One Oxford Centre, the 45-story office tower built during the city’s second renaissance, has changed hands, with new ownership pledging to return the struggling skyscraper to its glory days.

Aaron Stauber, president of New Jersey-based Rugby Realty, led a local group that won a bid for an outstanding loan on the skyscraper for about $56 million — well below its $72.6 million face value.

Once a gleaming symbol of the city’s future, the storied building is now more than one-third vacant and markedly devalued, evidence of the challenges facing Downtown’s office market still rebounding from the pandemic.

With the one million-square-foot acquisition, Mr. Stauber is now the single largest private property owner of Downtown real estate. His portfolio includes Gulf Tower, the Koppers Building and the Frick Building, as well as 10 other properties in the Cultural District.

Advertise with us

Under Mr. Stauber, One Oxford — home to retail, over 850,000 square feet of premium office space, Downtown’s only pool, and squash, pickleball and basketball courts — will be due for an upgrade.

The new owners said they plan to revamp the building’s five-story lobby with an upscale central bar that will host live entertainment after hours. The building’s plaza will also be reimagined, with additional public amenities and recreation options, including a potential rock-climbing facility.

“This is the future of office life: work hard, play harder, all within the same walls,” Mr. Stauber said in a statement, in which he confirmed the sale.

Now that ownership has changed hands, major tenants in One Oxford plan to stay in the building. The law offices of Bill Pietragallo’s firm, based in the Centre for the past 38 years, renewed their lease, as did another 15,000-square-foot tenant.

“We were ready to pick up and leave because there was no vision for this trophy building, which we view as Downtown’s commercial center,” Mr. Pietragallo said. “But knowing Aaron Stauber’s reputation and after learning of (his) and his team’s big vision, we’re thrilled to renew our lease and be part of shaping this next chapter for One Oxford Centre.”

Advertise with us

High Downtown vacancy rates a lingering problem

Built during the city’s second Renaissance, One Oxford was purchased by San Francisco-based Shorenstein Properties in 2016 for $148.7 million with help from the loan Rugby purchased.

The German commercial bank Helaba hired Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm to sell the note in November after Shorenstein struggled to manage its real estate holdings in the wake of the pandemic.

JLL previously stated that the loan was non-performing “due to an event of default caused by the borrower’s failure to pre-fund interest through maturity.”

Best and final bids on the note were due shortly after the new year. According to JLL, aspects of the deal allowed Rugby to take immediate ownership of the property.

Mr. Stauber led “a local development group” that moved quickly to secure the deal, with plans to “revitalize the Grant Street corridor,” he said in the release.

Advertise with us

In 1992, Mr. Stauber began investing in Downtown with the restoration of the Gimbels building. Though based far from the Golden Triangle, his firm has shown a commitment to the region, upping the occupancy of multiple local buildings, including the Ewart building and 11 Stanwix, formerly the Westinghouse headquarters.

In partnership with the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust, Mr. Stauber also helped reimagine Penn and Liberty Avenues, now home to housing, retail space, restaurants and entertainment.

“When people give up on buildings, that’s when we step in,” Mr. Stauber said.

Rugby already has a hand in two major projects of the city and state’s extensive, $600 million plan to revitalize Downtown, announced last October.

Working with New York City-based Left Lane Development, Rugby plans to convert the 44-story Gulf Tower — the former home of Gulf Oil — into 225 apartments and a 126-room luxury hotel, a $200 million undertaking. The group will also turn its office building at 933 Penn Ave. into 70 apartments.

Advertise with us

The Golden Triangle’s office vacancy rate is high, currently hovering around 19%, due to hybrid work policies and tenant downsizing since the pandemic.

That, paired with a major change in the county’s calculation of taxable value, has spurred steep assessment cuts to high-profile buildings that are eroding Downtown’s tax base — a cause for concern in City Hall, which is dependent on property tax revenue.

‘Pittsburgh stands at a pivotal moment’

After buying One Oxford Centre in 2016, Shorenstein put $40 million towards renovations. But the building is only around 65% leased, and became the third prominent Golden Triangle property to see a massive cut in its assessment for the 2025 tax year in February.

The county approved a $25.9 million cut, bringing the building’s new taxable value to $54 million.

That’s a 59% decrease in value over just six years, and the third reduction since 2019.

Advertise with us

The county’s decision followed major assessment cuts to Fifth Avenue Place, the 31-story headquarters of Highmark Health, and Penn Avenue Place, the former Horne’s department store building.

On those three buildings alone, cuts could cost the city, county and Pittsburgh School District $2.6 million in revenue for the 2025 tax year.

Downtown represents about a quarter of Pittsburgh’s tax base, and historically property tax revenues have been a cornerstone of the city’s finances. But Mayor Ed Gainey in his 2025 budget projected that property tax revenues will decline in each of the next five years.

The three taxing bodies are already paying the price for over half a billion dollars in assessment rollbacks over the past several years, to the tune of more than $11 million in lost revenue.

Rugby’s plan to improve One Oxford’s occupancy could revitalize the building, and help recoup Downtown’s tax base.

Advertise with us

“Pittsburgh stands at a pivotal moment,” Mr. Stauber said. “The city can build on Governor Shapiro’s Downtown investment by providing residents, small businesses, and investors with the confidence that core services — public safety and cleanliness — will be consistently delivered.

“My sleeves are rolled up, and I’m ready to get to work.”