Houses in Pittsburgh’s luxury real estate market aren’t just holding their value, prices are appreciating more than the national average, according to Zillow.
“We’re still having brisk sales in the luxury price range,” said Georgie Smigel, a Coldwell Banker real estate agent in Cranberry.
According to Zillow, the value of the average luxury home in Pittsburgh is $839,418. The online service defines the luxury market as the priciest 5% of homes in the region.
Pittsburgh’s most elite home market saw values jump by 5.3% over the past year, which is just shy of the 5.5% growth in value for mid-tier homes in Pittsburgh, the average of which is $217,285, according to Zillow.
Nationwide, Zillow found luxury home values are actually rising faster than typical homes, which is not usually the case.
“Luxury homes can be challenging to sell because the pool of buyers is so much smaller. That’s one reason prices for them usually grow more slowly,” said Anushna Prakash, a research scientist at Zillow.
According to Zillow, the average price of a luxury home across the U.S. was about $1,620,000. But metro-specific values ranged from less than $750,000 in Buffalo to more than $5.3 million in San Jose.
In Pittsburgh, luxury home sales over the past year have actually been stronger than the year before.
West Penn Multi-List records show 640 properties sold for more than $839,000 over the past year. Sellers received 96% of their asking price and homes took 65 days on average to sell.
In 2022, the previous year, 565 luxury properties sold in the Pittsburgh region and got 96.7% of the asking price after 54 days on the market.
“Homes are still selling. But if they don’t sell right away, sellers are decreasing the price,” said Kim Marie Anguilli, a Coldwell Banker real estate agent who specializes in the high-end market north of the city.
“For any price range, if a home is still not under contract within two weeks, or they haven’t had multiple showings or second showings, then I feel it needs a price adjustment,” Ms. Anguilli said.
Julie Welter, a Compass Realty agent in Upper St. Clair, said she has found that one big difference between typical buyers and luxury buyers is that the latter group isn’t afraid to lowball offers.
She said luxury homes that are large with amazing lots and great locations, but need updating, don’t appreciate as much as newer properties.
“They are tracking at like a 3% to 6% appreciation rate,” Ms. Welter said. “But homes that are perhaps newer construction or have been recently updated are seeing insane rates of appreciation.”
One Upper St. Clair home she sold in newer condition appreciated 55% over two years of ownership, she said.
Other luxury listings have sat on the market for months and taken price cuts. One of her listings for $2.2 million has been reduced to $1.99 million after two months on the market.
Sales numbers across the whole market are down in general since interest rates climbed from around 3% to the 7% level, she said.
“Buyers lost a lot of their buying power,” Ms. Welter said. “The ones that started looking when rates were exceptional are having a harder time coming to grips with the reality of what they can now afford.
“Somebody originally looking at a $600,000 house can maybe afford a $400,000 house now,” she said. “That’s a big drop.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-779-5834






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.