The homeless shelter at the Smithfield United Church of Christ is gone. And now the fate of the historic church itself may be hanging in the balance.
Faced with the need for extensive renovations and repairs beyond the reach of its small congregation, the church has launched a bid to survive while hoping to become a spark in reviving Smithfield Street.
“We want to stay a part of Downtown Pittsburgh. We would love to be more active and to give more,” congregation President Jeanette Thomas said.
The church that baptized H.J. Heinz has embarked on a “planning process” to ensure that the building at Smithfield Street and Strawberry Way “will be preserved and rehabilitated to continue its historic role as a key resource in the life of Downtown Pittsburgh,” officials said.
It’s reaching out to various stakeholders — including the city, the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, the state, and local foundations — to try to plot a strategy for moving forward.
The effort comes at a time when the church building, designated as a landmark by the Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, is facing substantial capital and repair needs. The facade has been wrapped in a protective netting since 2007 to prevent deteriorating precast concrete from breaking off and falling to the sidewalk. The building’s radiator and ventilation systems date to 1925 and the small elevator inside is not accessibility-compliant and will have to be relocated to bring it up to current standards. The roof also needs work.
Jon Colburn, parish administrator, said a study commissioned 12 years ago put renovation and repair costs at $10 million. He estimates they would be at least $20 million now.
“It’s a substantial chunk of change,” he said.
Ms. Thomas said the 139-member congregation does not have the means to raise such a large sum.
Given that, the “ideal goal” would be to find a partner who could help with improvements and repairs and find supplemental uses for the building while allowing the congregation to continue to worship there.
“We are actively seeking assistance, partners, creative ways to use the building and give back to Pittsburgh. We want to be an active partner with the city. This is not our expertise,” she said. “So we are starting to talk to anyone and everyone that will talk to us about what do we do next, what direction do we take with the building, what are the next steps, what is God calling us to do next.”
The 96-year-old church building, which dates to 1927, is perhaps best known for serving as a cold-weather shelter for homeless people for years. Amid controversy over homelessness in Downtown, the county shut down the shelter in June and has no plans to reopen it, church officials said.

“If they had wanted to keep the shelter here, we would have kept the shelter,” Ms. Thomas said. “The decision was made not by us to close the shelter.”
While the church itself did not operate the shelter, it provided the space in the basement to house about 140 people each day and received rent from the county in exchange. That revenue has now dried up. And although it is not nearly enough to cover the church’s substantial capital needs, “I would say for a small congregation, it’s an absolutely big hit,” Ms. Thomas said.
At the same time, officials see a potential partnership as a way to bring new life — and new revenue — to the building. The magnificent sanctuary, with its soaring vaulted ceiling and stunning stained glass windows, is considered “one of the acoustically finest rooms in the city,” Mr. Colburn said.
One possibility would be to team with someone to program the space for musical performances or concerts when it is not being used for worship. Another, particularly with the gym and second floor office and classroom space, could be some type of youth programming.
“The ultimate goal is that we can continue to worship here yet also work with someone else to utilize the rest of the building. That’s the goal,” Ms. Thomas said.
However, without a white knight, she questioned whether the church would be able to survive another 10 years.
“I would tell you with the size of this congregation and the size of this church, we cannot continue endlessly,” she said.
Ms. Thomas acknowledged that another option could be selling the property on which the church building sits. The land, which stretches from Strawberry Way to Sixth Avenue and Smithfield to Montour Way, was given to the congregation in 1787 by the Penn family.
In addition to the church, the real estate holds a building owned by McKnight Realty Partners that includes the Downtown branch of the Carnegie Library, a Brooks Brothers store, and offices. The lease McKnight has for its building runs another 46 years.
“If we cannot afford the church and we can’t make this work, eventually we would have to, at some point, look at the possibility of selling it,” Ms. Thomas said. “That would be an absolutely last, last resort.”
Izzy Rudolph, McKnight president of development and acquisitions, acknowledged that the firm is having conversations with the church about a possible long-term partnership. But he stressed the talks are very preliminary. He declined further comment.
Given the condition of the church building and the cost of a potential rehab, a sale could also raise the specter of a possible demolition.
“That’s not even on my radar at this point. I don’t even want to think about that,” Ms. Thomas said. “We aren’t ready to talk about that yet. I think that’s what McKnight would want to do but I’m not there.”
She and Mr. Colburn view the church as an architectural gem that is very much worth keeping. It was designed by noted Pittsburgh architect Henry Hornbostel. The stained glass in the sanctuary portrays a mix of biblical scenes and church and Pittsburgh history.

The building’s steeple, made of aluminum with steel supports, was the first architectural use of aluminum in the world, according to the church. Several bells in the belfry came from Europe more than 100 years ago.
In addition, the church for many years operated as the German Evangelical Reformed Church. At one point, the German Savings and Loan bank used part of the building.
“This is such a significant building in this city. It’s all J&L Steel. The steeple was made by the Aluminum Corporation of America before it was Alcoa. It’s an outstanding architectural feat in this city,” Mr. Colburn said.
He can’t imagine it ever being razed.
“I tell people I have an edifice complex because I love this building,” he said.
For now, church officials are hoping for a far different path. They have formed a committee that includes members of the congregation and architect Rob Pfaffmann to explore potential options. They hope to get help from foundations in funding that effort.
They also are consulting Sustainable Solutions for Sacred Sites, an organization that helps churches develop creative reuses for their buildings. And they want to include Downtown stakeholders and big players like PNC in helping determine “what the best use would be.”
It hopes to have a plan of salvation in place sometime next year. With a born-again building, the church believes it can play a key role in reviving a section of Smithfield that has fallen on hard times.
“We want to be the catalyst to Smithfield Street becoming great again,” Ms. Thomas said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.