Some Hill District groups say an agreement that cleared the way for construction of a music venue at the former Civic Arena site is out of tune with neighborhood priorities.
At a news conference Monday, leaders of the Hill District Consensus Group, the Hill District Collaborative, and Uptown Partners of Pittsburgh ripped a decision to include support for the New Granada Theater in the conditions for approving plans for the music venue and a 910-space parking garage.
They argued that the emphasis should be on stabilizing existing housing and creating more affordable housing in the Hill, not on the New Granada, which is being redeveloped by the Hill Community Development Corporation, another community group.
“Our first priority, the city must understand, is housing. Our second priority is housing. And our third priority is housing,” said Randall Taylor, equitable developer officer for the Hill District Consensus Group. “We have to not only house the people who are here and fight to make sure our seniors are able to stay in their homes with the home repairs that they need but we also need to build more housing to bring back the residents who were displaced from this community due to city policies.”
The groups maintained that the decision to include the New Granada in the conditions was the result of a “closed door deal” between city leaders, the Hill CDC, and the Urban Redevelopment Authority — the latter of which approved plans for the project last week — and not representatives of the Hill as a whole.
“I just want to put it out there that it is totally wrong and unethical for political leaders and officials to make closed, behind-door deals with one group on behalf of the community,” said Carol Hardeman, Hill District Consensus Group executive director and a longtime neighborhood resident.
Read More
But City Councilman R. Daniel Lavelle, who represents the Hill and who has been a key force in negotiations on the music venue, said there is an emphasis on creating more affordable housing in the neighborhood — including a tax diversion plan as part of the parking garage project designed to generate funding for such efforts.
Mr. Lavelle, a URA board member, challenged claims that the agreement last week was the result of last-minute wheeling and dealing, saying that nearly all of the commitments, including those involving New Granada, were part of a term sheet negotiated in 2019.
“The community was well aware of all the terms in the term sheet,” he said of last week’s action. “What we did was to put conditions in place to ensure those community benefits were actually realized.”
In approving plans for the live music venue and parking garage last Thursday, the URA and Sports & Exhibition Authority boards included aid for the New Granada Theater among a host of conditions the Pittsburgh Penguins are required to meet in moving forward with their plans.
As part of that support, Live Nation, the operator of the music venue, will book and promote at least 25 events a year at New Granada for the first five years of the theater’s operation. The Penguins also will provide up to 250 parking spaces at the ex-arena site for free for New Granada events over the same period and contribute $100,000 to the Hill Community Development Corporation to support the theater.
Mr. Taylor insisted Monday that the deal included a $2 million commitment to the Hill CDC for New Granada, although that did not appear on the URA agenda summary or in documentation provided to the SEA board in conjunction with last week’s vote on the music venue.
Mr. Lavelle said no such commitment was mentioned at the meeting. He said there was a commitment made by the city in 2019 to provide $5 million to the redevelopment if a new entertainment venue was built at the former Civic Arena site, located in the lower Hill.
Marimba Milliones, president and CEO of the Hill CDC, said the organization had requested at least $5 million from the city and the URA for the first phase of a $36 million New Granada redevelopment on Centre Avenue. She added that both have committed “a portion” of the $5 million as part of the music venue pledges, but did not give a specific number.
For its part, the URA said in a statement that its Avenues of Hope redevelopment initiative is focused on the Centre Avenue corridor as a whole, not just New Granada.
“For the past four years, the URA has been working with the Hill CDC in developing a capital stack for the New Granada Theater. Our investment in the Hill District is not limited to the Hill CDC,” it stated. “We are committed to ensure reactivation along Centre Avenue and beyond. We are working with Amani CDC, Communion Place, Studio Volcy, Big Tom’s Barbershop, Salem’s Grocery Store, 21 Rose, Sankofa Square, and Salon XO.”
Nonetheless, Mr. Taylor said the groups are “standing by our sources that a deal has been cut for that amount of money.”
He said the Hill District Consensus Group, the Hill District Collaborative, and Uptown Partners are demanding a meeting with the URA and Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration to discuss the situation.
“Our next step, again, will be to speak directly with our city officials and make it clear to them that there’s not one voice on this hill. There are many voices. They all have a right to be at the table,” he said.
“Nobody died and left somebody czar of the Hill,” Ms. Hardeman added.
In a statement released after the press conference, the Hill CDC said it shared the concerns of the other groups about the need for affordable housing in the Hill. It noted that it recently completed the $16.5 million New Granada Square Apartments, a 40-unit complex affordable to households between 20% to 80% of the area median income.
It also defended the aid being provided to New Granada, an iconic venue which once drew jazz greats like Louis Armstrong, Charlie Parker, and Ella Fitzgerald.
“The New Granada project is the most essential economic development project in the Hill District neighborhood and has been a focus of redevelopment for decades under many mayoral administrations,” it stated. “With the Lower Hill entertainment venue and parking garage receiving tens of millions in tax dollars, it would be unconscionable to not ensure that the City of Pittsburgh and URA are investing in this historic project that is not only important to the Hill District, but nationally.”
It stated its involvement in the negotiations surrounding the Civic Arena site date back to 2007 — and that since then it has been able to secure $45 million in commitments for other parts of the neighborhood.
Among those commitments is a $2 surcharge on music venue tickets it pushed for that is to be used to redevelop other sections of the Hill. Mr. Lavelle said that was the only new addition to the 2019 term sheet.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.