At one time, the Strip District’s historic produce terminal mixed apples and oranges. Now it’s preparing to whip up an even more unlikely combination — books and ice cream.

New York-based Posman Books, an independent, family-owned bookseller, has signed a lease to open a 3,243-square-foot space in the rehabbed Strip landmark on Smallman Street.

The store will be Posman’s first in both Pittsburgh and in Pennsylvania, joining two each in the Big Apple and Atlanta and another opening in Boston on Friday.

And in the Steel City, Posman is eschewing the traditional bookstore pairing of literature and coffee for a more daring combination — prose and ice cream.

Advertise with us

It’s teaming with New York-based OddFellows Ice Cream Co., co-owned by chef Sam Mason, to add flavor to a visit, making it possible to browse for Hemingway while munching on Rocky Road.

“We feel the unusual combination of a bookstore with an ice cream store is a winner. To my knowledge, it has not been done before,” said Robert Fader, Posman vice president. “Who doesn’t love ice cream and books?”

Posman settled on Pittsburgh as its fourth city because it liked the vibe of the $62.6 million terminal rehab and the town itself.

“Pittsburgh really appealed to us as a city that we feel has the right balance between the college population and the tech companies that are moving in or have moved in,” he said.

Mr. Fader said Posman’s Chelsea Market store in New York has Google as its landlord.

Advertise with us

“We understand the Googlers. The Googlers are our customers. We feel that it is the same kind of demographic in Pittsburgh,” he said.

The store will feature books and one-of-a-kind items, including a selection of Japanese gifts that Mr. Fader said seems to resonate with tourists in New York. He also is planning to work with Bloomfield-based Sapling Press to stock some of its items.

On the book side, Posman tends to lean toward the classics, with a table devoted to such literature. There also will be a “good selection of what’s new right now” and lots of books for kids.

Mr. Fader said Posman doesn’t try to offer every book available, adding “we’re pretty unapologetic about our selection.”

“We have become more comfortable with the idea that you can’t stock everything,” he said.

Advertise with us

For those who favor ice cream over Dostoevsky, OddFellows boasts on its website of concocting more than 500 “wacky and weird flavors alongside reimagined and improved classics” since its opening in 2013.

An online menu includes such creations as Apple Cider Donut, Caramel Chocolate Truffle, ExoticFruits sorbet, and Thai Tea & Lemongrass.

Posman will become the sixth tenant in the 1,533-foot-long produce terminal, the former longtime hub of fruit and vegetable wholesalers.

It joins a Fine Wine & Good Spirits Premium Collection store operated by the state Liquor Control Board, City Grows, OnPar Now, Envy Nail Spa, and a Walk Run Lift studio.

With the latest addition, Chicago-based McCaffery Interests, the developer behind the terminal conversion, is inching toward having half the warehouse leased — no small feat given the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on retail and restaurants.

Advertise with us

Dan McCaffery, CEO of McCaffery Interests, said he is in discussions with other possible tenants but declined to name them. He noted he is looking to add things like restaurants, a coffee shop, and a pharmacy to the mix.

He also wants tenants that will appeal to the young and old alike while encouraging additional development.

“It’s a community hub. It’s not a regional mall,” Mr. McCaffery said of the terminal. “It’s not intended to be a big entertainment complex.”

The developer also had discussions with GNC about moving its headquarters from Downtown to the east end of the terminal, which McCaffery is marketing for office space.

But that didn’t pan out. The global vitamins and supplements company is looking for a new home in the Pittsburgh region.

Advertise with us

“We probably didn’t have enough space for them,” Mr. McCaffery said.

Posman, meanwhile, is hoping to open its Strip District store in the 2021 fourth quarter. It got its start 60 years ago as a college bookstore before converting to a traditional bookseller 35 years ago. Its first store was in New York’s Grand Central Terminal.

Its goal is to make every visit “as good as it can be, as surprising as it can be, and as unusual as it can be,” Mr. Fader said.

“You’ll find something that will surprise you or make you happy,” he pledged.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.