A proposal to convert a building that housed the last Downtown McDonald’s into a bank will require a special order.
Huntington National Bank is scheduled to go before the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment Dec. 7 to seek the variance needed to open a branch at 500 Liberty Ave.
For half a century, a McDonald’s filled up the site, serving Big Macs, Quarter Pounders and Egg McMuffins to Downtown workers, students and late-night denizens. It outlasted every other McDonald’s in Downtown before closing last spring after the fast-food chain decided against exercising two five-year options in its lease.
Nick Nicholas, the owner of the property, then negotiated and signed a lease with Huntington to take over the space.
But before the bank can move forward with its plan, it first must obtain the variance before the zoning board.
According to the zoning board agenda, the relief is required because in the Golden Triangle zoning district “only retail sales and service and restaurant uses shall be located with direct access from a street. Bank with direct access to street proposed.”
It’s unclear why a bank branch is not considered a retail sales or service use. Banks and financial institutions are permitted by right in the zoning district.
Mr. Nicholas said he didn’t need a variance to open Chase Bank and Bank of America branches in two former restaurant spaces in Market Square just a block from the Huntington spot.
“I have no idea what this is about,” he said.
In an email Wednesday, city zoning administrator Corey Layman stated: "The code makes a distinction between the use categories of Bank or Financial Institution and Retail Sales & Services. It's possible that standard was missed in a review of prior applications. That wouldn't make it any less of a requirement for a new application."
In a project description and variance justification statement, Huntington stated that the zoning code defines retail sales and service uses as “an establishment engaged in the sale or rental of goods or services.”
It noted that it refers to its branches as “retail banking facilities.”
“While it is not a traditional retail use, Huntington’s customers enter the establishment to make an in-person transaction or meet with a teller, and then leave. The use is similar in nature to a retail store,” the bank stated.
It added, “Our development team feels like the proposed facility is consistent with the goals of the zoning code.”
Huntington further stated that the project will improve the appearance of the building and the pedestrian experience at the Liberty and Stanwix intersection “while respecting the historic character of the building.”
Improvements to the old McDonald’s include a repainting of the building’s roof, reconfiguration of its main entrance on Stanwix, a new door and window on the Liberty Avenue side and updated lighting.
“We feel the redevelopment will transform the western entry point into the Market Square Historic District,” the bank stated.
The project also required the approval of the city’s historic review commission. Mr. Nicholas had hoped to have the branch up and running by the start of 2024.
Laura Trendler, a planning and zoning consultant for Huntington, estimated that the project would take three to four months to finish once the required city approvals are secured.
Mr. Nicholas purchased the property in 2022 for $2.4 million. His other Downtown holdings include Nicholas Coffee & Tea Co. in Market Square as well as the Chase and Bank of America spots.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.