The future of a Shadyside church — to tear it down or let it stand — will not be decided just yet.

A hearing Friday before Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg, who had been asked to issue a temporary restraining order over a developer’s plans to demolish the 133-year-old Shady Avenue Church, concluded after three-plus hours of testimony, but more testimony to come. The hearing will resume July 17.

East Liberty Valley Historical Society is asking for the temporary restraining order to stop Beatrice Icon LLC from tearing down the church at 241 Shady Ave., and for a suspension of the demolition permit issued by the city in May.

The preservation group argues that the developer failed to give proper notice of its intent — no “placard of intent to demolish” was physically seen posted at the property from April 17 when Beatrice Icon applied to raze the structure until June 8, the group argues — and that the city didn’t make sure that it did.

Advertise with us

Jason Lardo, head of Beatrice Icon, denied the allegations. In an interview with the Post-Gazette last month, he said that “everything was posted properly” and that the placard was posted twice “just for good measure.”

“We did things the right way,” he said.

On Friday, however, the first two witnesses called by the plaintiff were local photographers who presented dozens of photos of the old church that they took when they heard it might be demolished.

No placard of intent to demolish could be seen in any of them.

Architect Rob Pfaffmann also testified that he tried repeatedly to get information on the status of the church from the city, but his emails went unanswered for weeks. After receiving no response to his May 4 email, he said, he tried again on May 25 and only then was he notified that a demolition permit had already been issued by the city’s Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections.

Advertise with us

Named as defendants in the 32-page lawsuit are Beatrice Icon and the city. Their alleged failures in not ensuring the demolition permit posting occurred left the preservationist group and four other plaintiffs, including Mr. Pfaffmann, in the dark about the developer’s intentions.

Three more witnesses will testify for the plaintiff when the case resumes at 1 p.m. July 17.

According to the East Liberty Valley Historical Society, the church was built in 1890 as the Shady Avenue Cumberland Presbyterian Church at a cost of $20,000. The architect, Thomas Cox McKee, was inspired in part by the design of Henry Hobson Richardson’s Allegheny County Courthouse.

In 1911, an addition to the church was erected after the congregation outgrew the original building. In 1964, after membership declined, the building was sold to the Italian Christian Church of Pittsburgh. It worshiped there until 2015, when it sold the building to Beatrice.

Mark Belko contributed. Emma Kim: ekim@post-gazette.com