When the White House announced in October that more than $35 billion could be available to help to convert office buildings to apartments, some Downtown property owners saw it as a possible lifeline.

Then they read the fine print.

And what they discovered was a program that looked good on paper, but not in practice because of some of the strings attached — ones they say would make it virtually impossible to use the money for the very conversions it targets.

“I call this a rotten carrot. The White House presented something that looked like a tasty carrot but when you bit into it, [it wasn’t],” said Aaron Stauber, president of Rugby Realty, which owns the iconic Gulf Tower and a number of other properties Downtown. “It feels like they didn’t properly investigate what really goes into our deals.”

Advertise with us

Now Mr. Stauber and other local stakeholders, including City Council, have teamed up in a bid to try to persuade the Biden Administration and the U.S. Department of Transportation to make changes to the program so that it will be more palatable for developers and building owners.

Without swift changes, “the precipice of ruin awaits southwestern Pennsylvania’s epicenter and living space,” Mr. Stauber warned in a letter to President Joe Biden and Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.

The target is the Railroad Rehabilitation and Improvement Financing program. In October, the Biden Administration announced that more than $35 billion would be available through that initiative and the Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act to help with office-to-residential conversions near rail lines and transit-oriented developments.

For some Downtown property owners and developers struggling with high office vacancy rates caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, the loan program seemed to be tailor-made for the kind of residential conversions they’ve been considering.

The fact that such a large pot was becoming available at a time of high interest rates and construction costs made it even more appealing. And any building Downtown within a half mile of the Amtrak Station at the end of Grant Street qualified — meaning just about all of them.

Advertise with us

But optimism soured over some of the RRIF program requirements.

For one, closing on a loan could take up to 18 months — far beyond the normal six-month closing time developers experience with private banks and other lenders.

The current rules also require those doing a conversion to set aside more than $1 million to hire RRIF consultants to review the plans.

Jonathan Kamin, an attorney who is helping Rugby and other Downtown property owners in the bid to change the guidelines, said such an amount is exorbitant, particularly given that engineering and architectural plans for the types of projects involved rarely amount to more than $300,000.

Regulations also call for a full National Environmental Policy Act review of proposed residential conversion projects. Mr. Kamin said such reviews can take years and typically involve major projects such as pipelines or highways.

Advertise with us

He said there is no need for such an extensive review for a change in building use from office to residential. He and other stakeholders are urging the White House to grant exceptions in such cases or allow more basic environmental reviews that can be done in weeks.

“All of this stuff is not changing the footprint. In fact, reuse of an existing building is one of the most green . . . things you can do. You’re not ripping down a structure to build a new structure. You’re using what is there,” he said.

The current regulations make the program “completely unusable and economically unfeasible for many of the projects it is designed to support,” Mr. Kamin emphasized.

“We’re trying to get the bureaucrats to realize that the regulations they created make it all unworkable,” he added.

In its resolutions backing changes to the guidelines, City Council stated that more than $300 million in conversion projects Downtown are shovel ready, with the potential for that number to increase to $1 billion.

Advertise with us

Changes in the regulations that stakeholders would like to see include reducing the loan closing period to six months and bringing oversight costs in line with typical commercial lending practices.

Mr. Stauber said he would like to take advantage of the funding for the proposed conversion of the Gulf Tower into 190 to 215 residential units and a 150- to 170-room luxury hotel.

He also is looking at turning an eight-story building at 933 Penn Avenue into roughly 55 apartments and another structure in the Cultural District into a boutique hotel.

In a letter to Mr. Biden and Mr. Buttigieg, Mr. Stauber said the $35 billion being offered to help fund such conversion projects is sorely needed.

Given current economic conditions, “soliciting conventional private investment without substantive governmental backing remains an insurmountable feat,” he stressed.

Advertise with us

But at the same time, changes need to be made to the regulations to make the program appealing to property owners and developers.

“These proposed alterations would not only ensure our commitment to convert current properties, but would unequivocally prompt myself and other property owners to embark on additional building conversions and vacant-building acquisitions,” he wrote.

The U.S. Department of Transportation’s Build America Bureau, which is overseeing the initiative, did not return an email seeking comment.

Mr. Stauber said he did speak to a bureau official recently who was interested in hearing about the changes he and other local stakeholders were recommending.

“This is one significant tool in the toolbox,” he said of the program. “It’s not the only tool. Without it, there are other tools the city and the state can implement that would allow projects to proceed. But in my opinion, they have to work faster.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Stauber and others have also been pushing the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority to finalize a tax abatement program designed to help with building conversions. However, the way it’s currently structured “does not lend itself to a purposeful use,” Mr. Stauber noted.

The tools are needed, he said, in order to help stabilize a Downtown office market reeling because of high vacancy rates. In its resolution, City Council stated that many Downtown buildings are “facing the prospects of foreclosure, significant potential declines in property tax revenue, and an overall lack of market vitality.”

In urging the White House and the Department of Transportation to make changes to the RRIF regulations, Mr. Stauber also noted that some Downtown buildings have already won hundreds of millions of dollars in property assessment reductions because of the woes they are facing. That could result in a “disastrous loss of our Downtown tax base,” he said.

“These are common sense changes that would allow the program to be used,” Mr. Kamin said. “We just think the regulatory authorities put these provisions in without understanding the market.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com