The Pittsburgh Penguins say they will impose a $2 surcharge on each ticket sold for events at a proposed live music venue at the former Civic Arena site to help fund development in other parts of the Hill District.
Developer Buccini Pollin Group and Penguins officials outlined the proposal in a letter to the city planning commission in advance of what was expected to be a key vote Tuesday on the music venue and a 910-space parking garage to be built in the middle of the 28-acre arena site in the lower Hill.
But in the end, the commission delayed a vote on the project and proposed amendments to a preliminary land development plan after its members thought the community should have a chance to review the package the Penguins had submitted.
In addition to the letter touting the ticket surcharge and other investments related to the arena redevelopment, the package included a 101-page response to concerns that had been raised by an executive management committee that makes sure that Penguins live up to the promises and commitments they made to the community as part of the $1 billion arena redevelopment.
In public comments before the commission delayed a vote, several Hill residents urged the board to give them time to review the documents. Commissioners decided to grant the request.
“I think it’s been proven over many, many years that ignorance leads to fear,” Commissioner Jean Holland Dick said. “If people have not read it — even if it’s a perfectly honorable document and it says exactly what you said — if people have not read it, they’re afraid of it and afraid of what it may be.”
Read More
Commission Vice Chairwoman LaShawn Burton-Faulk added that it boiled down to “a little bit of a trust issue.”
“In fairness, you’ve got to give an extension of trust. If someone doesn’t feel as if these last-minute things ... 101 pages is a lot. I hope you’re saying a lot in those 101 pages. And given that, folks need to wrap their arms around it,” she said.
In a statement after the meeting, Kevin Acklin, the Penguins’ president of business operations, said the team was “very pleased with the robust engagement” exhibited at the meeting.
“We appreciate the attention of the Planning Commission members to our detailed presentation on how we are delivering a transformational development on the lower Hill. We look forward to coming back in two weeks to seek final commission approvals for this exciting project,” he said.
Before Tuesday, the Hill Community Development Corporation had been pushing for the $2 ticket fee as well as a $2 surcharge on each vehicle parked in the garage as a way to help fund infrastructure improvements and development activities in the neighborhood.
Buccini Pollin and the Penguins have flatly refused to impose a parking surcharge, stating it could put the garage at a “competitive disadvantage” particularly given that many such facilities are still struggling to attract customers in the age of COVID-19.
But in its letter Tuesday to the commission and others, including Mayor Ed Gainey, the team and its developer said they “are prepared to deliver an exciting new recurring revenue stream” in the form of the $2 ticket surcharge.
The letter stated that the money would be deposited into the same Hill District reinvestment fund that was the conduit for nearly $7.2 million in anticipated tax revenues advanced by First National Bank as part of the construction of a new 26-story office tower to be anchored by FNB. The money is to be used to help build up other parts of the Hill.
In response, Marimba Milliones, CEO and president of the Hill CDC, said Penguins and Buccini Pollin have not made the $2 ticket surcharge pledge known to either her organization or the executive management committee.
“We look forward to actually receiving that in some type of contractual form,” she told planning commissioners at the meeting.
Last month, in its own letter to the commission, the executive management committee raised concerns about the team’s progress to date in meeting some of the promises related to community benefits.
The committee also stated that it “has been disappointed” with the development team’s minority and women business enterprise efforts, saying they have “not been consistent with the letter or the spirit of” the benefits package, known as the community collaboration and implementation plan.
It said that “the methodology used to calculate certified MWBE company percentages of participation reported in their monthly reports selectively depart from recognized practice.”
The 101-page document submitted to the Planning Commission Tuesday was the team’s formal response to those concerns. It contained not only the cover letter outlining the ticket surcharge and other benefits but also a five-page summary addressing the concerns and dozens and dozens of pages of exhibits, including presentations it had given in the past.
In the response, the Penguins and Buccini Pollin stated that more than 70 minority and women business enterprise consultants and contractors have been awarded contracts during the pre-development and construction phases so far. That includes commitments approaching $45 million and payments of more than $10 million.
The team stated that it “has maintained detailed documentation of its efforts, those of our builder and, furthermore, those of our Hill District-based third party vendor diversity consultant E. Holdings.”
“Collectively, we remain committed to meeting and exceeding the goals — MWBE inclusion, wealth building, workforce development — of the [community collaboration and implementation plan] and are on track to do so,” it added.
In its letter, the executive management committee also pressed the Planning Commission to require that the Penguins abide by the terms of the community collaboration and implementation agreement in approving the proposal for the music venue and parking garage and in amending the preliminary land development plan for the site.
Ms. Milliones and R. Daniel Lavelle, the city councilman who represents the Hill, also urged the commission to do so during Tuesday’s meeting. Both are members are the executive management committee.
But the Penguins pushed back against the idea, saying it is not within the purview of the commission to do so. The one responsible for holding the team accountable is the executive management committee itself, said Craig Dunham, the Penguins’ senior vice president of development.
“That’s where the heart and the authority of the CCIP lives,” he said.
As part of the changes the Penguins are seeking to the preliminary land development plan, they want to eliminate two streets that were originally planned in the upper part of the site near Crawford Square and replace part of Wylie Avenue on the western end with open space leading into Frankie Mae Pace Park, which connects the Hill to Downtown.
One controversial aspect involves the creation of a conservancy to operate and maintain the public open spaces throughout the site. Mr. Lavelle and others raised concerns that the move would result in the privatization of the land and could keep people out. But the Penguins insisted that the spaces would always remain open to the public.
The proposed music venue, to be operated by Live Nation, would total about 95,000 square feet and seat about 4,500 people. The $110 million project also includes the relocation of an EMS public safety center to the site from Downtown.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.