Maybe the third time will be the charm for the owner of Station Square.
New York-based Brookfield Properties has put the South Side restaurant, entertainment, and office complex up for sale, the third time in the last 12 years it has hit the market.
The listing comes at a time when the sprawling real estate on the Monongahela riverfront next to the Smithfield Street Bridge has struggled to regain its mojo coming out of the COVID-19 pandemic, which had a devastating impact on retail and office properties alike.
A Brookfield spokeswoman confirmed Monday that the property is for sale but declined further comment.
Brookfield has owned Station Square since 2018, securing it in the $11.4 billion acquisition of Forest City Realty Trust. Three years later, it put the property up for sale but never secured a buyer.
In 2012, Cleveland-based Forest City Enterprises had hired the CBRE real estate firm to begin marketing the 52-acre, 669,800-square-foot complex to potential buyers.
Read More
Less than a year later, it decided to retain the real estate, with a spokesman saying then that Forest City “didn’t see the values that we thought the property really merited.”
For many years, Station Square was a premiere Pittsburgh destination, drawing tourists and locals with its dancing fountains, vibrant retail and restaurants, entertainment, and office space.
That included the likes of the Freight House Shops, an eclectic mix of retailers and restaurants; the stately Grand Concourse restaurant, an old railroad station; and Commerce Court, which include offices, retail and restaurants.
The complex, a former Pittsburgh and Lake Erie railroad terminal, was transformed by the Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation, which still has its offices on the property.
But in more recent years, Station Square has had a harder time maintaining its popularity amid competition from the North Shore and SouthSide Works on the other end of the South Side.
After acquiring the property in 2018, Brookfield invested $30 million into the complex in hopes of injecting new life and vitality into it.
It brought in Tupelo Honey, a North Carolina-based restaurant that specializes in fried chicken and other Southern favorites to anchor a 5,000-square-foot spot at the Station Square entrance.
In addition, it landed First Ascent, a Chicago-based climbing and fitness gym to take a 35,000-square-foot spot inside the Freight House Shops. But it has been unable to fill a prime 36,500-square-foot space in the southeast corner that UPMC had planned to use for a training center. The Pittsburgh-based hospital giant has since put the space up for sublease.
At the same time, Brookfield has had some wins on the office side, with insurance company New York Life announcing in April that it was moving from North Fayette to a 45,000-square-foot spot in Commerce Court.
Besides the Grand Concourse, Station Square still retains restaurants like Hard Rock Cafe, Joe’s Crab Shack, the Gandy Dancer, the Melting Pot, and Texas de Brazil. In June, Buca di Beppo closed its doors after 25 years at the location. It was the last Buca di Beppo in the region.
Herky Pollock, a CBRE executive vice president who has done retail brokerage work at the complex in the past but who no longer is involved, described Station Square as an iconic property — but one in need of a makeover.
The retail component, he said, “needs to be fully updated, with many of the older restaurants replaced, so as to make it competitive with all of the new offerings surrounding it in the urban core.”
“The office has done quite well. The retail has struggled to gain traction as many of the existing restaurants are older and as such they date the perception of the overall project. This is simply a re-tenanting issue,” he added.
Station Square also is home to the Sheraton Station Square Hotel, Highmark Stadium, the Gateway Clipper, and the Glasshouse Pittsburgh apartments. All of those are separately owned and not part of the sale.
Michael Connor, market leader for Hanna Commercial Real Estate, said securing an office tenant like New York Life may help Brookfield in selling the property.
Mr. Pollock also sees “plenty of upside for a redevelopment,” noting that there is land on the east side of Station Square surrounding the Glasshouse that can be developed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.