Highmark Inc. says a “routine systems upgrade” is to blame for statements sent out to 5,000 UPMC patients, mistakenly telling them that their UPMC doctors were already out of network and that they may owe money for medical services.
While Pittsburgh health giants UPMC and Highmark are set to split Dec. 31 — leaving many of UPMC’s Allegheny County hospitals and practices out-of-network for Highmark’s under-65 and non-Medicaid health insurance customers — these notices were sent out in late October and early November, following appointments that occurred in the same time period.
The “explanation of benefits” statements notified patients that the doctor they had just seen was out-of-network.
Some statements simply told customers that a bill would be forthcoming; others, according to UPMC, included checks from Highmark to help them pay the bills that they didn’t owe in the first place.
UPMC began receiving calls about the statements a week ago. Twenty-two practices were involved — all UPMC practices.
Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger said the problem was rectified immediately.
Read More
“We found out about on Nov. 4, and fixed it Nov. 5,” he said.
UPMC, naturally, took a more skeptical view of the error.
“This is a cautionary tale of the perils of anyone — individuals or employers — thinking that Highmark is going to make it easy to see their UPMC doctors,” said UPMC spokesman Paul Wood. “Clearly, Highmark does not have the processing capability to assure individuals or employers their claims are being handled correctly.”
The 5,000 statements included nearly 9,000 services — one visit can include multiple billable services — and amounted to about $1 million in incorrect patient bills. Highmark says it is making calls and sending out letters to explain the error to affected customers.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.