Allegheny Health Network CEO John Paul made at least $1.7 million in base compensation and bonuses last year, according to federal tax documents submitted Friday by AHN and its parent company, Highmark Health.
Highmark Health and its affiliated hospitals released their 2013 tax returns Friday, the first time Highmark has done so since converting to a 501(c)(3) nonprofit a year ago. Highmark, a Blue Cross Blue Shield insurer, historically has organized as a nonprofit corporation but not a charity with a federal tax exemption, meaning it didn’t have to file a Form 990 tax return.
That changed last year, when Highmark reorganized its corporate structure following its purchase of the West Penn Allegheny Health System, which is now part of AHN.
Typically, a nonprofit whose fiscal year runs January through December would have to file its 990s by May 15. Because of the reorganization of the companies’ fiscal calendars, Highmark received a six-month extension for filing the 2013 tax returns. Allegheny Health Network, which is owned by Highmark Health, came into existence in April 2013, after Highmark’s purchase of the West Penn Allegheny Health System was approved by the state.
The 990 returns offer a limited view into a nonprofit’s financial and programmatic operations, reporting net assets, lobbying activities and other organizational information. For larger nonprofits, the most noteworthy aspect is the listing of the company’s highest-paid employees and board members, which is useful for benchmarking the organization against others of similar size, with similar missions.
Mr. Paul’s $1.7 million compensation package is smaller than that of Jeffrey Romoff, UPMC president and CEO, who made $6.55 million last fiscal year. Highmark’s CEO through May, William Winkenwerder Jr., made $4.5 million in 2013. The salary of current Highmark Health CEO David Holmberg wasn’t included in the 2013 tax filing.
The rest of Highmark’s affiliated hospitals filed their 990 forms this week, too, including the five-hospital West Penn Allegheny Health System. Top salaries reported for WPAHS include two former executives: chief financial officer Daniel Lebish, $3.67 million; and Judy Zedreck, Allegheny General Hospital interim president and CEO, $937,015.
Chief medical officer Tony Farah received $864,864 in 2013.
Other executive compensation: Duke Rupert, president and CEO of West Penn Hospital in Bloomfield, $407,763; Reese Jackson, president and CEO of Forbes Hospital in Monroeville, $362,674; and Ned Laubacher, president and CEO of Alle-Kiski Medical Center (now Allegheny Valley Hospital) in Natrona Heights, $619,780.
Also notable were severance payments to former WPAHS CEO Christopher Olivia, $626,302, and to chief administrative officer Roy Santarella, $585,872. The two men both left in 2011.
At other AHN hospitals, former Jefferson Hospital president John Dempster received $812,328 in compensation in 2013, and COO Louise Urban, who has since succeeded Mr. Dempster, received $342,870.
Meanwhile, two executives served as president at Canonsburg General Hospital in 2013: Kimberly Sperring received $236,567 and Marcie Caplan received $243,887 serving dual roles at Canonsburg and Jefferson Hospital in Jefferson Hills. Both have since left AHN.
St. Vincent Health System, AHN’s facility in Erie, reported that president Scott Whalen’s total compensation was $767,803.
And at Highmark itself, top legal officer Thomas L. VanKirk ($1.6 million), organizational treasurer Nanette DeTurk ($2.9 million) and Darren Macioce, senior vice president for Health Plan Operations ($1.1 million) all exceeded the $1 million mark in total compensation.
Top Highmark Health employees who work for Highmark’s insurance arm (Highmark Inc.) or its for-profit subsidiaries are not listed in the 990 return, but they are identified annually in compensation reports submitted to the state Insurance Department. For example, Highmark Health Plan CEO Deborah Rice-Johnson made $2 million in 2013, and Mr. Holmberg (then the head of Highmark’s diversified operations unit) made $1.6 million, but neither was listed on the 990 return.
Also of note, Allegheny Health Network reported spending more than $1 million last year advertising with the Pirates. It paid an additional $4.9 million to Mullen, which is Highmark’s primary advertising firm.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.