UPMC Health Plan has dramatically slashed premiums for the 2015 insurance policies that it is selling via the federal government’s online insurance marketplace, while Highmark Inc.’s have risen slightly, meaning UPMC has the cheapest midrange “silver” plans available in Allegheny County.

The price differential is minimal, though. For a 21-year-old, the cheapest possible 2015 “silver” policy from UPMC Health Plan, before accounting for subsidies available to lower-income buyers, starts at $133 a month; Highmark’s starts at $140, according to pricing data released Sunday by the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, which operates the HealthCare.gov insurance marketplace.

But the relative parity on price is a marked change from a year ago, when Highmark offered some of the cheapest exchange policies in the country.

At the time, UPMC accused Highmark of underpricing its policies to grab business. And in a filing this spring with the state Department of Insurance, Highmark said it expected to lose $2.9 million on its Pennsylvania-based exchange business from July 1, 2014, to June 30, 2015. UPMC, on the other hand, claimed that its own 2014 plan prices — which were 50-70 percent higher than its 2015 offerings — were “actuarially sound” and “fiscally responsible” compared to Highmark’s.

Advertise with us

This year, it’s a different story, UPMC Health Plan says.

“As you may imagine, many factors influence the manner in which health coverage products are priced,” said Gina Pferdehirt, UPMC Health Plan spokeswoman. “This year’s exchange market is very different from last year’s.”

Last year, she said, the marketplace was disproportionately trafficked by people with pre-existing health conditions who had been unable to purchase coverage in the past. That caused UPMC Health Plan to set higher prices, and caused some national insurers to boycott certain states and markets altogether.

Meanwhile, the young and healthy weren’t scared by the small penalties for lack of coverage, and many declined to buy policies for 2014.

“This year, the penalties have increased; as such, even healthier persons are more likely to purchase coverage to avoid paying these penalties, [further] balancing the overall risk pool,” Ms. Pferdehirt said. “All of these factors have allowed UPMC Health Plan to offer the lowest-priced [plans] on the exchange.”

Advertise with us

Uninsured Americans shopping for individual and family plans via HealthCare.gov can buy their 2015 policies starting Saturday, the first day of the three-month open-enrollment period that ends Feb. 15. The Obama administration opened the website for window shopping Sunday, allowing customers to compare premium prices, deductibles and other policy specifics.

Those who lack health insurance and who aren’t eligible for government plans such as Medicare and Medicaid are supposed to buy coverage or be subject to a fine, according to the individual-mandate provision of the 2010 Affordable Care Act.

In 2015, that penalty could cost up to $975 per household, or 2 percent of taxable income, whichever is greater.

The regional price battle between Highmark and UPMC on the marketplace is reflective of the larger war between the two. UPMC is locking Highmark’s commercial customers out of most of its Allegheny County hospitals and practices starting Jan. 1, 2015.

The network lockout shouldn’t affect customers’ buying preferences on the exchange; many of those who bought Highmark policies on the exchange last year bought the company’s “Community Blue” policies, which by design excluded access to most UPMC facilities.

Advertise with us

On the strength of those plans — and low prices — Highmark sold 131,000 plans on the exchange last year and early this year in Pennsylvania, which accounted for more than 40 percent of all marketplace plans sold in the state.

Four out of five Highmark plans sold through the marketplace were Community Blue plans.

If the absence of UPMC’s network wasn’t, and isn’t, a major factor in marketplace sales, the new prices probably will be. Many of those who bought insurance coverage for the current plan year shopped based on price, as opposed to the breadth of the provider network.

A Highmark spokesman said the company was forced to increase its exchange premiums after the 2014 experience, which was an experiment in rate-setting for all insurers.

“Of those who enrolled with us on the Pennsylvania exchange in 2013, more than half were considered ‘new to Highmark,’ ” said spokesman Aaron Billger. Many of those were new to health insurance, as well.

Advertise with us

“We anticipated there would be a population of previously uninsured people coming to the marketplace, which can translate to ‘pent-up demand’ for health care services,” Mr. Billger said. “The data supports this. We found that, on average, individuals who purchased an ACA plan utilized services more than those who purchased coverage through an employer.”

As for UPMC Health Plan’s reduction in premium rates, Mr. Billger said, “Across the country, issuers with little ACA market share in 2014 dropped their rates for 2015, while issuers with more significant ACA market share in 2014 needed to increase rates.”

He also noted that Highmark’s provider network, while it excludes UPMC, includes 97 percent of all hospitals and more than 92 percent of all U.S. physicians, because of Highmark’s Blue Cross Blue Shield affiliation.

“One of the key reasons competitors were able to lower rates this year was due to the limited choice their networks provide when it comes to accessing care,” he said.

If Highmark no longer has a distinct pricing edge, it does keep its geographic edge. It can sell policies in 49 Pennsylvania counties, excluding the Philadelphia and Scranton regions, and Highmark can also sell policies in West Virginia and Delaware. UPMC Health Plan sells only in Western Pennsylvania’s 29 counties.

Advertise with us

UPMC Health Plan has the premium pricing advantage in Allegheny and Erie counties. In other counties, it’s a draw — in Beaver, Butler, Armstrong, Westmoreland and Washington counties, “silver plan” premiums start at the exact same price for UPMC Advantage Silver plan and Highmark’s Community Blue Flex Plan, according to HealthCare.gov’s window-shopping price preview feature.

In Centre County, where UPMC has no hospitals, Highmark’s silver plans are cheapest, followed by Geisinger Health Plan, then UPMC Health Plan. In Pennsylvania counties where UPMC Health Plan isn’t selling policies, such as the Harrisburg area, Highmark’s prices are still the lowest. In West Virginia, it’s still the only carrier offering ACA-compliant plans through the HealthCare.gov exchange.

But broadly, UPMC’s plans are cheaper in the counties where the two companies go head to head.

In Allegheny County, for example, a 40-year-old nonsmoker has 23 silver plans to choose from. Of those, nine cost less than $200 a month, and eight of those are UPMC Health Plan policies. The other is Highmark’s.

The remainder of the plans are sold by UnitedHealthcare and Assurant, both new to the state exchange this year, and by Coventry, which is owned by Aetna.

Advertise with us

Those buying health plans through the federal marketplace, or through state-based marketplaces in the states that opted to build their own exchange websites, can buy from several tiers of plans — bronze, silver, gold and platinum, and some will be eligible for limited-benefit “catastrophic” plans, as well.

Platinum plans cost most in terms of monthly premiums, but have the lowest copays for doctor visits and drugs, followed by gold, the silver baseline plan and then bronze.

Silver plans have proven to be the most popular locally and nationally; those buying a silver plan may be eligible not only for federal tax subsidies to help defray the cost of premiums, but also “cost-sharing” subsidies that help save money on out-of-pocket deductibles, copayments and coinsurance.

Customers who lack insurance but make too much money to be eligible for premium subsidies can buy health plans off the marketplace, directly from health insurers.