A $30 million proposal to remake a block of Eighth Street in Downtown’s Cultural District has cleared its first hurdle.

Pittsburgh Planning Commission members unanimously approved a request by the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust Tuesday to raze a Goodyear Auto Service store at 800 Fort Duquesne Blvd. that is standing in the way of the revamp.

Also Tuesday, the commission backed plans for the construction of a six-story apartment building with up to 240 units on Railroad Street in the Strip District.

The Cultural Trust paid $1.9 million for the Goodyear store in 1997. The demolition will allow the arts nonprofit to create a large lawn along Eighth Street between Penn Avenue and Fort Duquesne Boulevard that can be used for concerts, festivals and other events such as the Three Rivers Arts Festival.

Advertise with us

Other elements of the $30 million plan totaling 3.6 acres include a children’s play area, an outdoor bandshell and a possible expansion of the Giant Eagle Foundation Backyard, a space that now features live music, pickleball courts and fashion boutiques.

The Cultural Trust wants to move quickly to demolish the Goodyear store so that it can have the improvements in place in time for the 2026 NFL draft, which will be held in Pittsburgh.

It also is planning sidewalk upgrades along Penn Avenue between Sixth and Ninth streets (and possibly Stanwix) and on Seventh, Eighth and Ninth streets between Penn and Fort Duquesne.

Asked by commission member Steve Mazza about plans to remediate the Goodyear site, a representative for the Cultural Trust said Goodyear is obligated under its lease “to leave us with a clean building.”

He added that in corings and drillings completed so far, “we haven’t found any big surprises that you wouldn't expect in an urban area.” The Cultural Trust hopes to start the demolition in the spring.

Advertise with us

The Eighth Street rehab is part of the nearly $600 million plan unveiled by Gov. Josh Shapiro in October to rescue Downtown. That initiative also includes the conversion of six buildings to residential and other improvements.

In the Strip, the new six-story apartment building is being developed by Oxford Development Company and Steel Street Capital Partners, whose principals are Brandon and Ryan Guy, sons of former Oxford Development CEO Steve Guy.

Of the 240 units planned, 48 would be studios, 142 one-bedroom and 50 two-bedroom. As part of the project, Oxford and Steel Street are also providing 84 parking spaces, including 46 off-site adjacent to the development. In addition, 83 bike spaces are planned.

The apartment project is part of the second phase of Oxford’s sprawling 3 Crossings development along the Allegheny riverfront. It already has built a six-story office building and converted a warehouse for office uses.

Also Tuesday, the commission tabled proposed transit-oriented zoning map amendments involving areas in Polish Hill, Sheraden, Crafton Heights, Beltzhoover, and Mount Washington after listening to extensive opposition from residents in the affected neighborhoods.

Advertise with us

During a hearing spanning several hours, residents voiced concerns about the impact the proposals would have on their properties and the character of their neighborhoods, and in some cases expressed fears about potential flooding or landslides resulting from development in areas currently zoned for hillside.

In the end, the commission decided that the plan needed more work and more input from those who live in the affected areas.

Commission member Steve Mazza said residents are “worried. They’re scared.”

“I think we need to go back to the drawing board and work on this a little bit more and get a little bit more input,” he said.

Mel Ngami, another commission member, said that, while she’s a fan of transit-oriented development, “I do think that hearing all of the comments today, there definitely needs to be rework and there needs to be a conversation that is had.”

Advertise with us

Commissioner Phillip Wu noted the city may have to change its approach and limit transit-oriented development to commercial parcels adjacent to busways or light rail rather than going  into residential neighborhoods.

While TOD is a “laudable goal,” there “needs to be some additional community involvement and some additional information provided,” Commissioner Rachel O’Neill added.