After hunkering down during the worst of the pandemic, companies once again are back to trading spaces but with one big caveat — many are shrinking their footprint, not expanding it.

It’s a paradox driven entirely by the fallout from COVID 19.

Companies that are relocating are interested in upgrading their space to lure employees back to the office. But they’re taking less of it in an effort to save money, said Dan Adamski, senior managing director of the Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm.

“The trend is generating an uptick in recent leasing activity because it is typically easier to relocate into new space than live through a complete renovation and downsizing of an active workspace,” he said.

Advertise with us

“And with record high office vacancy, landlords are offering unprecedented levels of concessions and construction allowances to subsidize relocations to newer buildings with greater amenities and more modern mechanical systems such as air filtration.”

This phenomenon is borne out in statistics.

Of the 16 new leases signed in or near Downtown last year, 11 involved reductions in space, according to JLL. They ranged from big deals to small ones.

Even the marquee event of 2021 — the start of construction on the 26-story headquarters for First National Bank at the former Civic Arena site — involved a downsizing.

FNB will be taking 164,927 square feet in the 26-story office tower, down from 180,000 square feet at its locations on the North Shore, according to JLL.

Advertise with us

Another major relocation announced earlier this year — the move by Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote PC from PPG Place to Four Gateway Center in 2025 — also will result in a smaller footprint.

The law firm will be taking 79,719 square feet in Four Gateway Center, or 25,281 square feet less than it has at its current location, JLL reported.

Vitamin and supplement maker GNC really slimmed down. It shed nearly half of its office space in moving from its Downtown headquarters to 75 Hopper Place in the Strip District, where it is taking 76,000 square feet, down from 150,000.

‘We’ space

Contributing to the trend, Mr. Adamski said, is the way companies are rearranging their new space. Individual employee “me” space is giving way to more collaborative “we” space, as companies focus on “interacting, ideating, and socializing,” he said.

Advertise with us

“JLL’s national research shows that many firms have found individual productivity increased with remote work, but even more important than productivity is innovation and growth, which is hard to accomplish when the workforce is highly dispersed,” he said.

That means that private offices and workstations, both of which have defined the office experience for decades, could give way to spaces devoted to collaboration and amenities, a big selling point these days.

“Offices now have two major purposes — to aid in culture and team building and, in some cases, to host customers,” Mr. Adamski said.

Companies, he explained, also are recognizing that they have to reinvent the office to make it more of a destination to coax people from the comfort of their homes to return to work at least a few days a week.

“The office of 2023 will be like a boutique hotel or clubhouse with technology activation throughout,” he predicted. “With so many companies now offering a hybrid-work option, the office of the future will be a magnet, not a mandate.”

Advertise with us

Shorter leases

While leasing activity increased last year, it still remained below pre-pandemic levels, the Newmark real estate firm noted, with the average transaction size dropping to the single digits.

“Companies are beginning to recognize the need for a physical office to maintain culture and business operations, but they continue to struggle with appropriate space requirements, configuration and work week structure,” Newmark stated in its fourth quarter report.

“Many users have opted for shorter lease terms and increased requests for early termination options, exercising a ‘wait-and-see’ approach to better understand the direction of their businesses.”

Some tenants are so eager to adjust their space needs that they are doing so even if it means existing a lease early, Newmark noted.

Advertise with us

A few expansions

Not everyone was downsizing in 2021.

Incline Equity Partners signed a deal to expand their offices at EQT Plaza, going from 16,292 square feet to 27,069 square feet.

The Whiteford Taylor Preston law firm added more than 6,000 square feet in inking an agreement to move to 11 Stanwix Street, where it will occupy 16,186 square feet, according to JLL.

Another big signing involved language learning start-up Duolingo, which is taking up to 38,000 square feet in the new Liberty East development in East Liberty in relocating from its Penn Avenue headquarters.

Advertise with us

Autonomous vehicle firm Argo AI also has expanded its presence at the 3 Crossings development in the Strip, taking nearly all of the space in the five-story Riverfront West building.

The Class B slump

While the uptick in leasing activity last year gave the struggling Pittsburgh office market some hope, it was offset by an increase in vacancies, putting pressure on landlords to lower rents.

Particularly hard hit, according to JLL, were Downtown’s older Class B buildings, where vacancies rose to 28.9%.

Since 2018, new leasing in the region has gravitated 70% more to buildings built or renovated within the last 10 years. Downtown’s Class B buildings average 81 years in age, JLL stated.

Advertise with us

“Looking ahead, older buildings will continue to face leasing challenges across the market, but especially the urban core as the flight to quality continues to be prevalent,” it added.

Although vacancies appeared to slow in the first quarter of 2022, the amount of subleased space continues to rise in the Pittsburgh market, reaching nearly 2.3 million square feet in the first quarter, Newmark reported.

And while some segments of the market have improved, the pandemic continues to present challenges.

“Regarding upcoming lease expirations, decisions will have to be made on new models of space use in determining future office needs,” Newmark stated.

“Many questions remain regarding working from home, utilizing a hybrid schedule or fully returning to the office. As these decisions are made, the market will begin to see an increase in office market activity.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.