Vice President Kamala Harris’ $25,000 down payment assistance plan for first-time homebuyers is stirring up Pennsylvania’s political landscape, with voters mostly split along party lines, according to a new survey.

While 64% of Pennsylvanians back her idea to tackle housing affordability, the divide is clear: 81% of Democrats are all-in, while Republicans are nearly split, with 47% in favor and 53% opposed, according to a survey by the Program For Public Consultation at the University of Maryland.

“In the swing states, bipartisan majorities want the federal government to pursue an active and multi-pronged approach to deal with the high cost of housing,” said Steven Kull, director of PPC.

As housing affordability has become a major issue for many Americans, the PPC survey in Pennsylvania, five other swing states and the country as a whole, finds majority support for the federal government taking a variety of actions to make housing more affordable, especially for low and middle-income households.

Advertise with us

The proposals include providing billions in grants and tax incentives for building and repairing affordable homes; providing down payment assistance to first-time buyers; reducing large corporate ownership of houses; incentivizing local governments to reduce single-family zoning restrictions; and increasing the number of public housing vouchers.

The 300 block of Suncrest Street in Knoxville on Nov. 24, 2020 (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

This survey is the tenth, and last, in a series — the Swing Six Issue Surveys — being conducted in the run-up to the November election in the swing states of Pennsylvania, Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, and Wisconsin, as well as nationally, on major policy issues.

Unlike traditional polls, respondents in a public consultation survey go through an online “policy simulation” in which they are provided briefings and arguments for and against each policy proposal.

Respondents were informed that the federal government currently provides some funding and tax incentives for building more affordable homes, mostly for low-income households. They were told that housing is considered affordable when it costs the household no more than 30% of their income to live there.

They then evaluated a series of proposals for the federal government to do more to increase the supply of affordable homes. Each one was favored by bipartisan majorities in Pennsylvania, the five other swing states and nationwide.

Advertise with us

Support for $40 billion to build or repair affordable housing for low-income people and provide more low-interest loans to homebuilders was favored by 71% in Pennsylvania, including majorities of Republicans (62%) and Democrats (83%). Across all swing states support ranged from 69-73%, and nationally support was 74% (Republicans 63%, Democrats 86%).

A tax credit for building or repairing housing to be rented, on the condition that 60% of them are affordable to middle-income households, was favored by 73% in Pennsylvania (Republicans 64%, Democrats 82%). Across all swing states, support ranged from 69-73%, and nationally it was 73% (Republicans 63%, Democrats 85%).

“Government at all levels must work to expand non-market housing options,” said Jackie Smith who researches housing affordability as a University of Pittsburgh sociology professor.

“This is the only way that we can begin to rein in the growth of housing costs and ensure all residents have access to affordable housing,” she said.

The $25,000 down payment assistance proposal is a cornerstone of Ms.Harris’s political platform in her race for the White House against former President Donald Trump.

Advertise with us

Across all swing states, support for the down payment assistance plan ranged from 63-68%, including strong majority support among Democrats (81-87%), but with mixed views among Republicans. Nationally, 67% were in favor, including 84% of Democrats, and a bare majority (52%) of Republicans.

Two proposals for reducing large corporate ownership of single-family houses were favored by bipartisan majorities in Pennsylvania.

Requiring corporations with more than $50 million in assets to sell all their single-family houses, town homes and duplexes within the next 10 years and prohibit them from buying more, was favored by 67% in Pennsylvania (Republicans 58%, Democrats 77%.) Denying corporations that own more than 50 single-family houses, town houses and duplexes any federal tax deductions for their ownership of the properties was favored by 68% in Pennsylvania (Republicans 58%, Democrats 79%.)

Respondents were informed that, according to experts, one reason that housing has become less affordable is that local governments restrict building dense and mixed-use housing. They were told that the federal government — when distributing funding for infrastructure repair — has started giving priority to local governments that allow more dense and mixed-use housing.

A majority — 56% — in Pennsylvania were in favor of the federal government continuing that policy, including 72% of Democrats, but just 42% of Republicans.

Advertise with us

When respondents were informed that the government provides people who qualify for public housing — very low-income, disabled or elderly people — with housing vouchers that help cover rent in the private market, a bipartisan majority of 72% in Pennsylvania favored increasing the number of people who can receive vouchers by allocating an additional $24 billion.

Republicans favored the increase by 60%. Democrats supported it by 85%. Across all swing states, support was 69-72%, and nationally it was a bipartisan majority of 74% (Republicans 63%, Democrats 87%).