The struggling Pittsburgh Mills Mall in Frazer Township could soon get a new landlord.

The 1.1 million-square-foot shopping center — once vibrant and teeming with shoppers — is headed for sheriff’s sale on Oct. 2 at the Allegheny County Courthouse. A prospective buyer willing to pay $11.5 million and additional fees would inherit 31 tenants, fewer than half the vendors the shopping center had at its peak.

“The township is hopeful that the sale will produce an owner that can reimagine and breathe new life into the property in a way that creates new sustainable jobs and complements the success of the surrounding commercial parcels,” said Lori Ziencik, Frazer Township’s manager.

Local officials pursued a sheriff’s sale because owner Namdar Realty has failed to pay more than $11 million in special assessment bills, leaving the locale with a gaping hole in tax revenue. Frazer has pursued three cases against the building’s owners since 2021 for tax delinquency, but the company has yet to make payments.

Advertise with us

“We are working to have this resolved prior to the October 2nd auction,” a Namdar Realty Group representative said in an email to the Post-Gazette. “Our firm highly values the Pittsburgh Mills Mall and the surrounding community, it holds a significant place in our portfolio. As this process plays out, the day-to-day operations of the mall and its tenants will not be affected.”

Pittsburgh Mills opened to much fanfare in 2005 with big-name anchor stores such as Kaufmann’s, JC Penney and Sears. It attracted millions of visitors, and for years, every storefront was full.

The Pittsburgh Mills Mall in Frazer Township (Evan Robinson-Johnson)

While Pittsburgh Mills still has some big name brands such as Bath and Body Works, Macy’s and Dick’s Sporting Goods, the mall has been in perpetual decline for the past decade. The site faced foreclosure in 2015 and was bought by Wells Fargo in 2017 for $100 before New-York-based Namdar Realty swooped in a year later and paid $11.35 million.

The mall has only spiraled since then. It was about 30% vacant in 2018, but that figure has jumped to 47% today, according to CBRE, the real estate broker facilitating next month’s sale.

Last month, Ms. Ziencik called Namdar an “absentee landlord.”

Advertise with us

Private companies have also levied complaints against Namdar. Colliers Real Estate sued the company for failure to pay commission for helping the mall sign a lease with a tenant, and a Common Pleas judge ordered Namdar to pay Colliers $290,000. Macy’s sued the mall owner in June for allegedly breaking a longstanding financing agreement. The parties agreed to settle the dispute for $2 million.

Namdar has followed a similar playbook in other cities, failing to pay taxes and utility bills, and evading demolition orders for multiple shopping centers.

Locally, retailers in the mall are on edge, worrying what could happen to their businesses after the upcoming sale. A future buyer could carry out a new vision for a site, and that could mean anything from maintaining the shopping center as is or razing the entire facility and starting anew.

“We work really hard to drive people here,” said Matthew Frank, an associate at Amish Home furniture store. “We’ve been here for a long time and we plan on staying here.”

He added that a lot of vendors are “trying to survive” and customers have called repeatedly to ask about that mall’s future.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Mills is one of thousands of struggling malls. Retail centers across the country have weathered blow after blow because of the rise of online shopping and closures caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.

“It’s a shame what happened to this mall,” Mr. Frank said. “It has great potential.”

Neena Hagen: nhagen@post-gazette.com; Ciara McEneany: cmceneany@post-gazette.com