Dan Adamski likes to say that Pittsburgh will never again experience what it did on March 13, 2020, just before COVID-19 upended everything — a full workforce in Downtown.

But that doesn’t mean Mr. Adamski, senior managing director of the Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm, isn’t encouraged by what he has been seeing lately.

For one, outdoor tables at PPG Place and in Market Square are filled again at lunchtime, or at least they were when he walked through last week.

“That’s not a metric that anyone tracks officially, but I can tell you that hasn’t been the case the previous couple of years,” he said Wednesday.

Advertise with us

According to the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, the number of employees working in Downtown in April was at 54% of what it was before that fateful day in March, 2020. That’s the highest it has been since then.

And Mr. Adamski predicts it will continue to grow, if ever so slowly.

He noted that some employers, like PNC, are pushing employees to return to the office, at least part of the week, as COVID-19 loses its emergency status. Fewer and fewer are sticking with full-time remote work.

“It’s a very slow but almost inexorable climb,” he said of the Downtown workforce numbers. “We’re never going to hit 100% of where we were on March 13 of 2020 but the trend line is encouraging.”

So how much will it bounce back? Mr. Adamski doesn’t envision the Golden Triangle workforce numbers going beyond 70% or 80% of what they were pre-COVID.

Advertise with us

Agreeing with that assessment is Jonathan Bonime, senior vice president of Fischer, a Downtown real estate company that represents tenants. While the 70% to 80% might be “a little aggressive,” it’s not off by much, he said.

“I don’t think you’ll get over 80%. I don’t see it,” he said.

And it’s unlikely that those who do return will ever work five days a week in the office again.

“The new norm seems to be three to four days a week mandated in the office,” Mr. Adamski said. “I think it’s the exception, not the rule, that it’s five days a week anymore.”

While some employers are now requiring workers to be in the office at least some days a week, others have given up on the idea — at least for now — and are “not planning for people to come back to the office at all,” Mr. Bonime said. “These are things that were never discussed before. They are human resource issues that have risen to the top.”

Advertise with us

Even if workforce levels fall short of pre-COVID levels, that’s not necessarily a bad thing, Mr. Adamski said.

Before the pandemic, Downtown had too much office space, he said. With 20% to 30% fewer people working in the central business district, it provides an opportunity to convert some of that space to residential, he said.

It also means “some adjustments” will have to be made.

“There are going to be some buildings Downtown that frankly will not be able to compete. It’s a game of musical chairs. There are fewer tenants, fewer tenant needs, fewer demands for square footage,” he said. “There’s a lot of square footage available and a lot less demand for it even at that 70% to 80% range. So some buildings are going to have to change. They’re going to have to be converted. It is inevitable.”

Some companies and landlords are offering amenities like gyms, lounge areas, and relaxation spaces to entice people back, Mr. Bonime said.

Advertise with us

“They’re trying to do anything they can to get people back,” he said. “It’s not only employers trying to get their employees back. It’s landlords trying to make it easier for employers to get their employees back.”

But that also has led to some “cannibalization” with the buildings that can offer such amenities basically siphoning from those that can’t, he said.

As some companies have moved to buildings with better amenities in hopes of enticing employees back, they’re also reducing their overall footprint to curb costs, Mr. Adamski said.

That has not helped the office vacancy rate, which stood at 22.8% in the first quarter.

While Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey has been criticized by some business leaders and stakeholders for conditions in Downtown, from safety and open drug use to homelessness, Mr. Gainey turned the tables at a recent PDP meeting.

Advertise with us

He said “we need people to return to work,” adding that part of public safety is having people in Downtown.

The mayor, Mr. Adamski said, has a point.

“Our Downtown is beholden to several large corporate users for the majority of our commuters, tenants Downtown, employees. They have an outsized impact,” he said. “They greatly influence the health of Downtown.”

Mr. Adamski said businesses have been “actively engaging” with the mayor’s office and the Allegheny Conference on Community Development to find ways to increase the number of employees in Downtown.

On the other hand, he said, there’s a “battle of wills going on” with some workers resisting attempts to bring them back. PNC has gone so far as to offer free and discounted parking to employees in an effort to get them back in the office.

Advertise with us

Mr. Adamski said one of the biggest concerns employees have voiced about returning to Downtown is safety.

On that front, he said he has seen “a noticeable improvement in security” recently. That includes a heightened and more engaged police presence, more frequent trash pickups, and a new initiative announced last week by the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership to clean sidewalks and alleyways.

In February, in response to criticism, Mr. Gainey vowed to triple the number of police officers in Downtown as part of a series of initiatives aimed at dealing with crime, homelessness, unruly behavior,and other issues.

“I think there’s been a recognition and an awakening by a lot of Downtown stakeholders that we have to fix this now,” said Mr. Adamski, who has raised concerns about safety in the past.

While conditions are not where they were pre-pandemic, “the trajectory has started to improve,” he said.

Advertise with us

“People complained about security Downtown. I think the mayor listened and reacted. There’s a much greater police presence. It feels safer out there,” he said.

Mr. Bonime said there are other issues that have hindered the return to the office in Downtown. One is the cost of parking. As a result, some landlords that are able to do so are offering parking packages to tenants, he said.

In terms of workforce return, Mr. Adamski said Downtown Pittsburgh is about 7% ahead of Philadelphia.

In April of last year, about 40% of the Golden Triangle workforce had come back. In April 2021, it was 23%.

“We’re trending positive,” Mr. Adamski said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com