VisitPittsburgh spends nearly half of its budget on wages and benefits, concentrates too much on leisure travel at the expense of larger conventions, and does not adequately account for the millions of dollars in hotel tax money it receives each year, according to Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor.

Those charges are among the major findings in a 56-page performance audit of the region’s largest tourism group released Thursday by Mr. O’Connor’s office — one decried as inaccurate and “politically motivated” by VisitPittsburgh officials.

“It seems like the way that they’ve used their language, that this (is) a political narrative,” said Jerad Bachar, VisitPittsburgh president and CEO. “That is very concerning to us.”

In the report, which covered the period from Jan. 1, 2017, to Dec. 31, 2022, the controller accuses the tourism agency of maintaining “unreasonable” reserves and spending too much on rent for its 28th floor offices in Fifth Avenue Place in Downtown.

Advertise with us

The issues, according to the audit, are “significant,” and should be addressed before any move to create a county tourism improvement district — an initiative that VisitPittsburgh has been pushing but has failed to get through the state General Assembly. It would be funded by a 2% fee tacked on to every hotel room rented in the county. But VisitPittsburgh, the audit stated, “needs to focus on doing more with the financial resources that are already being provided to it.”

In his rebuttal, Mr. Bachar said the audit was politically motivated, contained factual inaccuracies and disregarded “some really critical information” in its findings.

He maintained, for example, that it failed to take into account steps VisitPittsburgh has already taken to remedy its office lease, which cost the agency $473,089 in 2021, or 7% of its total expenses. And while the audit notes that it appears that 12 VisitPittsburgh employees are paid in excess of market rates, including three by more than 25%, Mr. Bachar said the report did not point out that 21 workers are paid below market rates.

“All of these things, these facts, have been omitted,” he said.

He pointed out that the audit was prompted by a request from state Sen. Wayne Fontana, the Sports & Exhibition Authority board chairman who has been critical of the money received by the tourism agency. The Brookline Democrat also has been opposed to the creation of the tourism improvement district in its current form.

Advertise with us

In a response to the audit Thursday, Mr. Fontana called on county elected leaders to “exercise increased oversight” of VisitPittsburgh and to re-evaluate its designation as the county’s tourism promotion agency, which entitles it to a share of hotel tax revenue.

“Unfortunately, VisitPittsburgh has failed to promote all of our region’s assets in a way that maximizes tourism opportunities, and it is clear that changes are necessary,” he said in his statement. “The taxpayers deserve much more than they have been getting from VisitPittsburgh.”

Mr. Bachar countered that Mr. O’Connor, in doing the audit, was “trying to support the political ambitions of Sen. Fontana.”

“Sen. Fontana is trying to solve the operational and capital deficits that the SEA has been plagued with for years. So they’re looking for any kind of revenue source — whether it’s city, county or state — to help fill those gaps,” he said.

That, he contended, includes any future funding for tourism promotion.

Advertise with us

In terms of compensation, the audit found that wages and benefits totaled anywhere between $3.8 million to nearly $6.8 million, or from 39% to 53% of total expenses, between 2018 to 2022. It also stated that VisitPittsburgh refused to provide detailed compensation for all staff, a lack of transparency it described as a “major issue” that can “inhibit the free flow of information and lead to fraud and mismanagement of resources.”

Mr. Bachar said VisitPittsburgh opted not to provide the information on the advice of legal counsel, arguing that the agency is a private nonprofit and that there is an expectation of privacy. He stated that he offered to provide the information if the county solicitor guaranteed that it would remain private, but he never got a response.

VisitPittsburgh did turn in 990 forms showing top compensation and budget information with totals spent on wages and benefits. VisitPittsburgh, he added, has taken steps to reduce payroll by cutting staff from 55 to 40 during the pandemic. He said it has no plans to increase staff.

The audit accuses VisitPittsburgh of dedicating more staff resources to securing leisure travel than bigger business events that could help to fill the David L. Lawrence Convention Center, with 14 positions dedicated to the former and only four to the latter. It stated that VisitPittsburgh generally has secured smaller events — and that an incentive compensation system put in place for the sales staff seems to inhibit efforts to secure larger events.

