In the early 2000s, near-identical contracts set two Pittsburgh neighborhoods just miles apart on diverging paths forward.
On the north side of the Allegheny River, where there once was vacant land and parking lots, office buildings, restaurants, a hotel and retail now line Pittsburgh’s North Shore — a neighborhood still growing.
Across the river, save for a new office tower and a music venue, acres of land remain untouched in the lower Hill District — a neighborhood long held waiting.
Near the top of Webster Avenue, the windows of K. Leroy Irvis Towers overlook the lower Hill. With more than 11 years spent working in the lobby of the public housing complex, Hill District resident Ray Robinson has seen tenants come and go — all while the land outside sits unchanged.
“The problem,” he said, turning toward the lower Hill while manning the building’s front desk, “is broken promises.”
In both neighborhoods, Pittsburgh’s three major sports teams were handed the exclusive rights to build up empty land surrounding their stadiums years ago — the Steelers and Pirates on the North Shore, and the Penguins a few years later in the lower Hill.
Read More
Contracts with the city set clear deadlines: Within about two decades, the teams were expected to bring whole neighborhoods to life.
But as the North Shore grew, much of the land surrounding PPG Paints Arena sat idle as the Penguins struggled to make progress.
It’s a site laden with history: Once one of the most vibrant Black neighborhoods in the country, the Upper Hill was cut off from Downtown by construction of the Civic Arena in the late 1950s, uprooting a whole community. Since then, residents have pushed hard for a stake in their neighborhood’s future, at times clashing with developers over ever-changing plans.
Now, the neighborhood sits at a critical juncture. The Penguins’ hold over the lower Hill expired in late October, leaving the land in the hands of two city agencies — and open to new developers.
With the long-awaited change comes major questions, notably: What went wrong during the years of inaction? What do residents want to see built? And, as construction costs rise, what remains possible today?
As the city mulls its next step, officials say this could be a watershed moment for the neighborhood.
“I think we have a generational opportunity to do something really special and unique on this site to restore many harms of the past, as well as look forward positively,” said City Council President Dan Lavelle, who represents the Hill District.
‘The numbers wouldn’t work’
Longtime residents of the Hill District still can recall when homes were bulldozed to make way for the Civic Arena. Many, including Pittsburgh Public Schools board member Sala Udin, grew up on streets that no longer exist.
Winters were “frigid cold” in Mr. Udin’s childhood apartment on Epiphany Street, where the windows had holes and the rooms lacked radiators, he told a room full of University of Pittsburgh students during a panel discussion this month.
Still, he said, “It was home.”
That changed around the time Mr. Udin was 7 and rumors that “we were all going to have to move” began to spread, he said. His family became one of hundreds relocated to public housing as the lower Hill was cleared.
It didn’t take long for a committee of residents to form and post billboards across town demanding “low-income housing for the lower Hill.”
The goal was to give displaced families a chance to come back, and ensure that others were not priced out. So began a decades-long effort to right the wrongs of the neighborhood’s past that has at times conflicted with plans for its future.
The Penguins gained the rights to develop the land around their new arena in a deal that kept the team in Pittsburgh. But as their contract expires, the team has broken ground on projects covering less than a quarter of the site: the new headquarters of First National Bank, and a LiveNation music venue under construction.
The rest is undeveloped land where the team had pledged to build a hotel, thousands of new apartments, offices and more.
As development plans ramped up in 2014, the Penguins inked an agreement with the community. The team promised, among other things, to include minority-owned businesses in the construction and build affordable housing.
The pact required at least 20% of new units to be affordable for residents earning 60% to 80% of the area’s median income — a broad range that led to disputes between the team and community through the years.
Months after signing the agreement, the team and the Hill Community Development Corporation, a nonprofit that represents residents, worked through the first of several standoffs over the terms, delaying progress at the site.
A frequent issue was the cost of building affordable units. With reduced rents come reduced profits, a hurdle for developers already splitting revenue with the Penguins, said Mulu Birru, a former consultant for the developer McCormack Baron Salazar, initially tapped by the Penguins to build housing.
In revenue projections, the project never broke even, Mr. Birru said.
The Penguins in 2019 brought on new developers and announced revamped plans for housing, several office buildings, the music venue, a food hall and more. Team officials made additional pledges to the community, promising to renovate a community center and begin work on hundreds of affordable units within months.
But the team never got started on housing — or most plans for the site.
“The numbers wouldn’t work,” said state Sen. Wayne Fontana, D-Brookline, chairman of the Sports and Exhibition Authority’s board, one of the two city agencies overseeing development of the lower Hill.
The Penguins and Buccini Polin Group, the lead developer at the time, did not respond to requests for comment.
The team — which changed hands in the midst of the redevelopment and faced another possible sale this year — previously told the Post-Gazette it was dedicated to “inclusive development” at the site, donating to the community and supporting local businesses.
But Mr. Lavelle said the team’s involvement was the “largest impediment” to progress over the years.
“While really good at hockey, they are not developers,” the city councilman said.
Meanwhile, on the North Shore, projects that have been completed include Stage AE, the Hyatt Place Hotel, several office and residential buildings, and retail space between PNC Park and Acrisure Stadium, all during a similar timeframe.
Frank Kass, chairman of Continental Real Estate Companies, which worked with the Steelers and Pirates, said such results were possible for a simple reason: Before the housing was built, no one lived there.
“We never talked to a community group,” Mr. Kass explained. “There aren’t any adjacent to our property.”
Meanwhile, in the lower Hill, the cost of development and disagreements with the community made it “very difficult” for the team to attract developers, said Mr. Birru.
The Penguins in 2019 said they expected to break ground shortly on office buildings and retail space. Years later, just First National Bank’s headquarters is finished.
