Just three months after a federal judge ruled against them, Pittsburgh-based developers are restarting the fight to kill one of the city’s most debated housing policies.
Representatives of Walnut Capital appeared before the city’s zoning board on Thursday to request an exemption from inclusionary zoning, a law that requires all buildings with more than 20 apartments to mark down rents on some units.
Walnut does not believe that the policy should apply to The Caroline, a new 11-story apartment complex the developer is building on McKee Place in Oakland. Located near the University of Pittsburgh’s campus, the building will be marketed to students.
The developer’s request is teeing up another lawsuit against inclusionary zoning, said Jonathan Kamin, a Goldberg, Kamin and Garvin attorney representing Walnut Capital.

In 2022, an association of local developers and builders sued the city of Pittsburgh, claiming that inclusionary zoning violates state law. Action in the case ramped up this summer when the group asked the court to immediately strike down the law, maintaining that it was jeopardizing completion of Walnut Capital’s building in Oakland.
The court in November sided with the city and upheld inclusionary zoning. But the decision left the door open for future lawsuits: A key sticking point was that the developer did not exhaust all options to get around the policy, such as asking the city for exemption.
Read More
“We are here … so that we can go ahead and essentially tick off that box,” Mr. Kamin said on Thursday.
Inclusionary zoning was introduced in Lawrenceville seven years ago and has since expanded into Oakland, Polish Hill and Bloomfield. Supporters argue it has increased Pittsburgh’s scant supply of affordable housing units. But developers and some residents say it can drive up costs and delay construction starts.
The policy was a hallmark of former Mayor Ed Gainey’s term. Mr. Gainey last year introduced a proposal to expand inclusionary zoning citywide with limited exceptions — prompting months of heated debate within City Hall.
The city has yet to issue a decision on an amended version of the mayor’s plan.
Reopening the debate, Mr. Kamin argued that inclusionary zoning has stunted growth in Pittsburgh, raising the price of building here.
In Oakland, the policy requires Walnut Capital to mark down rents on 16 units in its new building — a measure that would reduce the project’s value by nearly $5 million, Mr. Kamin said.
“[This] is a very difficult challenge to go ahead and place on people who are looking to develop housing in Pittsburgh,” he said, adding that inflation and rising construction costs already raise the price of building here.
But Oakland Planning and Development Corp. executive director Andrea Boykowycz countered that Walnut Capital has already secured enough funding for the project to offset any potential loss.
The developer has received a multimillion-dollar grant from the state and tax abatements from the school district and county toward the building, which is under construction and slated to open in 2027.
“Unless they are hiding something, they can absolutely make this project work without a variance,” Ms. Boykowycz said.
Lawrenceville United executive director David Breingan framed the developer’s request as “disingenuous,” appearing on Thursday to back inclusionary zoning. “It can be developed,” Mr. Breingan said. “It’s literally being developed right now.”
Mr. Kamin hit back, maintaining that Walnut Capital pursued those subsidies because of the costs associated with offering reduced rents.
“Without those subsidies, there would be no project,” he said.
The Caroline was designed for students, with three-bedroom apartments that Walnut Capital plans to rent out by room. Those plans underscore the “inappropriateness” of requiring affordable housing within the building, Mr. Kamin argued.
“If you have people who are not students living with students, it's not ideal,” he said on Thursday.
But Mr. Breingan and others insisted students are the exact group in need of lower rents.
“Most students do not have significant incomes,” Mr. Breingan said.
If the zoning board denies Walnut Capital’s request, the Builder’s Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh — the group behind the original lawsuit against inclusionary zoning — is prepared to file suit again, Mr. Kamin confirmed.
And if the request is granted? “The Builder’s Association has hundreds of members,” Mr. Kamin said. “I imagine you would see another coming forward asking for the same thing.”
With that in mind, supporters of inclusionary zoning on Thursday framed the developer’s request as a high-stakes ask that could threaten the policy’s survival in Pittsburgh.
“I urge you to deny Walnut Capital’s petition so as not to create a precedent that will undermine Oakland’s preservation of affordable housing,” Monica Mehaffey, an Oakland resident and member of the Oakland Planning and Development Corp., said during public comments.
Within the next two weeks, all parties involved must submit any materials for consideration to the zoning board. After that, the board will have 45 days to issue its decision.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.