Pittsburgh’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure says it has considered stakeholder input — even if much of it is very negative — for a plan to “rightsize” a section of Penn Avenue in the Strip District.

But those stakeholders say it’s not nearly enough.

In an update earlier this week, the agency said it met with local businesses and others to address a slew of criticisms with the initial project description, which will change one of Penn Avenue’s two inbound lanes of traffic into a single lane with a bike lane between the 31st Street Bridge and 22nd Street, right before the main Strip business district begins.

But business owners in the Strip maintain that the update still does not address concerns they have about increased traffic, the ability to receive deliveries and even an inability for emergency response vehicles to access the bustling business district.

Advertise with us

The Strip has had two lanes for generations, they said. So why try to fix what’s not broken?

“Why would you take away lanes?” asked Jim Coen, the owner of Yinzers in the Burgh on Penn Avenue. “It doesn’t make any sense. They’re ruining a perfectly incredible neighborhood.”

DOMI did not immediately respond to a request for comment Thursday evening.

The Penn Avenue redesign — first reported by the Post-Gazette in March — was met with immediate criticism from local business owners.

By the time the agency held a public meeting regarding the project in May, the owners had formed the Strip District Business Association, which circulated a petition to scrap the move — which it says has 4,000 signatures.

Advertise with us

A key concern is that traffic on a one-lane Penn Avenue would back up into Lawrenceville during peak hours — an argument that DOMI says it addressed in its update.

In a “Congestion Memo” in April, DOMI said that if traffic in the section of Penn Avenue increased by 4.4% annually — much higher than its projected growth rate of 1% — it would take at least 30 years for congestion to exceed roadway capacity.

“Based on the current average daily traffic, daily significant congestion is very unlikely to become a major issue anytime soon, even with the lane reduction,” the report said.

DOMI added that commuters are less likely to speed on Penn Avenue if it is reduced from two lanes to one, which it projects will result in a 45% drop in auto crashes.

Mr. Coen and many of his group’s supporters are not convinced.

Advertise with us

North Hills resident Annabelle Cullen, a server at Harp and Fiddle Irish Pub at Penn and 24th, said she drives to the Strip. She said the proposed lane reduction would add time to her commute.

“We’re already in such a tight space. It makes it harder for us to get to work and makes it harder for people to come here,” Ms. Cullen said.

Firefighters have also raised concerns.

In a statement posted on the petition website, Pittsburgh Fire Fighters’ union Chief Ralph Sicuro said that the proposed 11-foot-wide single lane of traffic “presents significant challenges for emergency vehicle access and aerial truck operations critical to our firefighting capabilities.”

DOMI, in its update, said that it met with Fire and Emergency Medical Services representatives to “ensure that the project will not infringe on emergency responders’ ability to reach people in need,” and that conversations are ongoing.

Advertise with us

DOMI also proposes expanding paid parking from 25th Street through 31st Street in response to stakeholders who, the agency says, were concerned about lax parking enforcement in the area. Paid parking will be enforced from Monday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., at a rate of $3 per hour, the agency said.

Jim Ludwig, the owner of Blumengarten Florist and Flower Delivery on 27th Street, said he considers himself “lucky” to have ample parking near his business. Making customers pay for street parking that had previously been free will hurt businesses, he said.

Mr. Ludwig said he appreciates that DOMI has listened to Strip business owners’ concerns.

But he said it’s concerning that the agency seems to meet only one-on-one with business owners rather than in a group setting.

“I don’t know if that’s because you can’t make promises to both,” he said.

Advertise with us

Another lingering concern is deliveries.

At the Penn Avenue Fish Company, employee Kyle Houghtelin said that the city’s loading zone strategy is “disconcerting” — his store is one of many that use the street to unload shipments, without viable alternatives.

“We get big deliveries, freighter trucks that come in, and they use Penn Avenue because the alleyways are way too small to maneuver and negotiate around,” he said. “People could just get into the right lane and go around the truck. If we have a single lane with a bike lane, and we have freighter trucks and box trucks delivering, it’s going to tie up traffic even more.”

DOMI plans to hold a public meeting before the “rightsizing” is finalized. The agency anticipates that the changes will be implemented later this year, and construction will take a matter of days.