2014 Audi Q5 TDI Quattro TipTronic vs. 2014 BMW X5 xDrive35d: Luxury and diesel together?

This week: BMW X5

Price: $72,475 as tested (a base diesel model starts at $56,500, and a bare-bones rear-wheel-drive X5 can be had for $53,725).

Marketer’s pitch: “The ultimate driving machine.” An oldie but a goodie.

Advertise with us

Conventional wisdom: A Volvo-loving friend of mine said the Eurozone competitors are a “we car” (Volvo) vs. a “me car” (BMW). A nice way of saying BMW drivers are — to borrow a phrase from Washington Post advice columnist Carolyn Hax — glass bowls.

Reality: Pretty darn ultimate, I’d say.

Catching up: Last week, I reported on the Audi Q5 TDI, a turbodiesel version of the company’s small crossover. The engine performed well and offered a little better than 30 mpg, excellent for the vehicle category.

Bimmer debut: Readers who follow my column know I aim for the more run-of-the-mill cars. For this reason, BMW has never really been on the Driver’s Seat radar. But when offered the chance to drive the all-new-for-2014 X5, I couldn’t pass it up.

And the XXL BehemothMW handles so well, I’d definitely take something in a small or a medium, thank you.

Advertise with us

Stealth diesel: It speaks volumes about the quiet and smooth engine that I didn’t realize I had a diesel until after traveling a couple miles and noticing the word “diesel” on the fuel gauge. (It also speaks volumes about how I can be clueless.)

Up to speed: The 3.0-liter diesel engine creates 255 horsepower and 413 foot-pounds of torque. That moves the heavy X5 in a great hurry. (A twin turbo inline 3.0 six and 4.4-liter V8 are among other engine choices.)

On the road: For a seven-passenger giant, the X5 handles beautifully. Being a budget-conscious car reviewer, I’d always imagined that Mazda was paying homage to the Bavarian automaker, and I quickly learned that’s true.

This was even before I noticed the “Sport-Comfort” button on the console. Engage “Sport” mode, and the X5 engine revs and on winding roads behaves like a German sports sedan. Yes, it’s that good.

Built for the forest: BMW’s NightVision with Pedestrian Detection proved worthy of its $2,600 price tag when a deer-shaped light illuminated one night while traveling the hinterlands and within seconds a previously unseen deer darted in front of the X5.

Advertise with us

Just to further prove its worth, the system lit up again a mile later, alerting me to another ruminant standing by the side of the road.

Controls: The X5 seemed to have everything within the driver’s reach. I marveled at the simplicity — just three buttons and a switch for the cruise control, for example.

Inside: The leather and shiny wood-laden BMW is as beautiful as expected.

Driving position: Comfy back. Comfy arms. Visible gauges. Pick two. I made peace with the setup, but still couldn’t see the top of the speedometer or tachometer.

Shifty: The X5’s eight-speed ShiftTronic automatic was easy to reach and a delight to shift. It upshifts by pulling to the rear, as nature intended.

Advertise with us

But getting out of Park was a real challenge. A button on top of the shifter engages Park. A button is required to change from Reverse to Neutral to Drive, and I missed gears more times than I care to count. Furthermore, whether BMW or Prius, pushing an electronic control forward to go backward and backward to go forward seems counterintuitive, even though it follows standard PRDNL gearing.

Shutting down: After some issues with last week’s Audi Q5 shutting down while leaving the stereo on, I found the BMW X5 would not turn off the radio at all upon shutdown. Finally I deduced it probably happened when I locked the doors. (Chirp.) And silence.

Friends and stuff: The rear seat — optional at $850 per butt, or $425 per cheek — is covered in fine leather and actually isn’t too hard on the back for an inch-thick padded cushion. But headroom is snug and knee room is dire. Fourteen-year-old Sturgis Kid 4.0 crossed a mall parking lot in the way, way back and couldn’t take any more.

Play some tunes: The display resembled an iPad standing on the dashboard. Though the sound system lacked a midrange adjustment, songs sounded as clear as ever.

I’ve seen joystick multimedia controls in other cars and found BMW’s intimidating at first. But after a few misfires, I managed to work it out in short order. The buttons are arranged in front of the joystick, and soon I could change from radio to CD and back without looking.

Advertise with us

Night shift: The overhead lighting is beautiful and subtle and doesn’t interfere with operation. The headlamp beams must be fairly bright and aimed high, because I experienced a lot of headlight flashing when I was in low-beam mode. But they turn with the vehicle, always an added bonus.

Fuel economy: The X5 averaged almost 27 miles per gallon of diesel. Worse than the Audi Q5, but the X5 hauls a whole lot more.

Where it’s built: Spartanburg, S.C.

How it’s built: Consumer Reports offers no reliability prediction for the new X5. It’s been average or better for the past couple years, but rated in the bottom at the end of the Oughts.

In the end: The Audi Q5 was definitely a nice vehicle, and perhaps worth the price tag. But the Audi quirkiness just left me befuddled. The BMW offers such intuitive controls and handles so well that it’s like being one with the road. Sure, for 72 Gs reliability should be more consistent, and it should come with a servant and a wine dispenser. But something tells me the “cheaper” Bimmers are even more fun.

And if that makes me a glass bowl, I can live with that.