“It appears that opportunities are being missed to fully utilize the David L. Lawrence Convention Center and the other large local event venues and to secure additional hotel night stays that would likely result in additional county hotel tax revenues to VisitPittsburgh,” the audit said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Bachar maintained that the finding “really shows a lack of understanding of tourism promotion” coming out of the COVID-19 pandemic. VisitPittsburgh, he said, had to redirect its resources toward the leisure side during COVID because for many months it was “illegal” to even book large events at the convention center.

“We had to make sure that we continued to speak to the consumers that we could attract,” he said. “So throughout the height of the pandemic, we put a lot of focus on leisure tourism because they were the only consumers traveling.”

Last year, VisitPittsurgh spent $4.9 million in sales initiatives for group bookings compared to $3.9 million in marketing initiatives, with 10 people dedicated to sales and eight to marketing, he said.

“To say that we are allocating too much to leisure marketing and not enough to group is factually inaccurate,” he said.

The audit further reported that VisitPttsburgh maintained reserves of $6.2 million at the end of 2021 and $5.2 million as of Dec. 31, 2022. It claimed that such large amounts “are not reasonable given the circumstances” and stated that peer groups in Baltimore, Cleveland, Columbus and Cincinnati do not have reserves. Additionally, it pointed out that VisitPittsburgh received more than $6 million in pandemic-related funding.

Advertise with us

“Such a large operating reserve is unnecessary,” the audit stated.

But Mr. Bachar described the reserves as a “safety net” should hotel tax revenues drop. He said VisitPittsburgh went 14 months without any such revenue during the pandemic and used $1.7 million in reserves to fill the gap.

Furthermore, the reserves act as a guarantee against the subsidies VisitPittsburgh often is required to offer to groups to bring conventions to the Steel City.

The audit countered that the agency should be able to handle those commitments without reserves. While such promises are significant, “proper budgeting precludes the need to maintain an event subsidy reserve fund,” it stated.

VisitPittsburgh each year gets 40% of the revenue from the 7% county hotel tax. In 2022, it received nearly $11 million.

Advertise with us

In terms of VisitPittsburgh’s rent at Fifth Avenue Place, Mr. Bachar said the agency has been trying to sublease the 17,000-square-foot space, and is prepared to move if it is able to do so before the lease expires in August 2026.

As for the three employees being paid more than 25% above market rate, he explained that two have been with the organization more than 25 years and that the third had a “special skill set” and was hired during the peak of the pandemic.

The audit also accused VisitPittsburgh of failing to “adequately track the expenditure” of millions of dollars in restricted hotel tax revenues, as required by general accounting principles.

Private and public funds typically are commingled. Not adequately tracking tax-related expenditures “impairs [VisitPittsburgh’s] ability to demonstrate that the funds have been expended in a manner that complies with applicable restrictions,’ the audit stated.

Mr. Bachar said VisitPittsburgh keeps track of both private and public funds in one accounting system that is audited annually. In 25 years, he said the method has never been called into question, adding that it has been validated by multiple external CPA firms. He noted that VisitPittsburgh is able to track all expenses separately to ensure, for instance, that travel and entertainment expenses are paid through private funds rather than public monies.

Advertise with us

The controller’s office also recommended that the SEA and the city’s sports teams should have representatives on the VisitPittsburgh board of directors.

Mr. Bachar said he’s willing to consider that — in exchange for VisitPittsburgh representation on the board of the SEA, which owns the city’s three major sports venues and the convention center.

Mr. Fontana, meanwhile, asserted in his statement that VisitPittsburgh “is not transparent in its use of public tax dollars, disregards basic accounting principles, overspends thousands of dollars on its operations, and is blatantly defiant to any kind of oversight.

“The audit also exposes the lack of a coherent and organized strategy to bring conventions and sporting events to the city and region — an egregious failure in the competitive post-pandemic tourism economy,” the statement read.

Mr. Bachar noted that although it was labeled as a performance audit, the document failed to report on the agency’s actual results — including the 74 events it booked at the convention center last year, a 54% increase over pre-COVID 2019.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com