Shadyside Market & Deli, a Walnut Street landmark for at least seven decades, is shutting its doors for good.

Co-owner Sara Mineo confirmed Friday that the market, known in part for the quality of its fruits and vegetables, will close by the end of September.

Ms. Mineo said she and her brother, Dominic, are ready to retire. Mr. Mineo just turned 68, and Ms. Mineo will be 69 in October.

“It’s time,” she said. “That’s what it is.”

Advertise with us

Shadyside Market has been a presence on Walnut Street since at least 1946. Joseph Mineo, Dominic and Sara’s father, bought the store in 1952. It has been in the family ever since.

The grocery at one time was at 5509 Walnut. It moved to its current location at 5414 Walnut in 1979 after Joseph Mineo purchased that property, which at the time housed a Mobil gasoline station, in the mid-1970s.

Ms. Mineo described the store’s closing as “bittersweet” given the connections built with customers over the years.

Photos of the original location of Shadyside Market & Deli on display at the market on Friday, Aug. 27, 2021, in Shadyside. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“There’s been a lot of relationships made,” she said. “But on the other hand, it’s time. It’s time to enjoy things we were not able to because of the business.”

Working at the store was a family affair. Ms. Mineo recalls that she and Dominic would take two buses from Penn Hills to Shadyside to help out at the store on Saturdays when they were 11 or 12 years old.

Advertise with us

They were assisted by two other brothers, Joey and Johnny, both of whom are now deceased.

They continued working at the store through high school, college and beyond. Ms. Mineo sometimes had to make the trek to Shadyside from Bethany College in West Virginia.

“It would not be unusual for my father to say, ‘Find a way home. I need you,’” she said.

The produce section at Shadyside Market & Deli on Walnut Ave. photographed on Friday, Aug. 27, 2021, in Shadyside. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Ms. Mineo and her three brothers took over the business after their father died in 1986.

“We knew what we were doing,” Ms. Mineo said. “We were able to keep it afloat.”

Advertise with us

Over the years, the market became particularly known for the quality of its fresh produce, spawning store nicknames like the “fruit museum” and “Tiffany.”

The fruit included Indian River Orchid Brand grapefruit, which was considered the “Cadillac of grapefruits,” Ms. Mineo said.

Shadyside Market was the only place you could get it — for a reason, she explained.

“No one else carried it in the city. They couldn’t carry it in the city because my father outbid [at auction] anyone else who had an interest in it,” she said.

While five or six people had expressed an interest in taking over Shadyside Market, nothing came of the overtures, Ms. Mineo said.

Advertise with us

Now the plan is to shut down the store and search for someone else to take the first-floor space.

“Once we close up, if someone approaches us and would like to take it over or put another market in, we would entertain it,” she said.

If not, the Mineos will focus on finding another tenant.

Shadyside Market & Deli on Walnut Ave. photographed on Friday, Aug. 27, 2021, in Shadyside. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“We would like something that is going to keep the reputation of Shadyside elevated. We’re looking for top-notch people,” Ms. Mineo said.

The two-story Mineo Building also houses an Eyetique store and a dress shop. A salon will be opening on the second floor.

Advertise with us

Herky Pollock, a CBRE executive vice president who specializes in retail, called news of the store’s closing “a sad day for Shadyside.”

“Shadyside Market has been one of the original tenants on Walnut Street for generations. They have been both a tenant and this evolved into a landlord. It is hard to imagine the street without them. I certainly hope that someone steps into their shoes,” he said.

“I grew up on Shadyside Market. So much so that we had a house account. For years I operated my hot dog cart on the street, and their family was always quite accommodating to me as a young man.”

Gregg Perelman, founding partner and CEO of Shadyside-based Walnut Capital, has been a frequent customer in the store, shopping there for several decades. He also was saddened to hear of its closing.

“They’ve been around so long. They’ve been great people to deal with. The delivery and the quality of the products have been amazing over the years. We’re going to miss them dearly,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Perelman said the market offered high-quality fruits, vegetables and meats and “brought in great turkeys for the holidays. They were just nice people.”

“During COVID, they were really helpful in terms of getting deliveries out to people in homes before everybody else did,” he pointed out.

While Ms. Mineo will miss her customers and the store, she said she and her brother now will be free to enjoy other things.

She noted that in the past, because of market obligations, they sometimes didn’t get to the weddings they were invited to until the end of the reception.

“We’re ready to enjoy the invitations that are given to us from the beginning to the end,” she said.

Advertise with us

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.

The produce section at Shadyside Market & Deli on Walnut Ave. photographed on Friday, Aug. 27, 2021, in Shadyside. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)