A preservation group has gone to court to block the proposed demolition of the Shady Avenue Church in Shadyside, claiming that the developer failed to give proper notice of its intent and that the city didn’t make sure that it did.

East Liberty Valley Historical Society is asking for a temporary restraining order to stop Beatrice Icon LLC from tearing down the 133-year-old church at 241 Shady Ave. and a suspension of the demolition permit issued by the city in May.

In the 32-page lawsuit, the group claimed that it had no idea the church was in danger because no “placard of intent to demolish” was physically seen posted at the property from April 17 when Beatrice Icon applied to raze the structure until June 8.

That’s even though the city building code requires an immediate posting after an application has been submitted, it stated.

Advertise with us

The complaint also accused the developer of not posting the demolition permit issued by the city on May 19. The alleged failures, both by Icon and the city in not ensuring the posting occurred, left the group and four other plaintiffs, including architect Rob Pfaffmann, in the dark about the developer’s intentions.

Named as defendants in the Allegheny County Common Pleas Court lawsuit are Beatrice Icon and the city.

Jason Lardo, head of Beatrice Icon, denied the allegations. He said that “everything was posted properly” and that he has records to support his statement. In fact, he maintained it was posted twice “just for good measure.”

“We did things the right way,” he said.

Mr. Lardo said his original intent after purchasing the property in 2015 for $350,000 was to preserve it after discovering that his grandmother and both great grandmothers attended the church.

Advertise with us

He maintained that he abandoned that path only after finding that the church was structurally unsound.

“It’s near and dear to my heart,” he said Tuesday. “I’m a lover of old buildings and structures. I do everything I can to save them. Sometimes it doesn’t work out.”

East Liberty Valley Historical Society and the other plaintiffs filed the complaint and moved to get the restraining order after they stated they were advised Monday that Sarah Kinter, director of the city department of permits, licenses, and inspections, was lifting a “stop order” that prevented any demolition.

According to the complaint, she did so after receiving a “secret ‘affidavit’” that showed Beatrice Icon had properly posted the church property. The stop order had been issued by a city inspector earlier in June after church windows were removed.

“The PLI director has no legal authority to make a judicial determination based solely on her receipt of ex parte secret evidence, received from an alleged violator, and then find the defendant Icon ‘not guilty’ of failing to post the 241 premises, lifting the stop work order, and allowing demolition to continue at close of business 6/26/23, all to the great harm and detriment of plaintiffs,” the lawsuit stated.

Advertise with us

That allegation is one of several the lawsuit makes regarding the city’s handling of the church matter.

It also maintained that the city’s historic review commission staff has “unjustifiably delayed and have ‘pocket vetoed’” its application to nominate the church as a city historic structure, which would prevent its demolition if approved.

According to the complaint, the plaintiffs submitted an application for the nomination May 26. It stated the HRC under law has 45 days to make a preliminary determination, meaning it should be on the commission’s July 5 agenda. But so far, the staff has refused to add it, it claimed.

The lawsuit further alleges that Ms. Kinter had an obligation to investigate the plaintiff’s allegations that Beatrice Icon had not posted notice of its demolition permit application.

PLI’s “failure to require applicant Icon to provide proof of its posting placard notices, and its numerous failures to even reply to inquiries as to the status of the demolition permit application equitably [bars] the city, city planning, and the director of PLI from now claiming the plaintiffs’ HRC application is ‘late’ and ordering HRC staff to refuse to place it on the agenda for July 5, 2023,” it stated.

Advertise with us

There is no statute of limitations on such HRC filings, according to the request for the temporary restraining order.

The lawsuit further claims that Mr. Pfaffmann emailed various city staffers about the status of the demolition permit on May 4 but did not receive a response from anyone until June 7.

Because of the various alleged failures, the plaintiffs had no way of knowing that the demolition permit had been applied for and issued, the lawsuit stated.

They are asking a judge for a temporary restraining order to halt the demolition until their application for a historic nomination of the church gets “proper treatment” from the HRC. The complaint also asks for injunctive relief.”

“Should the court refuse an injunction, and the demolition take place under PLI’s proposed order, the city, the East Liberty community and the plaintiffs will forever be deprived of the benefits of having the 241 Shady premises declared by the city HRC to be a historic structure,” it stated, adding that the church already is designated as a historic structure under state Historic and Museum standards.

Advertise with us

Olga George, spokeswoman for Mayor Ed Gainey, declined comment on the lawsuit.

According to the East Liberty Valley Historical Society, the church was built in 1890 as the Shady Avenue Cumberland Presbyterian Church at a cost of $20,000. The architect, Thomas Cox McKee, was inspired in part by the design of Henry Hobson Richardson’s Allegheny County Courthouse.

In 1911, an addition to the church was erected after the congregation outgrew the original building. In 1964, after membership declined, the building was sold to the Italian Christian Church of Pittsburgh. It worshiped there until 2015, when it sold the building to Beatrice.

The historic society stated that the church “reflects an important period of settlement and growth in the East End as well as its ethnic diversity, the religious diversity of Italians in Pittsburgh and, through its association with Willa Cather, LGBTQ+ history.”

For Mr. Lardo, the history is more personal. He said he decided to buy the property after learning that his great grandmothers and grandmother worshiped there. Beatrice, as in Beatrice Icon, was his grandmother’s name.

Advertise with us

In a bid to salvage the building, Mr. Lardo said he looked at possible reuses, including event spaces and apartments, but nothing worked out.

“The goal was always to save it but it’s too damaged to save,” he said.

Mr. Lardo plans to remove the stained glass windows and other artifacts to use in whatever he decides to develop at the site once the church is demolished.

Despite the family ties, the church no longer is structurally viable, he said, adding he has reports showing that it is beyond repair.

“It doesn’t make any financial sense to fix it because it can’t be fixed,” he said. “Now it’s just a liability sitting there.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com