The Penguins reportedly also struggled to lock down tenants for potential office space, pursuing many groups that now anchor new developments in the North Shore and Strip District.
Then came the pandemic. As office leasing plummeted and building costs soared, difficult projects became nearly impossible, sources said. “It was too hard. People don’t like hard when they’re spending millions of dollars,” said one source who was closely involved in redevelopment plans.
Rising costs, fewer options
From Irvis Towers, residents can see FNB’s 26-story financial center, which opened in February.
“They built that bank tower and now the music venue,” said Clifford Wilson, 84, a lifelong Hill resident who now lives in Irvis. Pointing toward the skyscraper on a recent afternoon, he continued, “You’d think they would have built the housing first.”
“That’s what we’ve always needed,” added Mr. Robinson, who works in Irvis Towers.
While the Hill has seen some affordable housing built in the last few years, it’s not enough to meet demand: A recent study by the city found that rising rents are forcing more residents out of the neighborhood.
“Without the housing, it's an events space,” said Carl Redwood, head of the Hill Consensus Group, another nonprofit that represents residents. “Not a community space.”
While disagreements hindered progress early, the rising cost of building slows progress now.

During a recent panel discussion about development in Pittsburgh, Breanna Tyson — head of the Pittsburgh-based developer Hullett Properties — compared the price of building a 175-unit apartment building in Pittsburgh in 2019 versus now.
Such a project is about 25% more expensive today, she said. And the expense of operating buildings after utility providers upped their rates is a “silent killer,” she added.
Sitting beside Ms. Tyson, co-panelist Bryan McCann — a senior vice president at the Colliers real estate firm — said that if he had a magic wand to spur growth in Pittsburgh, he “would remove mandated affordability requirements.” Many in the crowd of real estate professionals nodded.
Against that backdrop, finding developers willing to take on the lower Hill could be difficult, said Mr. Birru and Mr. Kass of Continental Development.
In a high-cost environment, developers working on just a few sites each year gravitate towards projects with fewer hurdles — where “water runs downhill,” said Mr. Kass.
‘It’s just going to sit there’
The expiration of the Penguins’ contract leaves the lower Hill in the control of Pittsburgh’s Sports and Exhibition Authority and Urban Redevelopment Authority.
Neither was a part of the 2014 agreement that for years guided development of the site, setting guardrails intended to benefit the community, including minimum levels of affordability.
At this crossroads in the neighborhood's future, some are pushing the city to honor past commitments. The Hill Community Development Corporation has formally asked both authorities to sign on to that pact, President and CEO Marimba Milliones said.
“[The agreement] has always been very clear in articulating what the aspirations of the community have been,” Ms. Milliones said. “It’s really government’s turn to ensure, now that they have unencumbered control of the site, that they do what they’re supposed to do.”
Representatives from the URA and SEA told the Post-Gazette that they are working with Allegheny County, other city officials and the community to identify and implement a process for selecting developers.
Any request for proposals from developers should, “at a minimum,” include past promises to the community, Ms. Milliones said.
But as the cost of building rises, others disagree: With “too many restrictions” on development, “they won’t get any proposals,” said a person with ties to the URA who requested that his name not be used because he didn’t have authorization to speak for the organization.
While the URA has long overseen one plot of land slated for residential development, the SEA governs the lower Hill’s other half, set aside for commercial projects — which also face hurdles.
Downtown is still recovering from the pandemic, when companies embraced remote work and scaled back their office space. After years of battling rising vacancy rates, the corridor’s office market is only now showing signs of recovery. Still, little new office space is in the pipeline, the latest market reports show.
Adding to that challenge is the question of parking. The lower Hill is currently made up of acres of surface parking lots, but it’s all slated for redevelopment.
FNB in 2023 applied for a $10 million state grant to help fund construction of a parking garage with more than 900 spaces in the lower Hill. The company declined to comment on the status of plans for the garage.
“You have to have parking to make office and retail space work,” said Mr. Kass, adding that new garages on the North Shore were critical to the neighborhood’s success.
Leasing in FNB’s headquarters is ongoing. The company occupies about half of the new building’s space, and when it opened, at least four other tenants had signed leases, leaving about 45% of the building available.
The real estate firm Jones Lang LaSalle’s Pittsburgh office said it continues to market the space, a task some said could be challenging without clear plans for the land surrounding the building. FNB said the Penguins’ departure has “no bearing” on their commitment to the neighborhood. The company has invested more than $40 million in the community, a spokesperson said.
Ultimately, as the authorities, county and community chart a path forward for the lower Hill after years of stagnation, they “need to revisit best uses for the site,” said Mr. Lavelle.
“Reality has to set in,” added Mr. Fontana. “Otherwise, it's just going to sit there.”
‘That anger should be healed’
A row of condemned homes with crumbling brick facades and chipped wooden doors lines Bedford Avenue, about a mile from the lower Hill.
On Centre Avenue — once the heart of the neighborhood — spray paint covers the stained, white tile exterior of a shuttered chess club and pizza shop.
For years, the lower Hill has been stuck in a state of “arrested development,” Ms. Milliones said. And she believes that the entirety of the Hill District has struggled to attract investment because of visible setbacks in the lower Hill.
Mr. Birru observed that demolition, displacement and decades of stagnation have “devalued the entire Hill District.”
“That’s why the anger is there,” he said.
The Penguins “inherited the agony and trauma of the residents,” he added. “The Hill was counting on them and pushing them hard to [make amends] for what happened in the past.”
Today, the anger and trauma lingers.
But there’s also hope.
This restart, Mr. Lavelle and other city officials say, is a generational chance to deliver for a community long stuck in neutral.
“That anger should be healed,” said Mr. Birru. “And I think there’s a good opportunity for that to happen.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.