One of Downtown’s most prominent office complexes is facing possible foreclosure, another sign of the mounting woes of some building owners in the city’s core.

Wells Fargo Bank has filed a foreclosure action against Hertz Gateway Center LP, listed as the borrower for the four-building Gateway Center property at 401-444 Liberty Ave., built during Pittsburgh’s first renaissance in the 1950s.

In a lawsuit filed Oct. 16 in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, Wells Fargo claimed that Hertz defaulted on a $84.3 million mortgage loan by not paying some operating expenses and by not taking care of four liens placed against the property.

As part of the action, the bank seeks a “public sale” of the 1.6-million-square-foot complex at the entrance to the Golden Triangle from the Fort Pitt Bridge.

Advertise with us

In a separate filing seeking to have the cases assigned to the court’s commerce and complex litigation center, Wells Fargo said the parties had consented to having the CBRE real estate firm serve as the property’s receiver.

It added that the parties “may also wish to pursue a potential sale of the Gateway Center by the receiver to a third party on terms and conditions authorized and approved by the court.”

“The Gateway Center is facing urgent operational and financial challenges that [Hertz] is not in a position to address,” it said.

In a statement, Timothy McCarthy, executive vice president of development for Hertz Investment Group, described the foreclosure filing as “mandatory for a lender to appoint a receiver in Allegheny County.”

“We’re working very closely with the special servicer of the loan and consented to them appointing a receiver as we continue to work on a loan modification,” he said.

Advertise with us

“We are committed to the asset but needed to work with our lender partners to be certain our tenants continue to be provided the services and professional property management they’re rightfully entitled to. They’re our priority and will continue to be so while we work on the financing end of the deal.”

Gateway Center is the third Downtown office property to be the subject of a foreclosure action since the start of the year.

In January, a lender moved to foreclose against McKnight Realty Partners, owner of the historic Grant Building on Grant Street, after claiming that it defaulted on a $38 million loan in part because it had failed to extend or renew the lease of key tenant Huntington National Bank.

That case is pending in Common Pleas Court. Huntington has since cut a deal to move its offices to the Strip District.

Also in January, Common Pleas Judge John T. McVay Jr. signed an order entering a judgment in mortgage foreclosure totaling $58.9 million against One Oliver Associates Limited Partnership, owner of the 37-story K&L Gates Center at 210 Sixth Ave.

Advertise with us

In a stipulation and consent motion filed days before the order, lender Pacific Life Insurance stated that the owner had “agreed to cooperate with plaintiff with respect to the foreclosure and subsequent foreclosure sale” of the property “without admitting any of the factual” assertions of the case.

Despite that, there’s no evidence that the property has been sold. According to the Allegheny County real estate website, the skyscraper still remains in the hands of One Oliver Associates.

In the foreclosure filing against Gateway Center, Wells Fargo claimed that Hertz “had acknowledged in writing that there are more than $5 million in unpaid operating expenses for the property.”

They included invoices for engineering operations, security and other services “that borrower has characterized to lender as ‘critical’ and ‘necessary for the health of operations and collateral.’”

The bank said Hertz’s “failure and/or refusal to comply with its covenants to maintain the property in a good and safe condition and repair and to pay when due all bills and costs for operation of the property constitutes a default under the mortgage and the loan agreement.”

Advertise with us

Wells Fargo also maintained that Hertz defaulted by not taking care of four mechanic liens totaling $88,927 filed by plumbing companies since May.

The action comes at a time that Hertz has been trying to convert the 25-story Three Gateway office building into residential use. The owner has emptied out that structure while seeking to consolidate office uses in the other three buildings within the complex.

There have been growing concerns about possible loan defaults and foreclosures in Pittsburgh and elsewhere because of high office vacancies spawned by the COVID-19 pandemic and hybrid work.

Earlier this year, a study prepared by the CBRE real estate firm estimated that more than two dozen Downtown buildings were either approaching foreclosure or at the risk of it.