A lengthy fight over who was responsible for the cost of improvements to the main scoreboard at Acrisure Stadium before the 2018 football season is finally over.
PSSI Stadium LLC, an affiliate of the Pittsburgh Steelers, and the Sports & Exhibition Authority have agreed to settle the dispute for $850,000 — less than the $1.2 million the team originally sought in arbitration.
The settlement comes four months after arbitrator Gary P. Caruso concluded that the SEA was obligated to pay for the improvements. But in doing so, he capped the damages the Steelers could receive at $964,015 and rejected their request for nearly $300,000 more in pre-judgment interest.
Furthermore, the SEA, the stadium owner, challenged at least $142,109 in costs included in the $964,015. That would have required further litigation had there not been a settlement.
Rather than returning to arbitration to hash out the remaining issues, the authority decided it was in its best interest “to reach a mutually agreeable settlement” that would limit further liability and conclude the case, Executive Director Aaron Waller said Monday.
He noted that the SEA believed its arguments, as they related to the Steelers’ stadium lease and the $142,109 in costs still being contested, were correct. And he stressed that the authority was not admitting liability or suggesting that its stance was in error in making the deal.
Read More
“We felt there was a need to settle,” he said.
Had the SEA not settled and won on the disputed costs, the most the Steelers could have received was $821,906.
“We’re glad it’s over and we’re happy to be moving forward,” an Acrisure Stadium spokesperson said.
The dispute started before the 2018 season when the team made $3 million in improvements to the main scoreboard at the south end of the stadium, then known as Heinz Field.
In the work, the Steelers, through PSSI, expanded the size of the scoreboard’s video board to 41 feet by 124 feet from 30 feet by 95 feet and enhanced the picture quality.
But the authority balked when the team sought repayment for the expense, claiming that the improvements it made represented a major expansion of the scoreboard and didn’t qualify as repairs eligible for reimbursement under the lease.
The SEA cited a clause in the lease that defines capital repairs in part as “major repairs of components to the communications system and the scoreboard (including the control room, message board, video board, bulbs, and circuit breaker panels).”
It agreed to reimburse the Steelers $1.8 million to cover the cost of replacing the 30-foot-by-95-foot screen with one of equal size and to pay for the higher picture quality.
The team’s case, on the other hand, hinged on another clause in its Acrisure lease, which stated that capital repairs shall not include “upgrades to components of the scoreboard more frequently than once every seven years.”
Steelers’ attorneys argued that the word “upgrade” could mean an increase in size, thus making the video board eligible for reimbursement.
Mr. Caruso ultimately sided with the Steelers, finding that the expansion did, in fact, constitute a capital repair under the lease.
The Steelers at first wanted $1.2 million in reimbursement from the SEA. But they later dropped the amount to $964,015, making the dispute eligible for arbitration. Under the lease, conflicts involving more than $1 million must be contested in the public courts.
However, in deciding to go to arbitration, the team limited itself to a maximum of $964,015 in damages, Mr. Caruso ruled.
Although the SEA claimed the Steelers sought arbitration to avoid having the fight “heard in a public court of law,” a charge the team denied, the authority agreed to the request.
The settlement comes as the two sides ready themselves for negotiations over a new or extended lease at Acrisure Stadium. The Steelers’ current lease is set to expire in 2031.
Steelers President Art Rooney II has said that the team has hired consultants to assess the stadium, which opened in 2001, and determine what improvements are required in order to stay there "for the next 10, 20 years, whatever it's going to be."
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.