A proposal that would give Pittsburgh City Council members more power over development projects in their districts is coming under fire from a local commercial real estate association.

In a policy alert Friday to its members, NAIOP Pittsburgh maintained that the legislation advanced by Councilman Ricky Burgess would hinder local projects and politicize the approval process.

“We believe that adding an additional layer to our city’s already cumbersome planning process will delay projects, market rate and affordable alike. This proposal would also serve to further politicize the planning approval process,” it stated.

“While the planning commission has an imperfect approval process, it is mostly objective. This would transform the process and make project approvals more subjective.”

Advertise with us

Under the legislation, council would have more power to review applications for site plans, project development plans and planned developments excluding those under 8,001 square feet and signage.

The bill would require the city’s zoning administrator to share a developer’s plan with the council member whose district is affected within three days after it is submitted.

That council member then would have 14 days to report a “significant community concern” about the project to the planning commission.

According to NAIOP, council then would be able to use the same process set up for reviewing zoning changes to approve or deny the project.

That would include a public hearing within 120 days after a planning commission recommendation, followed by a 90-day period after the hearing to make a decision.

Advertise with us

In its bulletin, NAIOP, which represents developers, brokers and other commercial real estate professionals, stated that there are currently “ample ways” for council members to address any concerns they have about projects.

They have the ability, for example, to raise objections before the planning commission or the zoning board of adjustment.

“We should avoid a situation where we subject our development process to an idiosyncratic political process,” the group stressed. “We believe that, as written, this legislation would be bad for development and government efficiency.”

Mr. Burgess has said the legislation is needed because low-income communities, particularly the city’s Black neighborhoods, “are on the verge of extinction.”

To make his case, he cited a report last month by a North Side-based organization that showed that banks overwhelmingly invested in Pittsburgh white residents and communities over Black communities from 2007 to 2019.

Advertise with us

Except for conditional uses, the city’s planning procedures now do not include a way for council members to review individual development applications. Nor do those members have veto power over projects.

An analysis by the Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney law firm that accompanied the NAIOP alert estimated that it could take up to nine months to get projects approved under the new process if it becomes law.

That’s despite the fact that the proposed bill seeks to reduce the planning commission’s decision-making time on a project from 90 to 60 days.

According to Buchanan Ingersoll, some reviews, including planning commission approval, now can be completed within as little as six to eight weeks.

City Planning Director Andrew Dash has said that his department now works with registered community organizations to understand concerns about potential developments.

Advertise with us

Mr. Burgess could not be reached for comment Friday.

In an interview, Brandon Mendoza, NAIOP executive director, said the organization has already met with the councilman to share its concerns about the legislation.

“As of right now, he’s meeting in good faith. He’s not signaled that he’s willing to change [the legislation],” he said. “He said he’s going to try to see if he can address some of our concerns.”

NAIOP, he added, is opposed to the legislation as it is written. He argued that it essentially would give council members a “new power” within their districts to approve or reject projects.

“The planning commission is already a body that has that power. As imperfect as their process is, it’s less of a political process than elected officials having that power,” he said.

Advertise with us

Part of the genesis for the legislation and a separate bill that would require developers to submit affordable housing impact statements is a concern about a shortage of affordable housing for households with very low incomes.

NAIOP, Mr. Mendoza said, is willing to work with council to address that shortfall. But giving council more power to approve or reject development projects, he emphasized, “isn’t the way to go, in our opinion.”

Mark Belko: 412-263-1262 or mbelko@post-gazette.com.