In 2017, the University of Pittsburgh lost out to Walnut Capital in the bidding for the iconic Pittsburgh Athletic Association clubhouse across from the Cathedral of Learning.
Seven years later, Pitt may be on the verge of securing the vacant Fifth Avenue property — from the very same developer.
Shadyside-based Walnut Capital is close to a deal to sell the building to the university, according to local real estate sources.
The possible sale comes after the developer spent $25 million to rehab the seven-story Oakland landmark it secured for $12.6 million in the bankruptcy reorganization of the PAA, a longtime private social and athletic club.
Todd Reidbord, Walnut Capital president, declined comment on a possible sale. Pitt would not specifically say whether it was pursuing a purchase.
"The University of Pittsburgh continually explores and works to optimize campus properties to support academic and student life needs. Without commenting on any specific ongoing discussions, we continue to follow that approach as it relates to properties on or near our campuses,” spokesman Jared Stonesifer said Wednesday.
Read More
That the university is interested in buying the real estate is no surprise.
In 2019, it had reached a deal with Walnut Capital to take 30,199 square feet of office space in the clubhouse under a 15-year lease that was approved by its board of trustees’ property and facilities committee.
At the time, Pitt had planned to move its Learning Research and Development Center, part of the School of Education, into the space. It also was looking at other “strategic relocations.”
The university planned to start occupying the building in June 2020. But then the COVID-19 pandemic hit in March of that year, and Pitt ended up not taking the space.
In the aftermath, Walnut Capital struggled to attract other tenants in an office market shredded by the pandemic. It’s one that continues to be plagued by high vacancies and soft demand.
There were also some near misses.
At one time, Apple was considered a prime candidate to take about 90,000 square feet in the 130,000-square-foot building before it decided to move into the Assembly, a converted eight-story building at 5051 Centre Ave. in Bloomfield.
The developer also had been in talks with InnovatePGH, a public-private partnership focused on tech development in Oakland, about using space on one floor as an incubator to connect Fortune 50 companies with students and researchers at Pitt, Carnegie Mellon and other universities.
Given the office woes, Walnut Capital last year considered switching gears, scrapping its original plan in favor of a mixed-use development that included higher-end condominiums and restaurants.
It estimated at the time that the building could house 20 to 30 condos, depending on the layout and the demand. It was banking on the location being a big selling point given that the property is situated in the heart of the Pitt and UPMC campuses in Oakland.
But in the end, the developer decided that the building, listed on the National Register of Historic Places, was more suited for office use.
Besides the Cathedral of Learning, Pitt owns a number of other properties near the PAA, including the Twentieth Century Club about a block away. It acquired that property in 2020 for $4.9 million.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.