPMC, said the letter “makes it look like UPMC is more available and more accessible” to Highmark members.

UPMC administrators have consistently emphasized to their physicians that the best way for Highmark members to assure continued access after the expiration of 2015 safety net period was to switch insurers, Dr. Gabos said. To now point to the five-year continuity of care provision as a way to retain Highmark patients seems “a manipulation of human lives and hospitals, which are community assets, and in violation of the spirit of non-profit law,” he said.

Advertise with us

“This is information they could have made clear five months ago.”

Instead, UPMC’s retention campaign is beginning at the end of 2014, now that the open-enrollment period for commercial customers is over.

“From [UPMC’s] standpoint, their biggest risk all along has been loss of revenue,” said Jim McTiernan, a benefits consultant at Pittsburgh-based Triad USA, a division of Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. “What they’re trying to do is minimize how much revenue is lost.”

In its audited fiscal 2014 financial report, UPMC said 31 percent of its $6 billion in net patient revenue, or about $1.9 billion, comes from non-Medicare Highmark insurance reimbursement payments. Only Medicare, with 33 percent, represented a larger slice of UPMC’s net revenue pie.

Since early 2011, UPMC has been saying that it didn’t want to sign a new, full-access contract with Highmark, because a new deal with Highmark “would wind up funding Highmark's own hospital system, making such a deal illogical, unrealistic and ultimately anticompetitive.”

Advertise with us

At that time, Highmark was contemplating the purchase of the financially distressed West Penn Allegheny Health System and UPMC was asking for a 40 percent increase in its commercial hospital rate, according to Highmark’s version of events. That proposed rate increase was one reason Highmark sought out WPAHS as a partner.

The 10-year, full-access contract  between Highmark and UPMC was set to expire in summer 2012, with a one-year run-out period to July 1, 2013; that contract was then extended to Dec. 31, 2014. This summer, UPMC and Highmark arrived at a divorce settlement that gave Highmark customers access to all of the UPMC hospitals and clinics outside of Allegheny County, plus Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh, UPMC Mercy (until June 2015, with a run-out of one year), and access to UPMC oncology services.

But access to UPMC’s core hospitals, such as Shadyside, Presbyterian, Montefiore, Magee Women’s, and UPMC East, would be out-of-network.

On Friday, UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said the letter does not represent any change in the health system’s position, but simply points out the “very strong continuity of care provision” outlined in the consent decrees.

That provision, he said, states that Highmark patients, in consultation with their physician, can continue seeing their UPMC physician for the five-year duration of the consent decree, “and Highmark has no role in interfering in the patient-doctor decision.”

Advertise with us

“What we’ve been saying publicly is that the best way to assure yourself of full access to UPMC doctors and facilities, without interruption, disruption or misapplication of the consent decree by Highmark, is to switch to an insurance plan that allows full, affordable in-network access,” he said.

The reason for Dr. Shapiro’s letter, Mr. Wood said, “is the plethora of Highmark’s attempts to separate patients from their UPMC physicians when those patients would clearly prefer continuity of their care. Those patients who wish to stay with their UPMC physicians will be protected as per the consent decree.”

Highmark said it had no comment on UPMC’s communique to its physicians.

But Rick Galardini, CEO of JRG Advisors, a benefits broker in Pine, said the UPMC email sounded a lot like what Highmark sales representatives have been telling his mid-sized business clients for the last several months.

“You’re going to be able to see your doctor,” Mr. Galardini said, summarizing the Highmark sales pitch. “By the time this is over, they’ll be begging us to see their doctors.”

Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625. Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.