Once a mighty symbol of Pittsburgh’s second renaissance, One Oxford Centre is now emblematic of the woes facing Downtown.
The 45-story skyscraper at 301 Grant St. is currently bracing for new ownership through the sale of a $72.6 million outstanding loan. More than a third of it is vacant in the fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic.
And last week, the Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review approved a $25.9 million cut in its taxable value for 2025, bringing its new assessment to $54 million.
That’s a far cry from the $132 million it was just six years ago. Thursday’s reduction was the third for the distinctive octagon-shaped office tower in that time. The taxable value was previously slashed to $118 million and $80 million by the Common Pleas Court board of viewers.
One Oxford Centre is the latest in a string of Downtown office buildings to get significant assessment cuts because of rising vacancies and a steep drop in the number used to calculate taxable value at appeal hearings.
At the same time, the decreases are slowly eroding the Downtown tax base, which has been battered by more than half a billion dollars in assessment rollbacks in the past several years.
Read More
That, in turn, has cost the city, the county and the Pittsburgh School District more than $11 million in revenue. Overall, the district has estimated that assessment reductions in Downtown and elsewhere in the city have resulted in about $20 million in refunds the past three years.
James M. Berent, the attorney who represented One Oxford Centre owner Shorenstein Properties in all three assessment appeals, said the reductions were based on appraisals obtained for the real estate.
He noted that office trends in general factored in. Many Downtown buildings, including One Oxford, are struggling with high vacancy rates spawned, at least in part, by hybrid work policies in the fallout from the pandemic.
The latest reduction will drop One Oxford Centre’s taxable value from $80 million to $54 million. Combined, it will cost the city, the county, and the school district about $642,807 in revenue.
It was the result of a hearing during which the property owner and the taxing bodies had the opportunity to present evidence to a hearing officer, whose recommendation is then reviewed by an assessment board member before it goes to the full board for approval.
The decision also came as the building itself is gearing up for a change of ownership through the sale of the $72.6 million loan on the property. A group headed by Aaron Stauber, president of New Jersey-based Rugby Realty, is believed to be the successful bidder for the note.
While the loan carries a face value of $72.6 million, it is expected to be sold at a significant discount, with some real estate sources predicting it could go for about the same price as the new building assessment.
Shorenstein has owned the property since 2016, when it bought it for $148.7 million. German commercial bank Helaba hired the Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm in November to sell the loan as San Francisco-based Shorenstein struggled to maintain control over its real estate empire after the pandemic.
Closing on the sale of the loan is expected to occur within the next few weeks.
Mr. Stauber currently owns three other landmarks on Grant Street — Gulf Tower, which is being converted into apartments and a luxury hotel, the Koppers Building, and the Frick Building, as well as a number of other properties in Downtown.
He could not be reached for comment Monday.
The other big factor in the assessment reductions, both on the commercial and residential sides, has been a dramatic drop from 87.5% to 52.7% in the common level ratio used to compute taxable value at appeal hearings. The number is used to account for widening disparities in the assessment system since the last revaluation in 2012.
At the 87.5% ratio, a property whose market value is determined to be $100,000 would be assessed for tax purposes at $87,500. But at the current 52.7%, it would be assessed at $52,700.
One Oxford Centre is the third prominent Downtown property to get a big cut in its assessment for the 2025 tax year.
Last month, the taxable value of the 31-story Fifth Avenue Place, headquarters of Highmark Health, was slashed by $63.4 million to $40.5 million. The cut involved two separate parcels owned by Highmark or its real estate arm.
In December, the assessment board sliced the taxable value of Penn Avenue Place, the former Horne’s department store building, by $18.3 million to $30.5 million. The property at 501 Penn Ave. is owned by HTA-Penn Ave LLC and leased exclusively to Highmark, which is responsible for paying the real estate taxes.
On those three buildings alone, the assessment cuts total $107.6 million for the 2025 tax year and could cost the three taxing bodies $2.6 million in revenue.
With Downtown representing about a quarter of Pittsburgh’s tax base, the plunging property values have fueled concerns in City Hall about the budgetary fallout.
In his 2025 budget, Mayor Ed Gainey projected that property tax revenues, for the first time in recent history, will decline in each of the next five years, the Post-Gazette reported in December.
Councilwoman Erika Strassburger has described the trend as troubling. “Historically, real estate revenues have been the cornerstone of our city finances, and we cannot permit them to enter an indefinite state of decline,” she wrote to her colleagues at one point.
After the $63.4 million cut in the taxable value of Fifth Avenue Place, a senior Gainey administration official stated that the Office of Management & Budget and the Department of Finance “actively monitor” appeal cases to determine their impact on the city’s revenues and to “inform spending decisions within the parameters” of the 2025 budget.
The official noted that changes in taxable value made by the assessment board can be appealed to the board of viewers in Common Pleas Court and that the full effect of the appeal decisions won’t become clear until the third quarter when the city incorporates the data into its initial revenue forecasts for the 2026 budget.
“We do not anticipate immediate disruptions to any city functions as a result of these appeals,” the official stated.
Meanwhile, the Allegheny Institute for Public Policy reported recently that commercial land and building values countywide fell by 3.8% to $25.16 billion for 2025.
Commercial values in the city fell even more — by 4.1% to $9.64 billion. They dropped by an even greater percentage in 35 other municipalities, the institute stated.
Overall, assessed property value countywide lowered by 0.1% to $107.54 billion in 2025. The institute said it was the first time since 2014 that taxable assessed value decreased year over year.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.