Another prominent Downtown building is getting a big cut in its assessed value for 2025, the latest in a wave of reductions issued over the past several years upending the city’s tax base.
Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review members on Thursday approved an $18.3 million drop in the taxable value of Penn Avenue Place, known to many Pittsburghers as the former Horne’s department store.
With the reduction, the building’s assessment will tumble by 37.4%, from $48.8 million to $30.5 million. It will cost the city, the Pittsburgh schools, and the county a combined $420,900 in tax revenue.
According to Allegheny County real estate records, the property at 501 Penn Ave. is owned by HTA-Penn Ave LLC. It is leased exclusively to Highmark Health, which uses the building for office and meeting space.
Highmark also is obligated to pay the property taxes under its lease, meaning it will benefit from the reduction. Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger said that “to the best of my knowledge, the [appeal] process was led by the landlord.”
Penn Avenue Place is far from the only Downtown building to see its taxable value slashed in the past few years, in part because of high office vacancies stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic.
Read More
But another major factor has been a steep drop in the ratio used to compute taxable value at assessment hearings. It has plunged from 87.5% to 52.7%, making it easier for property owners to win decreases.
Overall, more than 16 Downtown properties, including some of its biggest skyscrapers, have won assessment cuts totaling more than half a billion dollars in the past three years. Combined, they have cost the city, the Pittsburgh schools, and the county more than $11 million in revenue.
Among them has been BNY Mellon Center, the city’s second-tallest building, which saw its assessment plummet by $90.2 million, or 60.1%, to $59.6 million.
Other buildings to receive big cuts include U.S. Steel Tower, PPG Place, Tower at PNC Plaza, and EQT Plaza.
For the 2025 tax year, the Penn Avenue Place reduction seems to be one of the largest so far. It will take effect in January.
But Mike Suley, a property assessment board member, said there are still appeals involving a number of high-end commercial properties that have yet to be decided. He didn’t know how many of those were located in Downtown.
He noted some of the properties have current taxable values upward of $30 million.
“The bottom line is that there will be more,” he said. “There will be some significant reductions.”
The cuts in Downtown, which represents about a quarter of the Pittsburgh tax base, have played havoc with the budgets of the city and its school district.
This year, the city collected about $151.8 million in property taxes. It is estimating that the amount will fall to about $143.8 million in 2025. The number is projected to continue dropping over the next five years as a result of appeals.
For the Pittsburgh schools, the situation is just as bleak. According to one court filing, appeal results have cost the district more than $10 million in refunds in the 2022 through 2024 tax years.
The district has filed a lawsuit to force the county to conduct a countywide reassessment, which would eliminate the need to use the common level ratio to address inequities in the system. That litigation is still tied up in Common Pleas Court.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.