Despite an unfavorable court ruling, the Pittsburgh School District isn’t abandoning its fight to force a property reassessment in Allegheny County.

The district plans to appeal a judge’s ruling last week throwing out the lawsuit it had filed to compel the county to reassess all of its 586,000 properties, solicitor Ira Weiss said Tuesday.

In a ruling Thursday, visiting senior Judge Kenneth Valasek in the county’s Common Pleas Court stated that the district did not have standing, or the legal right, to bring the lawsuit against the county.

He also appeared to side with the county in its argument that the district could resolve any budgetary shortfalls caused by assessment appeals and refunds simply by raising taxes.

Advertise with us

The district has estimated that assessment reductions, including those involving large Downtown office properties, have resulted in $20 million in refunds over the last three years.

In his ruling, Judge Valasek noted that the district hadn’t raised taxes in four years. If it had done so by one mill this year, it would have raised $19 million for the district, he stated.

“The district allowed the refunds to impair its financial condition (the ultimate harm caused by the refunds) because it chose not to act,” he wrote. “This choice in four consecutive years was the cause of any degrading of the district’s financial condition.”

But Mr. Weiss took issue with that stance Tuesday.

“We believe it is amply shown that the district has suffered real financial harm. We cannot accept the notion that raising taxes is a remedy for an illegal assessment system,” he said.

Advertise with us

He added that a tax increase under such circumstances only makes matters worse and unfairly adds to the burden of those taxpayers who are already paying more than their fair share in taxes because of inequities in the assessment system.

One of the big factors in the assessment reductions the last couple of years has been a sharp drop from 87.5% to 52.7% in the common level ratio used to compute taxable value in appeal hearings. The number is used to account for growing disparities in the assessment system since the last revaluation in 2012.

The district also disagrees with the notion that it doesn’t have standing to pursue its litigation against the county. Mr. Weiss said that “decades of court precedence dictate that a taxing body has standing to challenge” issues involving uniformity in assessments.

“We have serious concerns about the process by which the court reached the decision and the analysis. While I respect the court’s decision, we believe that it deserves appellate review,” he said.

Judge Valasek wrote in his opinion that the state’s uniformity clause as it relates to property assessments was designed to “protect taxpayers, not taxing authorities.”

Advertise with us

While municipalities and school districts have won lawsuits to force reassessments in other cases, in none of those was the issue of standing raised, Judge Valasek stated.

He also ruled that the district had not shown that it had a “direct,” “immediate,” and “substantial” interest in the case — all legal requirements, he said, needed to show that it was an aggrieved party.

Mr. Weiss said he expects the district’s appeal to be filed in the state’s Commonwealth Court in a matter of days. It has 30 days to file an appeal from the date of Judge Valasek’s ruling.

A county spokeswoman declined comment Tuesday.

Churchill property owner Flavia E. Laun also has filed a lawsuit in Common Pleas Court to force a countywide reassessment. She, too, is represented by Mr. Weiss.

Judge Valasek of Armstrong County was assigned to preside over the district’s lawsuit after all Allegheny County judges recused themselves.