Allegheny County property owners who just bought their dream homes might detest the appeals filed by school districts and municipalities challenging their assessments. But a judge has ruled that the practice is perfectly legal, if not neighborly.
In a 32-page opinion and order, Common Pleas Judge Robert J. Colville dismissed a lawsuit filed last year claiming the practice amounted to “de facto spot assessments” and violated the uniformity clause of the state constitution.
Judge Colville maintained that such appeals did neither — and may in fact help to make the system fairer.
In doing so, he not only upheld the right of taxing bodies to file such appeals on recently sold properties but invalidated sections of the county’s administrative code and board of property assessment appeals and review rules that limit such actions.
Allowing property owners to appeal based on current market value following a sale but prohibiting school districts and municipalities from doing the same would, “in a material respect, upend fundamental notions of justice and fair play in our court system,” the judge wrote in his ruling last month.
“If the plaintiffs are correct, and this system, as presently employed, creates any degree of non-uniformity, the solution is not to declare that only one side to a legal dispute maintains appellate rights, and thereby impose a procedural lack of uniformity on top of a purportedly existing substantive lack of uniformity,” he stated.
Read More
Ira Weiss, solicitor for the Pittsburgh Public Schools, a defendant in the lawsuit, hailed the decision.
“It affirms what our position has been: There is this fiction out there that’s perpetuated by any number of people, including writers to your paper, that there is something wrong with taxing body appeals,” he said. “Taxing bodies have the right to do this and there is nothing illegal about it. There’s nothing really unfair about it.”
He argued that not appealing recently sold properties that are obviously under-assessed only serves to increase the tax burden on other property owners.
Edward Friedman, the attorney behind the lawsuit, has already appealed Judge Colville’s ruling to Commonwealth Court. He said he’s prepared to take his battle all the way to the state Supreme Court if necessary.
“We don’t believe that what has been called the ‘welcome stranger’ approach of all county school districts is proper or legal. In effect, if you move into Allegheny County and buy a house, your assessment gets increased while no one else gets an increased assessment,” he said.
The lawsuit was filed on behalf of a Squirrel Hill couple who saw the assessment on their Darlington Road home jump from $464,700 to $690,000 after buying it for $750,000 in 2015. The increase was the result of a school district appeal.
In his complaint, Mr. Friedman argued that the lack of a regular cycle for assessing property created illegal “de facto spot reassessments” that penalized those who recently purchased homes, while leaving unsold properties undisturbed.
The lawsuit also maintained that the county’s administrative code prohibited an increase in the base year value of a property founded, in part or in whole, upon a sale in a year subsequent to the established base year.
Since 2012, when the last countywide reassessment took place, the county has been operating on a base year system for assessing real estate.
But in his decision, Judge Colville found that the administrative code provision and a similar rule at the assessment board level violated the General County Assessment law, which allows taxing body appeals, and the Second Class County Charter law.
Amie Downs, spokeswoman for county Executive Rich Fitzgerald, declined comment because the case is under appeal.
In addressing uniformity, Judge Colville concluded that the decision to single out recently sold properties for appeal cannot be described as “improperly motivated or targeted.”
“The taxing bodies are simply taking appeals where there exists readily available evidence to prove their case. The taxing bodies are not unfairly focusing on, or targeting, a particular class or type of property owner,” he wrote.
And the fact that owners of recently sold properties that are appealed may pay higher taxes than those with similar real estate that hasn’t sold “does not mean that owners of recently sold properties are paying taxes that are too high; but, rather, only that owners of not-recently-sold properties may be paying taxes that are too low.”
Appealing an assessed value on the basis of a recent sale, “far from creating a lack of uniformity, tends, rather, to drive the system closer to uniformity — if the goal is that the uniformity coalesce around appropriate and accurate property tax valuations,” Judge Colville added.
But Mr. Friedman intends to challenge such logic in his appeal.
“We believe the Supreme Court has already spoken on this issue and that so-called spot appeals by school districts do not increase uniformity but rather do the opposite,” he said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.