Allegheny County is wrongly coding property sales submitted to the state, resulting in increased tax revenue from assessment appeals, a lawsuit contends.
The lawsuit, filed last week in county Common Pleas Court, accuses the county being “grossly negligent” or “intentionally dishonest” in the way it codes the sales.
“One person might make a mistake, but we’re talking over and over again. This is what they are doing. It certainly has the appearance of being intentional,” said John Silvestri, the attorney who filed the complaint on behalf of nine property owners.
Named as defendants are the county, county Executive Rich Fitzgerald, Manager William D. McKain, and the county’s board of property assessment appeals and review.
County spokeswoman Amie Downs declined to comment, saying: “We do not comment on lawsuits or legal matters as a policy.”
David Montgomery, solicitor for the assessment board, also had no comment, saying it appeared to be more of a county matter.
Read More
At issue in the lawsuit is what is known as the common level ratio, a state calculation used in property assessment appeals to account for widening disparities between assessed values and current sales prices since the last countywide reassessment took place nearly a decade ago.
The CLR, calculated by the state tax equalization board, is used in appeal hearings to determine the new assessed value of a property
To calculate the ratio, the state uses property sales, coded as valid, that are submitted by the county, according to the lawsuit — and that is where the problem occurs, the complaint alleges.
The complaint charged, in essence, the county is manipulating the sales data submitted to the state, targeting those transactions where the assessed value is closer to the sales price while excluding those where there are larger disparities between the two.
That, the lawsuit contends, has the effect of keeping the common level ratio higher than it should be. For example, it maintains it should have been 77.23% in 2019 rather than 87.5%.
The difference has real-life consequences for property owners in appeal hearings, according to the complaint.
As one example, it cited a property that sold for $258,940 and was appealed by the school district. With a common level ratio of 77.23%, the assessed value is $200,000, the number at which the real estate would be taxed. But at 87.5%, it is $226,573.
“The bottom line is that the property owner of this recently purchased average property pays 13.28% more in annual real estate tax for his property than the vast majority of property owners of un-appealed property,” the lawsuit stated.
“This results in the county, the school district, and municipal governments receiving increased revenues from the artificially overstated assessments of the appealed properties without increasing millage.”
In an area like Marshall Township, where properties are appreciating in value higher than average, a school district appeal of a sold property using an inflated common level ratio “causes a rate of taxation of more than 25% of what his neighbors pay on the same street for homes of the same size and value that have not recently sold,” the lawsuit contends.
But in parts of the county where properties are decreasing in value or where there’s no appreciation, homeowners are overpaying their fair share in taxes, it argued.
“Right now, the tax system is terribly regressive in areas where there has been no appreciation,” Mr. Silvestri said.
To support the contention the county is selectively coding sales, Mr. Silvestri, a former assessment board solicitor, analyzed the 2020 sales information submitted to the state tax equalization board.
He found of 34,563 sales reported, only 5,355, or 15.49%, were coded as valid for the purpose of calculating the common level ratio, according to the complaint.
“Said otherwise, the county determined that about 85% of 2020 sales were not valid sales,” the lawsuit stated.
It also maintains some of those dubbed as valid should have been labeled as “family transfers,” “financial institutions,” or other codes that would not have allowed their use.
But those transactions, according to the lawsuit, also had assessed values closer to the sales price.
At the same time, the complaint asserted, the review found many of the sales the county labeled as rejected should have been coded as valid.
“These sales were noticed as having low property ratios,” the lawsuit claimed, meaning wider disparities between sales price and assessed value.
The lawsuit asked a judge to require the county to employ a chief assessment officer with the professional qualifications outlined in the county administrative code to oversee the resubmission of sales data to the state for 2019 and 2020 and for the common level ratio to be recalculated for use in appeals this year and next.
It also requested the board of property assessment appeals and review be prevented from rendering decisions until the common level ratio has been correctly calculated.
In addition, it urged the court to force the county to “reform its real property assessing practices that cause property owners who recently purchase property to pay more than their fair share of real estate taxes.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.