A Pittsburgh developer is suing a Shadyside woman, alleging her ongoing appeal of the zoning board decision that greenlit the firm’s apartment complex project in 2023 amounts to abuse of the legal system that has cost the developer time and money.
Mozart Management claimed in the lawsuit, filed Monday in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, that Lania Rubio’s “frivolous litigation” was nothing more than an attempt to delay the development of the South Aiken Street property that has cost Mozart more than $1 million.
“[Ms. Rubio’s] tactics, pure and simple, were an abuse of the legal system,” according to the lawsuit.
Attorneys for Ms. Rubio called the suit “frivolous” and that it was “meant to intimidate landowners from exercising their rights under the law.”
“Ms. Rubio had no ill intentions whatsoever,” attorneys from the Stoner Law Offices said in an email Wednesday. “... We expect this suit to be dismissed."
The developer first took the proposal — a 12-story, 131-unit apartment complex — to Pittsburgh’s Zoning Board of Adjustments in 2022.
Read More
The board rejected the proposal, and Mozart submitted a revised plan later that year that adjusted the proposed complex to 10 stories and 117 units.
The board held a public hearing on the proposal in late 2022 — a virtual hearing that Ms. Rubio did not attend — and OK’d the project in March 2023 so long as Mozart would make 10% of the units affordable housing units, among other provisions.
Ms. Rubio appealed the decision to the Court of Common Pleas a month later, calling the zoning board’s ruling “improper and unjustified” and “an abuse of discretion or error of law” that warranted a reversal.
Mozart Management asked the court to quash the appeal, saying Ms. Rubio had no standing to appeal because she wasn’t represented — either by herself or through someone she appointed — at the public hearing. Though the lower court rejected Mozart’s motion to quash, the developer appealed that decision to the Commonwealth Court.
When Commonwealth Court ruled in Mozart’s favor, allowing the appeal to be quashed because Ms. Rubio had no standing, Ms. Rubio petitioned the state Supreme Court to hear her case. The Supreme Court declined to take up the case in late July, and the appeal was ultimately quashed.
The proceedings across the three courts took more than two years.
“There was no basis for [Ms. Rubio’s] appeals other than improperly seeking to delay the development and cause financial harm to Mozart Management,” attorneys for Mozart wrote in the lawsuit, noting “both of which has in fact occurred.”
The lawsuit alleges wrongful use of civil proceedings and abuse of process by Ms. Rubio, claiming the firm has suffered — and continues to suffer — “significant financial harm” in the form of attorneys’ fees, lost revenue, and costs that increased during the two-year delay.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.