A facade easement on a key building could complicate plans for the mystery buyer who appears to be assembling property for a new development on Downtown’s Wood Street.

The 2013 preservation easement attached to the Fifth-Wood building at the corner of Fifth Avenue and Wood prevents the facade from being demolished or altered — unless the owner or a successor repays hundreds of thousands of dollars in state money used to restore it.

And if someone doing a development on Wood doesn’t want to pony up to remove the facade, the only other choice, it appears, would be to incorporate it into the design.

Recent transactions on the block involving buyers using fictitious names have sparked speculation that some type of project could be in the works in the block across from the Tower at PNC Plaza.

Advertise with us

A buyer using the name Driver Developers LLC paid $2.76 million to buy a vacant four-story building at 439 Wood in February. In April, an entity called Bridges Real Estate Investors LLC acquired a building at 433 Wood, home of Mamma Lucia’s Pizzeria, for $1.35 million.

In addition, it appears that a building at 443 Wood is under agreement to be sold, given that the first floor retailer, Ninja Electronics, has been told to vacate.

The common link in the recent deals is Gregg Broujos, regional principal of the Colliers International real estate firm Downtown. He served as the broker in the two sales and appears to be involved in the other.

He has declined to comment.

For anyone seeking to assemble property in the block for a development, a critical piece would be the Fifth-Wood Building, home to Kashi Jewelers. The structure fronts on Wood and wraps around the corner onto Fifth.

Advertise with us

The building’s facade was one of 11, most of them in the Wood corridor, restored in 2015 with the help of a $4 million state redevelopment assistance capital grant.

As part of the deal, the owners, David Kashi and other family members, agreed to the preservation easement with the Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority.

While the agreement, which runs for 20 years, does not outright prevent the facade from being razed, it would require the owners or a successor, such as someone who buys the property, to repay the “percentage of the costs of renovation” based on a sliding scale.

According to an exhibit accompanying the easement, the building’s facade improvements were valued at $760,086.

Anyone seeking to tear down or alter the face up until Dec. 31, 2022, would have to repay the full amount in order to do so. After that, the total amount to be reimbursed drops each year, from $684,078 in 2023 to $0 on Jan. 1, 2032.

Advertise with us

That means anybody looking to buy the building with the intent to demolish it for a new development could be facing expenses of up to $760,086 in addition to the cost of acquiring the real estate.

Of course, the other option would be to preserve the facade as part of any new development.

In a recent interview, David Kashi said he had been approached by someone earlier this year who asked him whether he was interested in selling.

The inquiry went nowhere, according to Mr. Kashi, adding that he had not received a formal offer. At the time, he noted that he would be willing to sell for the “right price.”

The Fifth-Wood building isn’t the only one in the block to have a facade restored with the help of the state money.

Advertise with us

At the corner for Wood and Forbes, the Skinny and former John M. Roberts and Co. buildings, both of which are owned by the URA, also received the same treatment.

But unlike the building at the other end of the block, there are no preservation easements attached to those structures, according to the URA.

“To our knowledge, no other deed restrictions or covenants exist,” said Nathan Clark, URA chief legal counsel, in a statement.

Nonetheless, the authority, he added, “has the right to put restrictions on future building alterations through our conveyance process.”

“We understand the historical value of the buildings and seek to preserve that into the future,” he said.

Advertise with us

The URA has refused to say whether the buildings have been sold or whether it has been approached by anyone seeking to buy them — an indication perhaps that a deal could be in the works.

Both buildings have some historic value that could increase pressure to keep at least the facades.

The Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation said it wanted “to see the buildings and their facades preserved.”

Some enthusiasts consider the Skinny Building, with a frame measuring a mere 5 feet 2 inches wide and 80 feet long, the world’s thinnest building.

Dating back to 1926, the three-story structure has been used over the years as a lunch counter, a produce stand, a cookie shop, a jewelry store, a hair salon, and a space to hustle T-shirts, hats and other items.

Advertise with us

As part of its restoration, the building received a new tin roof and was repainted with its architectural details restored.

The vacant Roberts Building is its more classic companion. Three elegant Greek columns grace the facade. As part of the rehab, the face was repointed and cleaned and the building’s canopy returned to its original state.

While no one knows who is behind the recent purchases on Wood, many of those in the real estate community believe it’s PNC Financial Services Group.

Eleven years ago, the bank employed a similar method using fictitious names and paying higher-than-market rates to acquire seven properties on the other side of Wood needed to build the Tower at PNC Plaza, its headquarters.

A PNC spokeswoman had no comment recently when asked if the bank was behind the latest acquisitions across the street.

Advertise with us

In the construction of the new headquarters, PNC preserved much of the facade of a building at the corner of Forbes and Wood it demolished to make way for the skyscraper.

PHLF had described the old building as “one of the finest examples in Pittsburgh of the Beaux-Arts style.”

PNC incorporated some artifacts from the building into its new headquarters “where we could, and where it made sense,” spokeswoman Marcey Zwiebel said.

“For example, some artifacts were incorporated into pieces of artwork that are displayed within the building,” she said in an email. “Some larger pieces were incorporated into the design of some common areas, such as the employee cafeteria.”

To do any sizable new development on Wood, a developer likely would also need the CVS property that sits directly behind the buildings on the street.

Advertise with us

The upper two floors of the building, which runs the length of the block between Fifth and Forbes, have been marketed for sale for quite some time by Aegis Realty Partners. A broker stated he had no comment based on company policy.

CVS occupies the first floor of the building. An email seeking comment was not returned.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.