In 2013, executives from Moonbeam Capital Investments LLC traveled to West Mifflin to discuss the acquisition of Century III Mall.
Century III Mall PA LLC acquired the mall in 2013 and has long been associated with Moonbeam’s real estate network.
Companies in Moonbeam’s real estate network charged into communities across the country a decade ago with lofty plans to redevelop shopping centers that had spiraled into financial turmoil.
Companies associated with Moonbeam’s real estate network included a pages-long catalog of properties, promising a sports complex near Syracuse, N.Y., a strip of restaurants just outside Atlanta and a gleaming new movie theater in Baton Rouge, La.
In several communities, officials hailed Moonbeam’s arrival as a chance to revive retail meccas that once drew millions of visitors.
In all, the Moonbeam network of companies included more than a dozen flailing malls.
But like the abandoned Century III Mall, other properties acquired by companies associated with Moonbeam’s network as heralded acquisitions have turned into shuttered, empty shells.
“It was calculated deception,” said Kerry Mannion, an official near Syracuse who jousted with the company for years over its local mall. “We all had a better chance of winning the MegaLotto than Moonbeam ever doing anything.”
Today, some of troubled sites where Moonbeam’s network pledged transformations are plagued by collapsed roofs, shattered windows, barren lots — desolate eyesores that have contributed to crime and blight.

In five of the retail centers, including those in West Mifflin, Ohio, Georgia, New York and New Jersey, the properties associated with Moonbeam’s network have followed a well-worn script.
Company executives presented wide-ranging redevelopment plans to local officials, but didn’t break ground or even maintain the structures, all while taking in rent from tenants and accepting hundreds of thousands in federal funds to keep their business afloat, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette has found.
Moonbeam Capital mall properties Moonbeam Capital's network is associated with several crumbling malls across the country. Most were bought by Moonbeam-associated companies a decade ago.
Research: Neena Hagen | Source: Moonbeam website and real estate records
When confronted by officials, the companies associated with Moonbeam’s network have frequently countered with lawsuits against the local governments and have also filed bankruptcy for three different malls, according to records and interviews with officials in several areas.
At Century III Mall, it’s been a similar pattern of broken promises and escalating safety concerns since the facility shuttered permanently in 2019, straining first responders and depleting borough resources. Currently, local officials are locked in a bruising battle with Century III Mall PA LLC to compel repairs or tear down the crumbling structure.
“We’re going down the same road,” West Mifflin Councilman Dan Davis said in an interview. “That’s what’s scary.”
Borough council will likely vote to condemn the mall at a public meeting Tuesday, clearing a path to demolition. The mall’s attorney James Berent and Shawl Pryor, who has been identified in bankruptcy records as holding leadership roles for both Century III Mall PA LLC and Moonbeam, did not respond to requests for comment.
In bankruptcy filings, Moonbeam Equities X, LLC, a Moonbeam subsidiary, was identified as the owner of Century III Mall PA LLC until August 2018, and Beacon Commercial Limited and Bizmax Investments Limited were identified as the new owners. Both of those entities disclose in Nevada corporate records that Moonbeam Leasing & Management LLC, a Moonbeam subsidiary, is their registered agent. Moonbeam Leasing & Management LLC has also provided management services to Century III Mall PA LLC after the ownership transfer, according to bankruptcy filings.
‘Largest absentee landlord’
Based in Las Vegas, Moonbeam boasts on its website a “debt-free” real estate inventory of over 14 million square feet — a wide array of residential, commercial, retail and office spaces.
But records and interviews about the real estate network and its practices tell a different story. In several cities, companies once associated with Moonbean have left a trail of liens, unpaid property taxes and code violations.

At Century III alone, courts have imposed hundreds of thousands of dollars in fines against Century III Mall PA LLC for varying code violations. At Salem Consumer Square just outside Dayton, Ohio, the company operating the property, Salem Consumer Square OH LLC, has been slapped with a $3 million lien. Salem’s ownership changed in 2019, but a bankruptcy judge found that Moonbeam did not sever its connections with Salem Consumer Square OH LLC, according to an opinion in Salem’s bankruptcy proceedings.
At ShoppingTown Mall near Syracuse, the company that owns the mall and has long been associated with Moonbeam’s network failed to pay property taxes, racking up debt close to $10 million. Bankruptcy filings claimed Moonbeam Equities XI, LLC was the sole owner Shoppingtown Mall NY LLC until the end of 2018, with Steven Maksin remaining as CEO until the end of April 2019. Mr. Maksin is Moonbeam Capital Investments LLC’s CEO.
After the transfer, bankruptcy filings also indicated that Shoppingtown Mall NY LLC was then controlled by AT Realty Holdings, LLC and Beacon Commercial Limited. Both of those entities disclose in Nevada corporate records that Moonbeam Leasing & Management LLC, a Moonbeam subsidiary, is their registered agent.
“They were our community's largest absentee landlord for years,” Ryan McMahon, Onondaga County executive, said in an interview. Originally, the company was expected to be “a great asset for our community.”
When Shoppingtown Mall NY LLC bought ShoppingTown for $14 million in 2013, U.S. Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., swept into the small suburb to tout the news as a major victory — an opportunity to stimulate a once-vital organ of the local economy that had gone anemic.
“I also plan to do anything I can in facilitating the redevelopment of this tax-revenue generating site,” he said. A decade later, the mall has not generated any tax revenue and has now lost all of its tenants.
In 2013, the mall, though struggling, was still two-thirds full. A Moonbeam employee swiftly sent sketches for local officials showing plans for expanded office space and sweeping renovations. But nothing materialized.

