More than a decade ago, PNC Financial Services Group stepped in to rescue a historic Downtown bank building that had been vacant for nearly eight years after being converted into a Lord & Taylor department store.

PNC intervened to buy the former Mellon Bank in 2012 after Lord & Taylor closed in 2004, just four years after it opened and the then-owner failed to land another department store or retailer to use it.

Twelve years later, the building at 500 Smithfield St. is empty again, and it’s now PNC struggling to fill the once-glorious bank hall stripped of much of its grandeur in the department store makeover.

After acquiring the property for $3.85 million, PNC converted the four-story building into a call center, taking care to restore as much of the old bank’s splendor as possible, from original bronze chandeliers to marble check-writing desks.

Advertise with us

At one time, up to 800 employees worked there. But in 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic emptied out the building. Four years later, it is still vacant amid hybrid work policies and rising office vacancies in the Golden Triangle.

According to real estate sources, PNC is now trying to find a taker for the building and is perhaps even willing to virtually donate it if it finds the right user. It does not list the building for sale or for lease on its website.

PNC had little to say about the situation. In an email, a spokeswoman stated only that bank officials “are currently evaluating our strategy for the Smithfield building.”

She did not respond to a separate email asking how many, if any, people are still working there. However, a man who was servicing the former call center Wednesday said it has been empty since 2020.

Four years ago, Bill Demchak, PNC chief executive officer, said that the bank was planning to put its technology workers in the space. But that apparently never happened.

Advertise with us

PNC’s focus on the building comes at a time of renewed attention on Smithfield Street, which has been plagued by concerns about safety, open drug use, lewd behavior, and homelessness the past couple of years.

Wiener World, a longtime Smithfield Street staple, moved to U.S. Steel Tower recently because of such concerns. Another Smithfield business, Fragasso Financial Advisors, relocated to Sewickley.

The PNC building is located across the street from a vacant seven-story office building owned by Cleveland-based Stark Enterprises. Both are next to the redeveloped Kaufmann’s department store, which includes retailers Target, Five Below and Burlington, a hotel, and several hundred apartments.

Herky Pollock, a CBRE executive vice president who specializes in retail, said a repurposing of 500 Smithfield would help to jump start the corridor.

“Given the fact that three of four corners at the most prominent epicenter of Downtown Pittsburgh are currently dormant, to reactivate that building would have intrinsic value, not only to Downtown but more specifically to the Smithfield Street corridor,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Pollock added that redevelopment of the Stark-owned building at 441 Smithfield coupled with a new start for the former PNC call center “would be tantamount to repairing a hole in someone’s heart as it is ground zero of Downtown Pittsburgh.”

“The importance of what PNC has done for the vitality and stability of Downtown starting with [former CEO] Jim Rohr and continuing with Bill Demchak cannot be overstated,” he said.

PNC has been active in revitalizing Downtown, building its new headquarters, the Tower at PNC Plaza, on Wood Street and Three PNC Plaza on Fifth Avenue. In both cases, the developments removed a blighted section of the Golden Triangle.

In addition to 500 Smithfield, the bank owns One PNC Plaza, Two PNC Plaza, and Firstside Center in Downtown. PNC has also redeveloped several buildings on Wood Street opposite its headquarters, including one it is leasing to Pittsburgh police for a Downtown substation.

When it became interested in the former Mellon Bank on Smithfield Street, the building had been boarded up since November 2004 when Lord & Taylor closed.

Advertise with us

Mellon’s cathedral-like bank hall with its marble columns and floors and brass and bronze accents was turned into a Lord & Taylor as part of former Mayor Tom Murphy’s bid to revitalize the Fifth and Forbes retail corridor. City officials sank $11.8 million into the deal to lure the department store, which never gained a foothold in the market and closed amid declining sales and shopper indifference.

The conversion itself proved to be highly controversial, with preservationists lambasting the destruction of the bank’s interior to reshape it for department store use.

Arthur Ziegler, former president of the Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, claimed that Lord & Taylor “jackhammered the marble floor and marble columns to smithereens.”

Years later, when PNC bought the building, Mr. Ziegler lauded the move, saying that PNC would be using it in such a way that “it will be a noble architectural anchor on that corner.”

The 500 Smithfield property is not the only bank building in Downtown facing an uncertain future.

Advertise with us

At the 54-story BNY Mellon Center, BNY has been systematically moving employees out of the building to its service center behind it.

The decision has raised concerns about the future of the city’s second tallest skyscraper since BNY rents all of the building and its lease expires in 2028. Some believe it could be entirely empty by then.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.