A Hill District group is pushing for surcharges on parking and tickets at the new music venue the Pittsburgh Penguins are getting ready to start at the former Civic Arena site.
The Hill Community Development Corporation wants to see a $2 fee added to each ticket sold and each car parked, with the revenue redirected to other parts of the Hill in need of infrastructure improvements and where development can be costly.
“We desperately need capital to develop the neighborhood,” Marimba Milliones, Hill CEO and president, said Friday.
The surcharges are just one of the issues the Hill CDC is raising in advance of a city-sponsored development activities meeting to be held virtually Monday at 6 p.m. on the music venue and an accompanying 908-space parking garage, both to be built in the middle of the publicly-owned Lower Hill site.
Ms. Milliones also was concerned about a decision to move an incubator space for Black businesses off Wylie Avenue onto Logan Street and to not give it a prominent street front presence.
However, Kevin Acklin, the Penguins president of business operations, said Friday that the space is being moved back to Wylie.
Read More
The Hill CDC also is pushing for a benefits agreement known as the Community Collaboration and Implementation Plan, or CCIP, to be incorporated into the formal preliminary land development plan for the venue.
The $4 in proposed surcharges would be in addition to a proposal by the Penguins and developer Buccini Pollin Group to divert an estimated $8.2 million in parking tax revenues to other parts of the Hill to support housing stabilization efforts.
Ms. Milliones did not have an estimate on how much the surcharges would generate. But she said such funding is needed because it can cost as much as $40 million to develop just two blocks in the Hill.
She noted that the one-block New Granada Theater redevelopment on Centre Avenue will cost about $60 million. What’s more, there are about 600 acres of vacant land in an 1,100-acre neighborhood, Ms. Milliones explained.
“We have major infrastructure issues,” she said, adding that the recent award of a $11.3 million grant to refurbish the Centre business district and several nearby streets “will not fix everything.”
Mr. Acklin declined comment on the surcharge proposal, saying he had not heard about it.
Ms. Milliones noted that the CCIP calls on the Penguins to make “commercially reasonable efforts” to identify potential revenue streams that could lead to additional reinvestment in other parts of the Hill, including a $1 per car surcharge on structured parking.
The Middle and Upper Hill already are expected to benefit from more than $7 million advanced by First National Bank in anticipation of tax revenue to be generated by development at the arena site. FNB will anchor the 26-story office tower currently being built there.
That money is to be used for projects in other parts of the Hill. But Ms. Milliones noted that the funding is not a “generous contribution” from the Penguins but a transfer of tax revenue that otherwise would have gone to the city, county, and school district.
“It’s really not generosity. It’s oftentimes is presented as generosity. We’re grateful for it, right. But it’s not generosity and we had to really fight to get that,” she said.
The proposed music venue, to be managed by Live Nation, would be built in the middle of the site bordered by Wylie, Logan and Fullerton streets, and Bedford Avenue.
Buccini Pollin have tweaked the plans, eliminating an outdoor section because of concerns about noise and cost, and reducing capacity from 6,000 people to 4,500.
The team hopes to start construction early next year and have the garage and music venue completed in the first and second quarters of 2024, respectively.
At one time, the venue was to be built on top of the garage. But the two now will be built side by side, with the main entrance to the music complex to be at Wylie and Logan.
With the change in plans, the incubator space for Black businesses had been moved off Wylie onto Logan. Ms. Milliones said the decision was made without community input.
Nonetheless, Mr. Acklin said that no longer is an issue.
“The development team is working to design the building to accommodate the Catapult incubator space on Wylie, in compliance with the CCIP and earlier approvals” by the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority, which owns part of the 28-acre site.
“We can evaluate that move if and when it happens,” Ms. Milliones responded, adding that the formal plan still has the space on Logan.
Ms. Milliones also wants the CCIP to become part of the amended preliminary land development plan the Penguins have submitted for the site, where the team holds the development rights.
Incorporating the CCIP, she said, would allow the city’s planning commission to use the document as a “metric for future plans.”
The Penguins have argued that there’s no need for another level of enforcement, given that others are responsible for ensuring that the various elements of the deal are implemented properly.
But Ms. Milliones countered that one of the factors the planning commission looks at in weighing development proposals is socio-economic impact.
“So it’s simply not true that they couldn’t use that as a referencing document, just as they use a marketing study or a traffic study or something of that nature to do their deliberations,” she said.
“Their responsibility is to protect the environment, to protect the interests of the public good. You can’t do that if you’re not considering the fullness of all of the documents that have been a part of the process.”
Ms. Milliones also had concerns about the pace at which the music venue project is moving. She didn’t think sufficient notice was given for the development activities meeting. The URA, meanwhile, will be briefed on the proposal next month and could vote in December.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.