In 2018, as the company approached five years of tax delinquency, Mr. Mannion, the town’s deputy supervisor, pressed Moonbeam executives for an updated proposal. What they submitted after more than six months of pushing was largely the same as the first sketch, but with a few store names erased, according to interviews and records obtained by the Post-Gazette.
At one point, a company executive promised to renovate a library that had left the mall more than a year prior.
“If you gave it to a high school graphics class, they would have done a better job,” Mr. Mannion said.
Months later, as the county tried to put the mall up for tax sale, Shoppingtown Mall NY LLC, the entity associated with Moonbeam’s network, filed for bankruptcy, delaying the sale by more than two years.
By the time the county purchased the property in 2020 for $3 million, a fraction of what Shoppingtown Mall NY LLC initially paid, the roof was leaking and pipes had burst — likely a “teardown project” for the next owner, said Mr. McMahon.
“They bled the property and never invested back into it,” he said.
The penchant for companies associated with Moonbeam’s real estate network buying high and selling low also baffled real estate experts.
“This business model does not make any sense,” said Mr. Mannion, who also has 35 years of experience in commercial real estate. “There's no end game. There's no plan.”

‘A big box just sitting there’
In one poor community, another property associated with Moonbeam’s network has become an albatross.
At Salem Consumer Square in Trotwood, Ohio, a town where one in four residents lives below the poverty line, inaction by Salem Consumer Square OH LLC has left a hulking eyesore in the center of town.
In 2019, a tornado ripped off part of the roof and shattered windows. Executives from Salem Consumer Square OH LLC told a judge in a bankruptcy filing that they would rehab the crumbling structure, but to this day, “We haven’t seen anything," said Quincy Pope, the city manager.
“It's very frustrating for the community at large,” Mr. Pope said. The mall is “a big box just sitting there … and people want to see some redevelopment.”
In Georgia, another property associated with Moonbeam’s network, Gwinnett Place Mall GA LLC, operated the Gwinnett Place Mall. At one point, that mall became so lightly trafficked that the corpse of a 19-year-old woman went unnoticed for two weeks.
While Moonbeam’s network lacked investment in many of its properties and surrounding communities, many companies associated with its network or Moonbeam Capital Investments LLC’s CEO, Mr. Maksin, were granted more than $800,000 in federal money amid the COVID-19 pandemic under the Paycheck Protection Program, a Post-Gazette data analysis found.

‘Are we gonna do something?
Questions continue to abound over the future of Century III Mall. There were suggestions that the mall was near closing with a potential buyer, but borough officials said they haven’t heard anything since, and no necessary tax paperwork to facilitate the sale has been submitted, records show.
During last month’s condemnation hearing, where officials presented reams of evidence detailing the mall's safety hazards, residents expressed outrage over the lack of progress. More than 60 community members packed the borough’s council room, and a dozen or more lined the walls.
A week earlier, a teenage trespasser had fallen through the structurally unsound roof — which the mall failed to repair — sustaining critical injuries, but is expected to recover.
“That mall used to be one of the prime places to go … now it looks like crap,” Bernice Nylander, a lifelong West Mifflin resident, said to council. “You guys are doing nothing.”
“If one of your kids falls through the roof and is killed, then are we gonna do something?”
In April, a fire tore through the food court, drawing dozens of fire crews from across Western Pennsylvania. Century III Mall PA LLC has yet to address problems with its fire suppression system that West Mifflin notified the mall of in 2019.
The company has pledged to put up fences to deter trespassers, but that has yet to happen.
Since the mall closed four years ago, police have been dispatched to the facility nearly 200 times, police Chief Gregory McCulloch testified.
Throughout the hearing, Ralph Ciffaretto, a 19-year-old West Mifflin resident, shook his head as the testimony poured out.
Century III was a “very rare, very special place. I remember it was always full,” he said. “Now you could drive a whole tractor through there.”
With pressure mounting, the deteriorating building could soon face its end. After Tuesday’s meeting, where council members are likely to vote to condemn the mall, they plan to petition county and state officials for funds to raze what’s left of the monstrosity — leaving a massive void where millions once gathered.
Dave Marshall, former president of the West Mifflin Area School Board, says it’s time.
“Seeing this kid getting hurt. Seeing how this disaster has affected our whole community,” he said. “We’ve seen enough.”
Neena Hagen: nhagen@post-gazette.com
Correction, posted May 28, 2025: In an earlier version of the story, the owner of the Century III Mall was identified incorrectly. Additional details in the story have been updated to clarify Moonbeam Capital Investments LLC’s relationship with other malls identified in the story. The description of prior Paycheck Program Protection analysis has been clarified to better describe the entities referenced in that analysis.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.