As Whole Foods Market gets ready to move into its new store in East Liberty, the owner of the plaza that has been its home for nearly 20 years already is preparing for its checkout.
The partnership run by LaSalle Investment Management is considering a range of possibilities for the site at 5880 Centre Ave., including a possible vertical mixed-use development.
“All options are being explored,” said Herky Pollock, a CBRE executive vice president who is working with LaSalle to determine the highest and best use for repurposing the building.
A plan is needed because Whole Foods will be moving to a new, larger 50,000-square-foot space blocks away in the Liberty East development at Penn and South Euclid avenues this summer.

Mr. Pollock said the grocer should be occupying the space by August or September. Neither representatives for Whole Foods nor LG Realty Advisors, the developer, could be reached for comment.
LG Realty is scheduled to go before the city’s Zoning Board of Adjustment March 10 to seek three variances related to the signage planned for the new Whole Foods store.
Read More
Whole Foods will anchor a nine-story first phase that includes 252,000 square feet of office space and about 700 parking spaces, including 287 that will be reserved exclusively for grocery shoppers.
The grocer returned to the development and signed a lease for the space in 2019 after pulling out of it two years earlier because of the controversy surrounding it.
To clear the way for the redevelopment of the site, LG Realty displaced more than 200 residents from the former Penn Plaza apartment complex, which has since been demolished.
As a result, the new development became a focal point for demands for the creation of more affordable housing in the city, an issue that is still very much in the forefront of city politics, amid concerns about increasing gentrification in East Liberty, Lawrenceville and other neighborhoods.
At the same time, LG Realty has said that the first phase of the new development would generate up to $6.3 million in transit revitalization funding.
Of that, more than $2 million is to go into a fund to build affordable housing within three quarters of a mile of Liberty East and up to $1 million is to be used for improvements to Enright Park next to the development.
As Whole Foods prepares to make its move, it has no plans to maintain any presence at its current 32,500-square-foot Centre Avenue location, Mr. Pollock said.
In the past, there has been some speculation that the company might try another concept at the site. That will not be the case, Mr. Pollock said, adding that the grocer’s lease expires in August.
“Whole Foods won’t be keeping anything there,” he said.
But that doesn’t mean there aren’t options for the property. Mr. Pollock said possible reuses could be retail, office, medical-related, or flex space.
The partnership also is considering a vertical development that could be used for offices or residential purposes, he noted. That could involve utilizing the existing building or replacing it.
“Ownership is evaluating a myriad of options as to what to do with the existing Whole Foods building. The range of possibilities include simply re-tenanting the existing structure or going vertical with a mixed use development,” he said
As for whether another grocery could return to the site, Mr. Pollock said, “All options are on the table. Nothing has been ruled out.”
But don’t expect Giant Eagle to move from its current spot on Centre a short walk away. That’s “not a possibility,” Mr. Pollock said.
He added he has been talking to possible tenants and doing an analysis on potential redevelopment opportunities. That should be done in the next few months.
When Whole Foods opened in October 2002, it helped to launch a renaissance that has transformed much of East Liberty while at the same time sparking questions and concerns about gentrification.
Developments have included a new Target store, one of the chain’s best in Pennsylvania in terms of sales; a $156.9 million multistage transit oriented development that includes 360 luxury apartments and 43,000 square feet of mixed commercial development; and a shopping plaza that features retail and parking.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.