As West Mifflin’s abandoned Century III Mall falls further into disrepair, a series of court hearings has been scheduled that could decide the fate of the once-teeming shopping center and hold its owner, Century III Mall PA LLC, accountable for dangerous conditions.

The first hearing — scheduled for 8:15 a.m. Tuesday in the City-County Building in Downtown — concerns the mall’s appeal of $240,000 in fines for repeated code violations levied by District Judge Richard D. Olasz Jr.

A status conference is slated for the following Monday regarding the mall’s appeal from West Mifflin Borough council members’ unanimous vote in July to condemn the structure, a decision they hoped would lead to demolition. As part of that appeal, a judge will comb through evidence on the building's condition to either uphold or reverse the mall’s condemnation status.

At the court date on Tuesday, officials including Code Enforcer Jefferey Youkers plan to present the borough’s case, providing testimony showing the mall’s slew of hazards: rampant mold and structural vulnerabilities, among others. Mr. Youker’s testimony will largely resemble the evidence presented at June’s condemnation hearing in council chambers.

Advertise with us

“Unfortunately, we still have to go plead our case all over again,” he said.

Borough officials had hoped that the two cases would be combined, but that has yet to happen.

The hearings this month are merely a small step in the ongoing battle between borough officials and the mall’s owner, and will likely lead to a chain of appeals between the two camps — potentially all the way up to the state supreme court — leaving the structure deteriorating in the borough’s center for the foreseeable future.

At June's initial condemnation hearing, where officials presented evidence of the mall’s mounting safety hazards, executives promised to address the mall’s most urgent problems.

Chief Operating Officer Shawl Pryor said the company would put up a fence along the building’s perimeter to deter trespassers. That has not happened. And just last week, another trespasser posted a YouTube video showing their adventures through the mall’s barren remains.

Advertise with us

This summer, a teenager fell through the roof and sustained serious injuries. The mall still has not patched the hole.

Two months ago, the roof caved in where a fire had raged in April. No repairs have been made.

The exterior of the closed Century III Mall taken from a drone on Thursday, May 11, 2023, in West Mifflin. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Other than hiring a few security guards, “they’re not doing anything,” said Dan Davis, a West Mifflin Borough council member, who voted in July to condemn the mall.

Borough officials estimated that demolishing the structure could cost $10 million to $15 million, but the building could further decay as rainy conditions and frigid temperatures set in.

“It just deteriorates. And the more water you have in there, you’ve got rusting, erosion of materials, ceiling tiles getting wet. They drop down,” Mr. Davis said. “It's not an improvement with the temperature drop. Freeze-thaw cycles are starting to come in here, too.”

Advertise with us

The two cases could play off of each other. Mr. Davis said borough officials plan to weaponize the mall’s nonpayment of the code enforcement fines in the condemnation case, arguing that the company has failed to comply with local ordinances and put a strain on borough resources.

In 2018, the mall was fined $80,000 for high growth of weeds. The company has yet to pay the fine, records show.

Now — a decade after Century III Mall PA LLC bought the mall with promises to revitalize it — the situation has escalated to such a crisis that West Mifflin council is trying to solicit help from higher-up officials. Mr. Davis said he has spoken to county executive candidate Sara Innamorato and Lt. Gov. Austin Davis, but would not disclose details of those conversations while the cases are ongoing.

As the legal battles trudge along, some officials say there’s no end in sight.

“With their record, how many years we’ve been dealing with these issues,” Mr. Youkers said. “I just don’t feel that it’s going to be taken care of.”

Advertise with us

Neena Hagen: nhagen@post-gazette.com

Correction, posted May 28, 2025: In an earlier version of this story, the owner of Century III Mall was identified incorrectly. The earlier version’s description of upcoming court proceedings regarding the mall was clarified. The earlier version also included a summary of a fine imposed in 2018, which has been corrected as to the entity fined and the reason for the fine.